Justice H.V. Shankar Delhi HC MATTER REMANDED The landlord testimony undercuthis own site plan
[ Delhi High Court ]

Site plan showed rooms and kitchen, landlord said single hall: Delhi HC sends eviction back

Justice Harish Vaidyanathan Shankar set aside the eviction of a Karol Bagh shop tenant on a 2016 petition, holding that the Rent Controller ignored what the landlord himself admitted about his claim of too little space.

The landlords told the Rent Controller they needed a tenanted shop of about 14 square yards to expand their business, because the space they already had was cramped. Their site plan showed two rooms, a kitchen and a tin shed behind the shop.

Cross-examined, one landlord said the property he occupied was “a single hall” with no room or kitchen. On 18 November, the Delhi High Court held that the Rent Controller could not ignore that statement and sent the eviction petition back for a fresh decision.

A shop let at Rs 80 a month

The shop sits at Abdul Rehman Road, Nai Wala, in Karol Bagh. It measures about 14.36 square yards. The landlords said a partnership called Pradeep Automobiles was inducted as tenant at Rs 80 a month, and that the tenancy passed to Suresh Kumar when the firm dissolved.

The landlords, S. Esvinder Singh and another, said they acquired the property in 2003 under a registered agreement to sell dated 21 May 2003. They sought eviction under Section 14(1)(e) read with Section 25-B of the Delhi Rent Control Act, 1958, claiming a bona fide need to expand their business.

The tenant was granted leave to defend on 23 February 2013. After a trial in which both sides examined witnesses, the Additional Rent Controller at Tis Hazari allowed the petition on 24 March 2025. Suresh Kumar had died, and his legal heirs filed the revision petition.

The site plan against the witness

Counsel Amit Vohra argued that the landlords had projected an artificial scarcity of space with an incorrect site plan. It showed separate rooms, a kitchen, a tin shed and a bathroom in the portions they occupied.

He pointed to the cross-examination of the landlord, who said he did not know who prepared the plan and could not say whether it was of his property. He then said there was no room or kitchen in the property he used.

For the landlords, Senior Advocate Sandeep Sharma said a site plan is only a supporting document. The tenant himself identified the tenanted portion, so the identity of the premises was never in doubt. He relied on Neelam Jain and Rajender Kumar Pahuja.

What a revision court can do

Justice Shankar noted that the High Court’s power under the proviso to Section 25-B(8) is revisional and not appellate. He cited Abid-ul-Islam v. Inder Sain Dua for the point that it looks at the decision-making process and does not substitute its own view.

But the Supreme Court has also held that a High Court can step in where material evidence was overlooked or misread.

He referred to the Constitution Bench in Hindustan Petroleum v. Dilbahar Singh and to Mohd Inam v. Sanjay Kumar Singhal.

He said the rule does not allow a wholesale reassessment of evidence, but does allow him to ask whether the Rent Controller dealt with the material evidence bearing on the controversy.

Identity of the premises is not the question

The judge said the dispute was not whether the tenanted shop was correctly identified. It was whether the accommodation shown as available to the landlords matched the site plan, and what that did to their claim of needing more space.

The tenant’s identification of his own portion, he held, is not an admission that the whole plan is right. The two issues cannot be conflated.

He accepted that a site plan is a supporting document and that a minor discrepancy does not defeat an eviction petition. But where the plea is that existing accommodation is too small, the nature of that accommodation is relevant, and a discrepancy with the landlord’s own testimony cannot be brushed aside.

He distinguished Neelam Jain because the tenant there had raised a bald objection with no evidence. In Pahuja, the tenant had admitted the same plan in other eviction cases. Here the challenge came from the landlord’s own witness.

He also relied on a 2025 Delhi ruling in Tek Chand v. Meenakshi Gupta, which sent a case back where a landlady’s contradictory statements about adjoining premises were not examined.

Order

The High Court held that the Additional Rent Controller failed to consider the landlord’s statements in cross-examination and their bearing on the claim of inadequate accommodation. That, it said, amounts to non-consideration of material evidence.

It allowed the revision petition, set aside the judgment of 24 March 2025 and remanded the eviction petition for de novo consideration on the existing record. The Rent Controller was asked to dispose of it preferably within six months.

The judge clarified that he expressed no opinion on whether the landlords’ need is genuine, and that the Rent Controller must examine the pleadings, documents and the admissions in cross-examination. The parties will appear before the Rent Controller on a date fixed by the Registry.