Orders posted to January 2027 after three hearings: Delhi HC gives trial court 15 days to rule
Justice Girish Kathpalia said the word clarifications in the order sheets sounded mechanical, and asked district judges to circulate a 15-day limit for orders and 30 to 45 days for final judgments.
A trial court in Delhi heard arguments on an application three times. After the last hearing on 31 October, it posted the matter to 28 January 2027 for orders. On 17 November the Delhi High Court gave it 15 days to decide.
Justice Girish Kathpalia allowed Karan Kapoor’s petition and went further. He ordered his judgment sent to every Principal District and Sessions Judge in Delhi, with a time limit for criminal courts to follow after hearing arguments.
Three hearings, no order
Mr Kapoor asked the High Court to direct the trial court to decide his application under Section 175(3) BNSS expeditiously, preferably within one week. His counsel, Mr Rohit Gupta, said arguments had been advanced three times.
Each time, the matter was posted for orders. The last hearing was on 31 October 2026, and the trial court then fixed 28 January 2027 for orders.
Ms Manjeet Arya, the Additional Public Prosecutor, accepted notice for the State. In fairness, the judgment says, she did not object to the petition.
Six dates when the court did not sit
Justice Kathpalia first said what the case was not. It was not a matter pending for want of witnesses or prosecutors, or because a forensic report was late. It was a miscellaneous application on which arguments were heard repeatedly and the matter was posted for orders repeatedly.
He noted that after arguments the trial court had posted the matter for orders or for clarifications, if any. He did not find the second word convincing.
The judge said that the mention of clarifications “appears to be mechanical”, as if to justify the failure to pronounce orders in time. The order sheets, he said, showed the pattern.
Arguments were heard on 20 May 2026 and the matter was adjourned to 14 July 2026 for orders or clarifications. After that, the court was not held on six consecutive dates. Arguments were heard for the third time on 31 October.
Fresh arguments, fresh orders
The judge found substance in the petitioner’s submission that orders should be pronounced as soon as possible after arguments conclude. The arguments are then fresh in the mind of the judge while dictating.
Posting matters to unjustifiably long dates after hearing, he added, itself creates the need for clarifications.
Borrowing the 30-day rule
The court accepted that procedural criminal law sets no time within which orders on miscellaneous applications must be passed. It took its cue from Section 258(1) BNSS instead.
That provision requires a Court of Sessions, after hearing arguments, to give judgment as soon as possible and within 30 days of completing arguments. The period may be extended to 45 days for reasons recorded in writing.
Justice Kathpalia said the logic applies equally to Courts of Sessions and to Magistrates dealing with criminal trials. Keeping a matter undecided for an unreasonable time after arguments, civil or criminal, final or miscellaneous, the court said:
“erodes confidence of public in the justice delivery system” (para 7)
Order
The petition is allowed. The trial court must pass orders on Mr Kapoor’s application under Section 175(3) BNSS within 15 days of 17 November 2026.
Pending applications stand disposed of. A copy of the judgment goes to the trial court at once for compliance.
A copy must also go to all Principal District and Sessions Judges, to be conveyed to every court in Delhi dealing with criminal cases. Once arguments on any issue conclude, whether final or miscellaneous and before a Court of Sessions or a Magistrate, the order or judgment must be pronounced within a reasonable time.
For a final judgment, the court said, that time is at most 30 to 45 days, as Section 258(1) BNSS contemplates. In other cases it is not more than 15 days.