Delhi HC finds strong case on Rs 38.9 crore deposits, yet refuses post-award protection
Justice Tushar Rao Gedela held that Kimti Lall Jain had shown a strong prima facie case, balance of convenience and likely irreparable injury, but not the rare and compelling circumstances the Supreme Court requires from an unsuccessful party.
The Delhi High Court held on 18 November that a businessman was entitled to an interim order, and then declined to pass one. Kimti Lall Jain had asked it to secure four deposits, worth Rs 38.9 crore, that third parties had made in court.
Justice Tushar Rao Gedela found a strong prima facie case, a balance of convenience in his favour and a likely irreparable injury. He still held that Mr Jain, who lost his main claim in arbitration, had not shown the rare and compelling case the Supreme Court demands after an award.
A share sale and old receivables
Mr Jain and his family were the promoters of Driplex Water Engineering Private Limited and Driplex Water Engineering International Private Limited. In December 2015 they agreed to sell the two companies to the Suez Group of France, through its Indian companies.
Shares were to move in two tranches. The first, 76 per cent, passed on 1 March 2016 for Rs 122,02,82,200, and the second, 24 per cent, on 1 March 2019, when Rs 68,75,54,198 was paid.
Some old receivables, called Past Retention Money (PRM), had not been recovered by 1 March 2019. The parties signed a Supplementary Framework Agreement that day. Mr Jain was to chase the recovery for four years and one month, and the recovered sums were to be shared between him and the company.
The agreement set the sharing ratio at 70:30 in his favour for recovered book value. A General Agreement of 17 May 2021 followed, and a power of attorney issued on 1 August 2021 expired on 31 March 2023 without renewal.
Awards won, challenged and deposited
While he held the power of attorney, Mr Jain won arbitral awards for the companies in five projects, including those with BHEL, NTPC, NLC and MRPL. The third parties challenged them under Section 34, and in four projects deposited money in court. Those deposits total Rs 38,91,62,075.
He invoked arbitration against the respondents on 27 November 2023. The tribunal passed its final award on 18 April 2026, corrected on 8 June 2026. It rejected his claims 1, 2 and 8 and partly allowed claims 3, 5, 6 and 7.
Claim 1 was his share of the unrecovered PRM, put at Rs 156,46,04,632. He has challenged the rejection of that claim in a Section 34 petition, O.M.P.(COMM) 355/2026, and the present Section 9 petition sought to protect part of it while that case is pending.
What Mr Jain asked for
His main prayer was that the Driplex companies deposit in the High Court registry, in an interest-bearing account, whatever they receive on the four projects. In the alternative, he sought a bank guarantee of not less than Rs 128,79,98,675.
That figure is the value of the funds in court and in a Lucknow district court, with interest to 31 July 2026. He also asked for a restraint on the companies disposing of assets up to Rs 156,46,04,632, and for a bar on the Suez companies diluting their holding.
The respondents were Suez Water Technologies and Solutions, Veolia Water Technologies and Solutions (the name it was later given) and the two Driplex companies. Mr Jain’s senior counsel restricted his argument to the four deposits.
His case: money earned by his own efforts
Mr Arvind Nigam, Senior Advocate, said the Supreme Court’s decision in Home Care Retail Marts v Haresh N Sanghavi (2026 SCC OnLine SC 670) settles that an unsuccessful party can invoke Section 9 after an award. The only question was whether the case was fit for relief.
He argued that PRM forms part of the share price under the agreements, so it is sale consideration and not a top-up payment. The respondents, he said, took 29 months to issue any power of attorney and issued it for only 10 of 18 projects.
The tribunal, he submitted, held the powers valid to 1 August 2023 in one paragraph and found them expired on 31 March 2023 in the next. He said it also gave no finding on who caused the delay.
On the deposits, he said all but one were made before 31 March 2023, so his right had crystallised. He relied on the Driplex companies’ losses and on the fact that two of the respondents are French companies, against whom enforcement would be hard.
He also cited a Bombay High Court ruling in ONGC v Afcons Gunanusa Joint Venture and distinguished ONGC v Swiber Offshore Construction. The merits points, the court recorded, were put in a written note and not argued at length.
