Justice P. Purohit Uttarakhand HC PETITION DISMISSED Lohaghat election stands;petition dismissed
[ Uttarakhand High Court ]

Uttarakhand HC dismisses Lohaghat poll petition: road works not proved a State contract

Justice Pankaj Purohit held that Puran Singh Fartyal could not show a subsisting Section 9-A contract with the State Government, a defective nomination or a false Form 26 affidavit, and dismissed the challenge to Khushal Singh Adhikari.

The man who came second in the 2022 Lohaghat Assembly election has lost his bid to unseat the winner. On 18 November the Uttarakhand High Court dismissed Puran Singh Fartyal’s election petition against Khushal Singh Adhikari, four years and eight months after the result.

Justice Pankaj Purohit found that Mr Fartyal proved neither a disqualifying government contract nor a defective nomination nor a false affidavit. The judgment had been reserved on 28 September 2026.

The petition rested on the claim that Mr Adhikari, a Class-A contractor, still had road works with the State when he filed his papers. The court held that ongoing works, shown through a rural roads agency, were not enough.

Three grounds against the winner

The petition was filed under Sections 80, 80-A and 84 read with Section 100 of the Representation of the People Act, 1951. The result of 54-Lohaghat was declared on 10 March 2022.

Mr Fartyal said Mr Adhikari was disqualified under Section 9-A because contracts for government works subsisted. He also said the nomination was wrongly accepted for non-compliance with Rule 4-A of the Conduct of Elections Rules, 1961.

His third ground was concealment. He said the Form 26 affidavit filed with the nomination papers wrongly marked the entry on contracts, including contracts through a partnership firm, as not applicable.

Four years of preliminary skirmishes

Mr Adhikari filed his nomination on 24 January 2022. He filed a supplementary affidavit on 28 January, before scrutiny, after deficiencies were noticed in the original.

He sought dismissal of the petition under Section 86 of the Act and Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure. The High Court rejected that on 14 July 2022 and framed seven issues on 3 August 2022.

On 2 November 2022 it decided issues 4 to 7, holding that the copy of the petition served on him met Section 81(3) and that certain defects were curable. He took the July order to the Supreme Court, which dismissed his special leave petition on 15 September 2023, and the trial was stayed until then.

On 24 June 2024 the court amended issue 3, on concealment. Issues 1, 2 and 3 were left for decision after evidence.

Who gave evidence

Mr Fartyal examined himself and Ravi Pratap Singh, Chief Engineer of the Uttarakhand Rural Roads Development Agency (URRDA), who spoke of its functioning and the Pradhan Mantri Gram Sadak Yojana (PMGSY) contracts.

Mr Adhikari gave evidence himself, along with Shyam Singh Karki, who spoke to the notarised retirement-cum-amended partnership deed of 10 January 2022. The Returning Officer, Rinku Bisht, also deposed for him.

Mr Adhikari referred to a payment of Rs 99,87,675 relating to PMGSY works. He also relied on documents about the cancellation of his Class-A contractor registration and the reconstitution of his firm.

The petitioner’s timeline

Mr Fartyal’s Senior Advocate said Mr Adhikari held a Class-A registration with the Public Works Department, renewed for 27 July 2019 to 30 June 2022. A partnership deed of 1 January 2022 gave him a 90 percent share in a firm doing PMGSY construction.

Mr Adhikari asked for cancellation of the registration on 8 January 2022, but the order came only on 16 February 2022. Counsel said he was still registered on the scrutiny date of 29 January and on the polling date of 14 February.

On 4 March 2022, after polling, Mr Adhikari asked URRDA to transfer the works to a firm of his sons. An office memorandum of 29 March 2022 did so, which counsel said showed the works stayed with him until then.

On Form 26, counsel said, the omission of his occupation and contracts deprived voters of material information. He also argued that URRDA, with State officers on its body and under State control, is part of the appropriate Government.

The winner’s answer

Piyush Garg, Senior Advocate, appeared for Mr Adhikari. He said his client severed his links as a Class-A contractor before filing nomination, and that the later cancellation order only completed a ministerial step after his letter of 8 January 2022.

