Justice N. Mozhui Gauhati HC PETITION DISMISSED No UPSC advice needed for BROcivilian
[ Gauhati High Court ]

Gauhati HC upholds penalty on Border Roads engineer: civilian GREF officers need no UPSC advice

Justice Nchumbemo Mozhui held that a 1958 exemption for Defence service civilians covers a BRO officer, so a 2015 penalty over an explosives accident stands.

An Executive Engineer who commanded a Border Roads road construction company was charged in 2012 after personnel under him mishandled explosives. In 2015 he lost three increments. On 17 November 2026, ten years after he filed his petition, the Gauhati High Court upheld the penalty.

Justice Nchumbemo Mozhui rejected Kishori Saw’s central argument, that the Union Public Service Commission had to be consulted before the penalty was imposed. The court held that a civilian member of the Border Roads Organisation, or BRO, is covered by a 1958 exemption from such consultation.

An explosives accident and a memo of charges

Mr Saw joined on 10 July 2001 as Assistant Executive Engineer (Civil) in Himachal Pradesh. He was promoted Executive Engineer on 1 October 2009 and posted at Leh, where he was Officer Commanding of 51 Road Construction Company.

An accident occurred at Leh in which personnel below him were alleged to have mishandled explosives. He was issued a Memorandum of Charges on 21 March 2012 and replied on 13 April 2012, denying the allegation.

The Disciplinary Authority appointed an Inquiring Authority on 7 June 2012. By then Mr Saw had moved to Shimla, joining on 4 January 2012. The inquiry report held the charges proved and was served on him on 9 February 2015.

He submitted a detailed representation on 21 February 2015, listing deficiencies in the inquiry. On 27 November 2015 the Disciplinary Authority held the charge partially proved and withheld three increments without cumulative effect.

Why the engineer wanted UPSC advice

Mr IH Saikia, counsel for Mr Saw, said his client had been recruited through a UPSC examination. He relied on two Department of Personnel and Training memoranda, of 10 May 2011 and 5 March 2014.

The first requires the inquiry report and the officer’s representation to go to the UPSC. The second requires a copy of the Commission’s advice to be given to the officer, who may respond within 15 days, before the Disciplinary Authority decides. Neither was followed, he argued.

He also argued that withholding increments is a minor penalty under Rule 11(iv) of the Central Civil Services (Classification, Control and Appeal) Rules, 1965. Rule 16, he said, bars such an order without consulting the UPSC where consultation is necessary.

A civilian in the BRO is governed by those Rules, he said, relying on R Viswan v Union of India ((1983) 3 SCC 401).

Union says Defence civilians are exempt

Mr RKD Choudhury, Central Government Counsel, relied on Regulation 5(2) of the UPSC (Exemption from Consultation) Regulations, 1958. It says the Commission need not be consulted on any disciplinary matter affecting a person belonging to a Defence service (Civilian).

He added that a Ministry of Defence memorandum of 24 October 2019 had clarified that Regulation 5(2) applies to serving GREF officers of the BRO in disciplinary proceedings under the 1965 Rules. All BRO matters, earlier under the Ministry of Road Transport, had moved to the Ministry of Defence, he said.

He cited R Viswan for the holding that civilian BRO members are members of the Armed Forces under Article 33 of the Constitution. He cited Mohammed Ansari v Union of India ((2017) 3 SCC 740) for the dual disciplinary authority, under the Army Act and under the 1965 Rules.

He also relied on a coordinate bench judgment of 14 July 2026 in Randhir Kumar v Union of India, WP(C) 4861 of 2024, on the same proposition.

The timing objection

Mr Saikia replied on timing. The accident, the charge memo, the inquiry and Mr Saw’s representation all fell while he served under the Ministry of Road Transport and Highways at Leh.

The 2011 memorandum therefore governed, he said. The Cabinet Secretariat notification and the Defence Ministry memorandum of 2019, he argued, came only after the proceedings began.

Statutory guidelines, yet no consultation

Justice Mozhui accepted that the DoPT memorandum of 10 May 2011 is statutory in nature and that its compliance is mandatory. He also accepted that the memorandum of 5 March 2014 required the inquiry report and representation to go to the UPSC, and the Commission’s advice to be shared with the officer.

The court then set out the Defence Ministry memorandum of 24 October 2019 in full. It records that the issue of consulting the UPSC for serving GREF civilian officers of the BRO was examined with the DoPT and the UPSC.

The court noted that Mr Saw is not a regular member of the armed forces or the army. The army authorities do control the BRO and GREF, it said, but in this case the authority only recommended departmental proceedings.

There was no recommendation for court-martial under the Army Act. Such proceedings were perhaps not initiated, the court said, because Mr Saw was civilian personnel, and the inquiry therefore recommended departmental proceedings under the 1965 Rules.

On that footing the court held that a civilian member of the BRO is a member of the Armed Forces within the meaning of Article 33, and that the BRO came under the Ministry of Defence in 2015. It then reached its conclusion:

“there is no necessity for consultation with the UPSC” (para 18)

Regulation 5(2), it said, applies squarely to the petitioner.

What the court did not address

The court also took into account Mohammed Ansari. It reproduced a Supreme Court passage quoted there, which describes the General Reserve Engineer Force as:

“an integral part of the Armed Forces” (para 19)

The judgment records the timing objection but does not separately answer it. It does not discuss whether the 2019 memorandum could apply to a proceeding begun in 2012, and it deals with no other ground against the inquiry.

Order

The court found no merit in the petition seeking interference with the departmental proceeding, the inquiry report and the punishment order of 27 November 2015, or any consequential order. The writ petition is dismissed, with no order as to costs.