Justice H.V. Shankar Delhi HC APPEAL DISMISSED Goa police chief bungalow staysoff limits to his wife
[ Delhi High Court ]

Delhi HC upholds order barring wife from Goa DGP residence-cum-office and posts about him

Justice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar refused to disturb the Family Court injunction, holding that appellate review of interim discretion is narrow and that she has a settled home in Delhi. The allegations of both sides were left for trial.

An IPS officer posted as Director General of Police, Goa, went to a Delhi family court to keep his wife out of the bungalow he uses as his official residence and camp office. The court agreed, and also barred her from posting incriminating material about him on WhatsApp, YouTube and Instagram.

The Delhi High Court on 18 November dismissed her appeal. Justice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar held that the Family Court’s interim order was a reasonably possible view and not one a court of appeal should replace with its own.

He declined to decide either side’s allegations, including her claim that the officer is involved in an extra-marital relationship, which he said were for trial.

A police chief’s bungalow in Panaji

The appellant, Nishi Singh, and the respondent, Alok Kumar, are married and have children. He has been allotted an official bungalow-cum-camp office in Panaji. He has also been allotted government accommodation near Khan Market in Delhi, where the family once lived and she now lives.

They have lived separately since February 2024. Divorce, domestic violence and maintenance cases are among the proceedings pending between them.

In civil suit CS 02/2026, filed before the Principal Judge, Family Court, at Patiala House, he sought an injunction against harassment and the publication of material about him. He said she arrived at the Goa residence in November 2025 and made allegations of adultery before his drivers, personal security staff and other police officials.

He said the incident was reported to Panjim police and a daily diary entry was made. She said the discord arose from his alleged relationship with another woman, and that she could not be kept out of her matrimonial home merely because he was posted there.

What the Family Court ordered

On 16 April 2026, the Family Court granted the injunction under Order XXXIX Rules 1 and 2 of the Code of Civil Procedure. It restrained her and her relatives from entering the Goa premises. It also restrained her from putting incriminating material against him on social media until the suit is decided.

It reasoned that the head of the Goa police needs a conducive atmosphere to discharge his duties. If he was mentally disturbed by his wife’s behaviour, it said, his output would suffer.

The Family Court relied on Reena Grover, a Delhi High Court ruling, to say a wife with alternative accommodation may not be allowed to re-enter the shared house. It assumed for argument that the Goa house was shared, and said she could not claim re-entry as of right.

It also noted that he had not specifically prayed for an order barring her entry to Goa, but that both sides argued the point at length and the plaint mentioned it.

The arguments in the High Court

Her counsel, Mahavir Singh, said the injunction was a blanket restraint passed without weighing her claim to a shared household. He said the Family Court granted a relief nobody had asked for, ignored her allegations about the third party, and failed to test irreparable injury.

He argued that the officer, as a member of the All India Services, must meet standards of integrity and propriety. He also said the officer was relying on the order to stop the children visiting the Goa house.

For the officer, Mr Awasthi said the Family Court weighed the material and applied the settled test. The premises are his official residence-cum-office, and a conducive environment was needed.

Her allegations, he said, were disputed and belonged to trial.

He said alternate accommodation exists for her in Delhi. The social media restraint was needed to protect him against harassment and damage to his reputation during the suit.

The narrow lane of appellate review

The appeal was filed under Section 104 read with Order XLIII Rule 1(r) of the Code of Civil Procedure. Justice Shankar began with its limits. An appeal from a discretionary interim order, he said, is an appeal on principle.

Relying on Wander Ltd v. Antox India, Mohd Mehtab Khan and a 2024 ruling in Ramakant Ambalal Choksi, he said the appellate court does not substitute its discretion merely because another view is possible. It interferes only where the discretion was exercised arbitrarily, capriciously or perversely, or against settled principles.

The question, he said, was not whether he would have decided differently. It was whether the Family Court could reasonably have reached that conclusion on the material before it.

Why the wife lost

Being husband and wife, and having once used the Goa premises as a family residence, gave her no absolute right to enter in all circumstances. She was not being left without a roof, because she lives in the government accommodation in Delhi that the parties earlier shared.

Her grievance was that the injunction lets the officer continue what she calls a life of adultery. Justice Shankar said those contentions form the core of the matrimonial dispute, and to rule on them now would be to put the cart before the horse.

“It is not her case that she has no shelter” (para 37)

The Goa premises, he held, stand on a distinct footing. They were allotted to him as his official residence-cum-office, and the finding that the head of the state police needs a conducive environment was not an irrelevant consideration.

Even if the house had once been used jointly, the parties have lived apart since February 2024 and have several proceedings and complaints pending. The Family Court could take the present state of affairs into account.

Alternate accommodation and the missing prayer

On Reena Grover, the judge said it was relied on only as one circumstance in the balance of convenience, not for the proposition that a spouse can always be denied access to a matrimonial residence because other housing exists.

The absence of a specific prayer was a point “not without substance” as to how the relief was framed. But the Family Court had recorded the point, both sides argued it, and she had a full chance to oppose, so the order was not passed behind her back.

The Family Court had applied prima facie case, balance of convenience and irreparable injury, tying them to his official position, the nature of the premises, the discord, the November 2025 incident and her alternative housing. It made no final finding on whether the allegations were true.

The same approach applied to the social media restraint, which does not adjudicate the truth of anything. Her status as a wife and the effect on the children did not displace the discretionary order, the judge said, and any question about the children’s rights can be raised in proper proceedings.

Order

The High Court found no failure to exercise jurisdiction, no perversity and no disregard of the settled principles on interim injunctions. It affirmed the Family Court order of 16 April 2026 and dismissed the appeal along with pending applications.

The judge clarified that his observations are confined to the appeal and do not express a view on the matrimonial disputes, including the allegations of an extra-marital relationship. The Family Court will decide those independently.