Justice S.K. Sharma Delhi HC MATTER REMANDED A consumer regulator must saywhy a complaint is individual
[ Delhi High Court ]

CUET guide complaint was brushed off as individual: Delhi HC tells CCPA to give reasons

Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma set aside a one-line reply to a complaint that exam books were sold as per the latest syllabus before NTA released it, and ordered a fresh reasoned decision within two months.

Books for the CUET (UG) 2025 entrance were on sale carrying the line “Strictly as per the latest examination pattern and syllabus”, before the National Testing Agency had released the syllabus and pattern. A buyer complained to the Central Consumer Protection Authority.

The Authority answered that his grievance was of an individual nature and sent him to the National Consumer Helpline. On 19 November, the Delhi High Court held that it had to explain why, and sent the complaint back.

A complaint, a helpline and two forums

Rupesh Kumar Jha bought books published by Oswaal Books and Learning Private Limited on 10 February 2025. The covers said they were for the 2025 exam, strictly as per the latest pattern and syllabus, and a bestseller.

He said they were on sale before the NTA released the syllabus and exam pattern for CUET (UG) 2025. He sent a legal notice on 1 May 2025 and complained to the Authority on 5 May 2025 under Sections 17 and 19 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.

Oswaal replied on 2 June 2025 denying liability. With no decision from the Authority, he filed a writ petition on 5 August 2025.

On 24 September 2025, an Under Secretary of the Authority wrote that his grievance was of an individual nature. It had been forwarded to the National Consumer Helpline, and he could also file a case before a consumer commission, the letter said, so no action lay on the part of the Authority.

The detour to the NCDRC

The High Court on 25 March 2026 disposed of his first petition because an alternative remedy existed, leaving the question of the Under Secretary’s competence to the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission.

He appealed there. On 8 May 2026 the Commission held that the letter was an action under Section 19, that Section 24 allows an appeal only against orders under Sections 20 and 21, and that it had no jurisdiction. It did not examine the merits.

He returned to the High Court with the present petition.

What each side argued

Appearing in person, Mr Jha argued that books sold to students across the country for a national examination were not an individual matter. He said the Authority had to examine the complaint under Sections 18 and 19.

He also argued that only the Chief Commissioner and Commissioners could decide such complaints, not an Under Secretary, since Section 14 allows delegation only of administrative matters.

He relied on Dhondu Narayan Chowdhary and Kranti Associates.

Counsel for the Authority, led by Avshreya Pratap Singh Rudy, said the grievance was individual and Section 19 does not mandate an investigation in every case. The letter, she said, was issued on behalf of the Authority, and the signature of an Under Secretary did not make it void.

Individual or class: say why

Justice Sharma framed the question as whether the Authority was justified in disposing of the complaint in this way, given the allegation of misleading advertising for books aimed at students preparing for a national entrance test.

The letter, she held, did not examine the grievance in any detail. It called the grievance individual but did not say why, and did not consider the nature of the claims, how the books were marketed, the national examination or the possibility that other students were affected.

The difference between an individual grievance and a matter affecting consumers as a class is material to the Authority’s functions, she said. A complaint started by one consumer is not individual in nature for that reason alone.

The Authority had to look at the substance and record, at least briefly, why it concluded that the matter was outside its purview.

“Must disclose adequate reasons, even if brief” (para 17)

She added that the Authority may well conclude, after considering the complaint, that no proceedings are warranted. The court expressed no opinion on that, but any such conclusion must follow from the complaint and the statute.

Order

The High Court set aside the communication of 24 September 2025 and remitted the complaint of 5 May 2025 to the Authority for fresh consideration in accordance with law.

The Authority must also consider the petitioner’s objection that the officer dealing with the complaint is not competent, and the complaint must be dealt with by the competent authority. A fresh reasoned order is to be passed within two months of receiving the judgment.

If he is aggrieved by the new order, Mr Jha may use remedies in law. The court expressed no view on whether the books amount to misleading advertisement or an unfair trade practice, or whether any investigation is warranted.