Delhi HC lets in-laws evict daughter-in-law but makes them pay up to Rs 35,000 a month in rent
Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma held that the Senior Citizens Act and the Domestic Violence Act must be read together, and rewrote a vague eviction order into a rent-backed relocation that lasts until her right of residence is decided.
A woman who has lived in the same Pitampura house since her marriage in 2008 will have to leave it. Her parents-in-law, aged 70 and 64, will pay up to Rs 35,000 a month towards the rent of a flat she picks, and put six months of rent in advance.
The Delhi High Court said so on 19 November. Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma upheld an eviction ordered under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007, but found its terms too thin to protect the daughter-in-law and her son.
She rewrote them. The in-laws’ support lasts until her right of residence is finally decided in the pending domestic violence and matrimonial cases.
A decade of cases over one house
The petitioner, Namrata Yadav, married Deepesh Yadav on 27 January 2008. They have a son, now in Class XII.
The parents-in-law, Ramesh Kumar Yadav and Kavita Yadav, live on the first floor of the Pitampura house. She lives in a ground-floor portion with her son.
She says her husband left on 10 January 2017, and the in-laws say he moved to rented housing in 2016. He then filed for divorce and custody of the son, and both cases are pending in the Rohini Family Court.
She filed a maintenance case under Section 125 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Interim maintenance of Rs 30,000 a month was fixed on 14 March 2019. She says arrears reached Rs 8,46,000 by July 2026.
On 7 July 2017, one of the in-laws filed a civil suit to evict her, and her husband sought alternate accommodation for her there. The suit is pending.
She complained of cruelty and harassment, and a domestic violence case and an FIR under Sections 498A and 406 of the Indian Penal Code followed. Her son has separately sued, claiming the house is Hindu Undivided Family property in which he holds a share.
What the authorities decided
The parents-in-law applied to the District Magistrate (North-West) on 18 June 2025 under Rule 22 of the Delhi Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Rules, 2009. They cited ill-treatment, harassment and destruction of property.
On 23 December 2025, the District Magistrate refused eviction. After visiting the house, he found separate entrances but a blocked staircase, and ordered both sides to stay in their portions and stop interfering with each other’s water, power and passages.
The Divisional Commissioner allowed the in-laws’ appeal on 6 August 2026. He relied on videos and photographs, held that relations were acrimonious and that continued cohabitation was unworkable, and ordered the daughter-in-law and her son to vacate.
The in-laws were to give “reasonable alternate accommodation” within 15 days, after which she had seven days to leave. The order said it did not decide title. Mediation before the High Court failed on 2 September 2026.
Forum shopping and a disputed title
Senior Advocate Sandeep Sharma, for the daughter-in-law, said eviction in summary proceedings could not decide a disputed title. The conveyance deed of 12 May 2000 was said to derive from a man who died in 1987.
He argued that the in-laws had first sought her removal in a civil suit, then in domestic violence proceedings, and now under the Senior Citizens Act. That, he said, was forum shopping, barred by res judicata and issue estoppel.
He also said the Divisional Commissioner reversed the District Magistrate’s inspection findings on the strength of disputed videos. The authority, he said, effectively evicted her son too, though he was not a party.
Senior Advocate Mohit Mathur, for the in-laws, said the order balanced the daughter-in-law’s residence against their right to live in peace, since she was not being made homeless. He said the building shares a common porch and staircase, so conflict was daily.
He alleged that she disconnected their water and power and smashed CCTV cameras, and that her son smashed a car windscreen.
He also said she and her brother assaulted the mother-in-law and others outside the District Magistrate’s office, which led to a separate FIR and chargesheet. She disputes the incident and says the videos were doctored.
Two statutes, read together
Justice Sharma started with the Senior Citizens Act, a beneficial law giving older people a summary remedy. Rule 22 lets a senior citizen apply for eviction of a son, daughter or legal heir from property on grounds of non-maintenance and ill-treatment.
She noted the Supreme Court’s August 2026 ruling in Ravi Kant Gupta v. State of Uttar Pradesh, which confirmed that the tribunals can order eviction. In Samtola Devi, the Supreme Court said eviction is not mandatory in every case.
On the other side, Section 17 of the Domestic Violence Act gives a woman a right to reside in the shared household and bars her eviction except by due process. Section 19(1)(f) lets a magistrate order the same level of alternate accommodation or payment of rent.
The key authority is S. Vanitha, a three-judge Bench ruling on a Bengaluru dispute. It held that a tribunal may order eviction, but a woman’s right to a shared household cannot be defeated by the summary procedure, so relief should be moulded in composite disputes.