URRDA, he said, is a society registered under the Societies Registration Act, 1860, distinct from the State Government. He relied on the Supreme Court in Shrikant v. Vasantrao.

On the affidavit, he said the corrected Form 26 was filed on 28 January, within time, and accepted before scrutiny. Section 36(4) bars rejection for a defect that is not substantial, he added, and Mr Fartyal raised no objection at scrutiny.

What Section 9-A actually requires

Section 9-A disqualifies a person while a contract subsists that he made in the course of his trade or business with the appropriate Government, for supply of goods or execution of works. For a State Assembly seat, the appropriate Government is the State Government under Section 7(a).

The court read the requirements as cumulative, citing Kartar Singh Bhadana v. Hari Singh Nalwa. Each must be established, it said, because the provision takes away a citizen’s right to contest.

It stated the first principle in one line:

“an ongoing government-funded work, by itself, does not attract disqualification” (para 42)

URRDA is not the State Government

The court turned to Shrikant v. Vasantrao, where the Supreme Court distinguished instrumentalities of the State from the State Government itself. An entity does not become the State Government for Section 9-A merely because it is State under Article 12, the High Court said.

Mr Fartyal’s certificates of 14 July 2021 and 14 December 2021 on the Dhyari-Bhanoli road and the Basolikhan-Chamtola motor road showed works were ongoing and extensions sought. They did not, the court said, show who the contracting party was or that Mr Adhikari remained personally bound.

It kept two questions apart. Retirement from a partnership does not by itself show that obligations ended, and continued work by the firm does not by itself show that he remained bound.

On the cancellation of registration, the court said:

“cancellation of registration and subsistence of an individual works contract are distinct matters” (para 53)

Issue 1 went against the petitioner. He had not proved that the State Government itself was the contracting party.

The first affidavit was incomplete, but fixed

On issue 2, the court framed the question as follows:

“What is the effect of non-submission of an affidavit sworn by respondent no.1 before a Magistrate of First Class or Notary in Form 26, while delivering to the Returning Officer nomination papers, as required under Rule 4A of the Rules of 1961?” (para 57)

The Returning Officer, Rinku Bisht, said she noticed deficiencies in columns 7(i) and 9 on preliminary examination. She recorded them in a checklist and asked Mr Adhikari to fix them by 29 January 2022, before scrutiny began.

He filed supplementary affidavits on 28 January at 2.25 pm. In cross-examination she accepted that the affidavits filed with both sets of nomination papers, lodged at 11.26 am and 11.40 am on 24 January, had deficiencies.

The court said the nomination papers were not resubmitted, only the affidavits, so there was no illegality in that. It added that the lack of any objection could not validate a nomination otherwise contrary to law, but formed part of the background.

The Resurgence India test applied

The court quoted Resurgence India v. Election Commission of India, where the Supreme Court said a nomination is fit to be rejected if a candidate fails to fill the blanks even after a reminder. It also noted that the power to reject must be used sparingly.

The decisive question, it said, was whether the deficiencies stayed unrectified. Here they were identified, time to cure was given and supplementary affidavits came in before the deadline.

Mr Fartyal had to show that a material defect persisted or that the Returning Officer acted contrary to law in accepting the papers. He did not, and issue 2 also went against him.

Was the Form 26 entry false?

The court said disclosure in Form 26 serves the voter’s right to know, citing Union of India v. Association for Democratic Reforms. But whether an entry is false depends on what had to be disclosed and what the evidence shows.

It stressed that failing to prove a Section 9-A disqualification does not by itself decide whether the declaration was false. That needed a separate look.

On that look, Mr Fartyal had established ongoing construction works and Mr Adhikari’s earlier link to the partnership firm. He had not established that the contracts were of the kind that had to be disclosed.

He had also not shown that Mr Adhikari remained personally bound on the date of the affidavit, or that the not-applicable entry was therefore false. The necessary link between ongoing works and concealment was missing.

Order

Issues 1, 2 and 3 were decided in favour of the returned candidate and against the petitioner. The election petition fails and is dismissed.

The judgment does not record any order on costs. Issues 4 to 7 had been decided earlier, on 2 November 2022.