The respondents: a rejected claim, no urgency
Mr Jayant Mehta, Senior Advocate, argued that Home Care Retail allows such a petition only in rare and compelling circumstances, and none had been argued. Claim 1 had been rejected, he said, with a finding that the PRM arrangement ended by efflux of time on 31 March 2023.
So Mr Jain had no adjudicated or subsisting right to protect. Even if he won under Section 34, he argued, the most he could get is a fresh arbitration, not Rs 156 crore.
The deposits, he added, were made by third parties as a condition of stay in their own proceedings. Of the claim, Rs 68.40 crore relates to projects whose Section 34 challenges are pending, Rs 8.14 crore to one where the award was set aside on 2 August 2024, and Rs 79.91 crore to projects with no award at all.
He relied on Swiber for the point that a mere apprehension cannot create a legal right. He also said the financial documents all pre-dated the award, that a power of attorney of 25 September 2017 in favour of Mr DD Goyal stayed valid, and that review of an international commercial award is narrow.
The court isolates the unrecovered PRM
The court began with the agreements. It said the core of the petition is the Supplementary Framework Agreement, and that it was concerned only with PRM not recovered by 1 March 2019.
It said it need not decide in detail whether the 49-month period ended on 31 March 2023 or ran 29 months longer. Three deposits were made before that date, and Mr Jain said the fourth, of 22 May 2023, also came from work done earlier.
Whether PRM is part of the sale consideration, whether the respondents breached the agreements and whether the powers of attorney were late, the court said, are for the Section 34 petition. It added that, as the award is an international commercial award, its powers to interfere may be restricted.
Why the deposits count as retention money
The question at this stage, the court said, was whether Mr Jain could seek interim protection over the four deposits. It was not disputed that the money came from his follow-up and efforts.
The respondents had called the deposits top-up payments, but the court found no clause or document to support that. An oral submission, it said, could not stand against agreements the respondents did not deny, and it left the argument out of account.
It concluded that the deposits form PRM. Who ultimately wins the third parties’ Section 34 challenges is a separate matter, it said, but an ascertainable amount had been deposited in respect of the awards Mr Jain secured.
The court also put a hypothetical. Had the Driplex companies sought enforcement under Section 36 and obtained deposits before 31 March 2023, could Mr Jain be denied his share? The court thought he would surely be entitled to it.
Losses the respondents did not dispute
On the financial position, the court noted that Driplex International had twice put two factories up for sale. Driplex Water Engineering showed losses of Rs 30.04 crore, Rs 50.29 crore and Rs 28.58 crore in 2022-23, 2023-24 and 2024-25.
The 2024-25 statements of Driplex International showed no plant, equipment or immovable assets. The respondents said only that the documents pre-dated the award and did not dispute them, so the court took them at face value as showing a precarious condition.
On that basis it held that Mr Jain had shown a strong prima facie case. The balance of convenience, it said, favoured him, and he was likely to suffer irreparable injury without interim orders.
Strong case, but not rare and compelling
The court then turned to Home Care Retail, as applied in its own decision in Thor Ventures v Nyeq Technologies ((2026) SCC OnLine Del 8483). An unsuccessful party carries a higher burden after an award, and relief is possible only in rare and compelling circumstances that prevent irreparable prejudice and preserve the efficacy of the challenge.
Justice Gedela held that no such case had been made out. The circumstances Mr Jain relied on, he said, amounted more to a challenge to the award than to a rare or compelling case.
He accepted that preserving the deposits might be a good ground to some extent. But he held that the challenge under Section 34 remained intact, because Mr Jain had already joined the Driplex companies’ holding companies as respondents. If he wins, the court said, further proceedings and execution can still continue.
On the preservation point, the court said the efficacy of the Section 34 challenge was:
“neither diluted nor compromised” (para 53)
On the entitlement itself, it said:
“the petitioner is indeed entitled to an interim order” (para 54)
It added in the same paragraph that it was unable to grant the order because the standard in Home Care Retail and Thor Ventures was not met.
Order
The interim prayer is denied. The respondents must file their reply within three weeks, and Mr Jain may file a rejoinder before the next date.
The matter will be listed on 14 December 2026 along with the Section 34 petition, O.M.P.(COMM) 355/2026. The court made no order on costs.