Justice S. Sarkar Justice P.S. Chatterjee Calcutta HC MATTER REMANDED Building dispute sent to grampanchayat
[ Calcutta High Court ]

Calcutta HC: no post facto sanction under Panchayat Act, so gram panchayat must probe building

A Division Bench said the writ court was wrong to send an unauthorised construction complaint to the civil court. It ordered the gram panchayat to inspect the site, hear both sides and decide within three months whether the building came before or after sanction.

A writ petitioner said a building had gone up without any permission from the gram panchayat. The private owners answered that sanction had been granted in 2024. The Single Judge was told this, took the view that the dispute raised disputed questions, and sent the petitioner to the civil court.

On 17 November the Calcutta High Court held that this missed the complaint. A Division Bench of Justice Shampa Sarkar and Justice Partha Sarathi Chatterjee allowed Samir Ali Pathan’s appeal and sent the dispute back to the gram panchayat, with a three-month deadline.

Sanction in 2024, construction before it

Mr Pathan, the writ petitioner, alleged unauthorised construction by two private respondents, numbers 8 and 9. The Single Judge was told that a building sanction had been granted to them in 2024.

The Division Bench said the Single Judge was misdirected by that submission. The petitioner’s specific case was that the construction was made without permission, not that the 2024 sanction was defective.

He had relied on several documents, including orders of the Executive Magistrate. Those orders recorded that construction was going on and that complaints had been filed before the gram panchayat.

The question the Single Judge did not answer

The Bench said the issue was whether, even if the private parties got sanction in 2024, the court could accept that

“a post facto sanction could be allowed and the construction which was made prior to the alleged sanction could be sustained” (para 6)

The Single Judge had instead taken the view that the matter involved disputed questions, so the civil court should be approached. The Division Bench did not agree.

Why the civil court was the wrong forum

First, the Bench held that the Single Judge failed to appreciate that a civil court has no jurisdiction to decide the issue of unauthorised construction. Second, it said the West Bengal Panchayat Act, 1973 does not make any provision for post facto sanction.

Third, any construction without permission from the panchayat authorities is contrary to law. It should be demolished in accordance with Section 23(5) of the Act.

Fourth, it is the gram panchayat that has to decide whether the construction was made before or after sanction. It must also decide what exactly the sanction was, compared with the construction actually made.

Disposed of despite the absence of owners

Mr Tanmay Chowdhury, Ms Ritoprita Ghosh and Ms Sulagna Sarkar appeared for the appellant. The Bench took on record an affidavit of service filed in court.

Despite service, nobody appeared for the respondents. The two private respondents had been served with copies of the appeal and the application but were absent.

The Bench said it would still dispose of the appeal because it was not passing any order adverse to the two private respondents. It relegated the matter to the gram panchayat and the appropriate authority.

Eight steps the gram panchayat must follow

The gram panchayat must hold an inspection of the premises in the presence of both parties. It must prepare a report and supply it to them, and they are free to respond to it.

Both parties must be allowed to lead oral and documentary evidence on their contentions. The gram panchayat will then decide whether the construction was illegal or unauthorised, made before the sanction or made after it was granted.

It must pass a reasoned order and inform the parties. A copy of the resolution by which sanction was allegedly given to the two private respondents must also be given to the parties.

If the construction is found to have been made without sanction, or before sanction, the gram panchayat will forward all documents and its decision to the Sub-Divisional Officer concerned. The officer must then take appropriate steps in accordance with law, which shall include demolition.

Order

The appeal, FMA 1011 of 2026, and the connected application, CAN 1 of 2026, are disposed of. The gram panchayat must complete the entire exercise within three months from the date the order is communicated to it.

The Bench directed that an urgent photostat certified copy of the order be given to the parties on compliance with the necessary formalities.