In Satish Chander Ahuja, the Supreme Court said the right to residence is not indefeasible when a daughter-in-law is pitted against aged in-laws.
The judge also cited Vinay Varma and a 2025 Division Bench ruling, Manju Arora.
She summed up four propositions. Eviction is allowed where necessary for the senior citizen’s protection, but not mechanically. A woman’s shared household right cannot be defeated by the summary route, so relief must be moulded.
The fourth proposition was that the right is one to secure residence, not to a particular property.
“A right to secure a residence of an adequate standard” (para 55)
Why the reversal stood
The judge held that the Divisional Commissioner, as a statutory appellate forum, could reappraise the material. The District Magistrate’s own findings showed that the parties share a staircase, porch and terrace, and that access and utilities had been obstructed.
Rival grievances on both sides concerned common areas such as leaking water, CCTV cameras, the porch and a door. That, she said, showed persistent friction despite separate portions.
The matrimonial background did not defeat the in-laws’ claim. The judge cited Geeta Wahal and said senior citizens should not be haunted by their son’s marital discord.
The parents-in-law had lived with it for close to a decade.
She declined to decide the alleged incident outside the District Magistrate’s office, which will be decided in the criminal case. Even leaving it aside, she held, the admitted acrimony, the multiplicity of cases and the blocked staircase supported the conclusion that living together was unworkable.
Title, res judicata and the son
On title, the judge held that an authority under the Senior Citizens Act does not decide ownership. A senior citizen needs only a modicum of right or interest, and the Divisional Commissioner had said his order did not decide title or the HUF claim.
The validity of the 2000 deed will be decided in the son’s civil suit. The allegation of fabrication is in a police case where a closure report has been filed and she intends to protest.
On forum shopping, the judge read the earlier domestic violence orders. The magistrate had dismissed the in-laws’ applications for alternate accommodation because they had no standing to seek it there, and said the proper remedy was an eviction petition.
The Sessions Court said the same. So those orders did not decide the in-laws’ independent right under the Senior Citizens Act, and later incidents were also pleaded. The plea of res judicata and forum shopping failed.
She distinguished S. Vanitha, where the property had been transferred between family members during the dispute and the in-laws did not live there. Here the in-laws lived in the house and complained of daily conflict.
The son’s civil suit had an interim order of 16 May 2026 that stands stayed by an appellate order of 4 July 2026. Proceedings under the Senior Citizens Rules are themselves due process, the judge said, but safeguards for the son were needed.
The order was correct but thin
The judge found the Divisional Commissioner right in principle. But “reasonable alternate accommodation” did not set a standard, a duration, how rent would be paid or what happens on default. Three weeks to move a woman who had lived there since 2008, with a Class XII son, was unjustified.
The daughter-in-law had not answered the in-laws’ notices of 7 and 20 August 2026 asking for her preferred locality and naming a flat. The judge said the right is not to insist on a particular property.
She could not, however, be asked to move to unspecified housing on uncertain terms while depending on interim maintenance. The in-laws had told the court they would contribute up to Rs 35,000 a month for a place of her choosing.
The in-laws’ offer to buy a three-bedroom apartment in her and her son’s name, with permanent alimony and education costs, was a settlement proposal. The judge did not convert it into a direction but left it open to the parties.
Order
The High Court found no jurisdictional error or perversity in the finding that living together had become unworkable. It modified the Divisional Commissioner’s order of 6 August 2026 and issued directions.
Within four weeks the daughter-in-law must identify a home with two bedrooms, a drawing room and a kitchen, preferably in the same or an adjoining locality and near her son’s school. If she fails, the in-laws may offer the flat they have found or a comparable one.
The in-laws will pay rent up to Rs 35,000 a month, plus the security deposit, any brokerage and reasonable shifting costs. Within two weeks of receiving the particulars, they must deposit the first six months of rent, and later rent is due by the 10th of each month.
She and her son must vacate within two weeks of that compliance, with the SDM assisting if needed. The in-laws’ obligation continues until her right of residence is decided in the domestic violence or matrimonial proceedings.
If the in-laws default on rent for two consecutive months, she may approach the Divisional Commissioner, who can order restoration of possession. The arrangement is in addition to, and not adjusted against, her husband’s maintenance, and remains subject to the son’s pending suit and appeal.
Until she moves, both sides must follow the District Magistrate’s directions on the staircase, water and power. The petition was disposed of, and nothing in the judgment expresses a view on the title, the criminal cases or the merits of the matrimonial disputes.