Justice K.R. Mohapatra Justice S. Sharma Chhattisgarh HC APPEAL DISMISSED Compassionate job claim fails
[ Chhattisgarh High Court ]

Chhattisgarh HC: fatherless at 28 days, he sought compassionate job seven years after majority

Chief Justice Krushna Ram Mohapatra and Justice Santosh Sharma dismissed a writ appeal by a teacher’s son who applied in 2018 for the post of Assistant Grade-III, holding that he lost the right by not applying after attaining majority in 2011.

Virendra Kumar Rathiya was 28 days old when his father, an Upper Division Teacher in Bilaspur, died in service on 21 August 1993. He reached the age of majority in 2011 but applied for a compassionate appointment only in 2018. On 16 November the Chhattisgarh High Court held that he had lost the right to ask for one.

A Division Bench of Chief Justice Krushna Ram Mohapatra and Justice Santosh Sharma dismissed his writ appeal. The order was written by the Chief Justice.

Father died in 1993, application came in 2018

The appellant’s father worked under the District Education Officer, Bilaspur. After his death, the mother applied for compassionate appointment and asked that one post be kept vacant until her son came of age.

The State told the court she was not eligible, as she lacked the required educational qualification. The appellant attained majority in 2011 and made no application then.

His application came in 2018. By a letter of 2 July 2018 the State rejected it, saying no vacant post of Assistant Grade-III, to which he could be appointed, was available on that date.

He challenged the rejection in WP(S) 2335/2021. On 8 July 2026 the Single Judge dismissed the petition because the application came after a delay of seven years. The Single Judge held that he had no vested right to appointment under the policy after so long.

Delay of 31 days condoned first

The writ appeal was itself 31 days late. Mr K P Sahu, for the appellant, said he was a poor and rustic villager in a remote part of the State, who first had to arrange the money and then contact his lawyer.

Ms Anuja Sharma, Deputy Government Advocate, objected that the application gave no particulars and did not say when the money was arranged. The Bench took note of the submission that the appellant was a poor villager in a remote area, condoned the delay and heard the appeal on merits at the parties’ request.

Ten per cent of posts kept vacant

Mr Sahu relied on the State policy of 10 June 1994. He said a post should have been kept vacant until the appellant became an adult, and that 10 per cent of Assistant Grade-III posts were meant for compassionate appointment.

He also cited Digeshwar v. State of Chhattisgarh, WP(S) 4136/2012, in which the High Court directed the State to consider the claim of a similarly situated dependant. The State, he argued, had acted illegally, and the Single Judge had failed to appreciate that.

Ms Sharma answered that the post was kept vacant until the appellant reached majority. After that, she said, he had no subsisting right, particularly after more than seven years, and the rejection of 2018 was right.

She noted that the Single Judge had relied on the Supreme Court’s decision in State of Maharashtra v. Ms Madhuri Maruti Vidhate, AIROnline 2022 SC 471. The Single Judge had also held that the family survived 25 years after the death without a compassionate appointment.

Why seven years of silence mattered

The Bench began with the purpose of the scheme. The father died in 1993, and the appellant came of age in 2011. He should have applied immediately, the court said, when the family was allegedly in distress.

The court held that the family had survived for more than seven years after the right to apply accrued to him. Having failed to use that opportunity, it said, he lost the right to seek the appointment.

The Bench said compassionate appointment exists:

“to save the bereaved family of a Government employee from distress” (para 16)

The law is well settled on that, it added. The court recorded that the appellant, “for reasons best known to him”, did not apply within a reasonable time.

Vacant posts did not help him

The Bench accepted that 10 per cent of Assistant Grade-III posts might have been lying vacant. That did not give him a claim, because the delay was his own, and the right to such posts could not be claimed whenever he chose.

It also took up the appellant’s own submission that he did not acquire the required qualification until 2018. He applied only after that, the Bench noted. The authority could not have waited for him to acquire it.

The court agreed with the Single Judge on the reasoning and the authorities. It called the impugned order well-reasoned and supported by Supreme Court decisions, and saw no infirmity in it.

Order

The delay of 31 days in filing the writ appeal, covered by IA 01/2026, is condoned, and the application is disposed of.

The writ appeal, being devoid of merit, is dismissed. The order of the Single Judge of 8 July 2026 in WP(S) 2335/2021 stands. The Bench passed the order on 16 November 2026.