Delhi HC makes fraud complainant return Rs 19.57 lakh released from the wrong company account
Justice Sanjeev Narula set aside a magistrate release order only to that extent after bank records showed a business payment had been wrongly tagged to an investment-fraud complaint, and directed restoration within six weeks.
Two bank transfer references differed by a single digit, and a company lost Rs 19,57,212 from its account. A magistrate had directed the money to be released to the complainant in an investment-fraud case, and the bank debited it on 22 October 2025.
On 17 November the Delhi High Court held that the release could not stand. Justice Sanjeev Narula ordered the complainant to put the amount back within six weeks.
A flagged payment and a release order
The case began with FIR 97/2025 at the Special Cell police station in Delhi, on a complaint of an investment fraud of about Rs 2.14 crore. Transactions were flagged on the National Cybercrime Reporting Portal, and the corresponding amounts were put on hold in various bank accounts.
One was Rs 19,57,212 in the HDFC Bank account of Greenlam Industries Limited. The complainant asked the magistrate to release the held amounts.
The investigating officer’s report of 12 October 2025 said the flagged transactions were yet to be verified. It still gave no objection to release and suggested an indemnity bond from the complainant.
On 14 October 2025 the Judicial Magistrate First Class at Patiala House Courts directed release, on the premise that the amounts were traceable to the complainant. Greenlam was not given notice, and HDFC Bank debited its account on 22 October 2025.
Greenlam’s trail of invoices
Greenlam said the money was a trade payment from Bisnu Chem India, with which it dealt in duty free import authorisations for kraft paper. Under a rate contract of 14 April 2025, it raised a pro forma invoice of Rs 29,60,172 on 30 September 2025.
After adjusting a Rs 10,00,000 advance paid on 23 April 2025 and Rs 2,960 of tax deducted at source, Bisnu Chem sent the balance of Rs 19,57,212 by RTGS on 30 September 2025. Greenlam filed the contract, payment advices and emails, and HDFC Bank confirmed on 16 March 2026 that Bisnu Chem was the remitter.
Greenlam then asked the magistrate to let it intervene and restore the money. The investigating officer’s report of 15 February 2026 said the portal data showed the amount credited from the complainant’s AU Small Finance Bank account, but his statement showed no matching debit. The source and trail, the report said, remained to be verified.
On 15 April 2026 a second magistrate dismissed Greenlam’s application on a technical ground. Since the money had moved on a judicial order, he held, restoring it would amount to review of that order.
Greenlam moved the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution and Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. Mr Divij Kumar appeared for it, Mr Yudhvir Singh Chauhan, Additional Public Prosecutor, for the State and Ms Aayushi Gupta for the complainant.
Two payments, one digit apart
The court called for more from the police and the banks. The State filed a status report on 2 September 2026, and AU Small Finance Bank filed an affidavit on 17 September 2026.
The complainant’s own bank statement showed two transfers of Rs 10,00,000 each on 30 September 2025, to VJ Enterprises and Kaziji Impex Private Limited. None went to Greenlam.
The payment to Greenlam came from Bisnu Chem’s account, and both companies’ records show it. Its transaction reference ends in 9966, while the complainant’s transfer to Kaziji Impex ends in 9962, a resemblance the investigating agency itself noticed.
AU Small Finance Bank said in its affidavit that the Greenlam payment was wrongly tagged to the complainant’s complaint because of a technical error in its interface with the portal. It said it corrected the entry on 8 October 2025, and wrote to HDFC Bank and the investigators about the error on 7 November 2025.
The investigating officer’s report of 12 October 2025, the court noted, does not show that correction and still follows the earlier mapping.
An order that could not stand
The court found that the banking records establish that Bisnu Chem remitted the money, in line with the papers on the two companies’ dealings. Nothing placed before it showed any independent link between that payment and the funds the complainant had lost.
The release order of 14 October 2025, it said, proceeded on a premise that the investigating officer had himself described as unverified. Greenlam was not heard before its money was ordered out of its account, and the order could not be sustained to that extent.
Restitution, not a fresh suit
The court framed what followed as a question:
“The question that follows is whether the Petitioner should be granted restitution in these proceedings or relegated to an independent remedy for recovery of the amount.” (para 15)
It noted that Section 503 of the BNSS allows delivery of seized property to the person entitled to it.
It drew on a Karnataka High Court decision, Sri Rahul Chari v State of Karnataka, which set aside a transfer from a third party’s account to a cyber-fraud complainant made without hearing the account holder, and ordered the amount restored.
It also relied on the Supreme Court in South Eastern Coalfields v State of MP. There, the Supreme Court said the principle of restitution puts a party back where it would have been had the prejudicial order not been passed, and that it is not confined to Section 144 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
The complainant had received the money on a judicial order, and no wrongdoing was attributed to him for seeking it. That did not let him keep what verification had shown was wrongly taken from Greenlam, the court said, and merely setting the order aside would not remedy the loss.
“The appropriate course is to direct restoration of the amount” (para 17)
The record also holds an indemnity bond the complainant signed on 18 October 2025, which envisaged recourse against him to recover the amount. As for the second magistrate’s view that restoration would be a review, the court said that did not stop it from using its supervisory power to set aside the erroneous disbursement and direct restitution.
Order
The release order of 14 October 2025 is set aside only to the extent it authorised release of Rs 19,57,212 from Greenlam’s account. The other disbursements under it are not disturbed, and the order of 15 April 2026 dismissing Greenlam’s application is also set aside.
The complainant must restore Rs 19,57,212 by electronic transfer to Greenlam’s HDFC Bank account within six weeks. He must file proof of remittance before the trial court within one week after that.
His undertaking of 2 September 2026 about his interest in a Sonipat property stays operative until he repays, subject to the rights of the co-owner and the secured creditor. It will be discharged once full repayment is confirmed.
If he does not comply, Greenlam may seek enforcement and pursue other remedies in law. The court did not decide the liability of the banks or the investigating agency, and Greenlam may pursue them subject to adjusting any amount recovered.