Justice N.J. Jamadar Bombay HC ISSUE DELETED Dead co-sellers who had already conveyedtheir shares cannot sink the suit
[ Bombay High Court ]

Bombay HC keeps Vasai land suit alive: no need to join heirs of two dead sellers who conveyed

The sole surviving defendant argued that a suit on a single land contract dies as a whole when heirs of dead co-owners are not brought in. Justice N.J. Jamadar held that the right to sue never survived against those heirs, and deleted the abatement issue.

A builder's suit to enforce a 1996 agreement to buy about 47,000 square metres of land at Vasai has been pending since 2010. Two of the sellers have died since, and their heirs were never joined.

The last remaining defendant argued that the whole suit therefore stands dead. On 18 November the Bombay High Court said it does not.

Justice N.J. Jamadar quashed a trial court order that had framed an issue on abatement of the suit as a whole.

The 1996 deal and the 2012 settlement

Evershine Builders sued for specific performance of a memorandum of understanding of 1 June 1996 and an agreement for sale of 26 August 1997. It said the owners agreed to sell land in Malonde village, Vasai, at Rs 75,000 per guntha.

The builder said it paid Rs 24,21,000 as earnest money under the memorandum and another Rs 24,21,000 under the agreement for sale.

On 30 April 2012 it signed consent terms with all defendants except defendant No. 6, Hiren Jaswant Rajani.

The other sellers had conveyed their 23/24th undivided share in three deeds, to the builder and Green Court Associates. Two deeds are dated 31 December 2011 and one 25 July 2012.

That left the dispute alive only against Mr Rajani.

Two deaths and a string of applications

Defendant No. 2 died on 6 February 2015 and defendant No. 1 on 3 March 2022.

No heirs were brought on record within time.

Mr Rajani applied to dismiss the suit as abated. The trial court refused on 14 July 2022, reasoning that defendant No. 2 had performed his part in his lifetime and nothing remained for his heirs to answer.

The builder meanwhile amended its plaint to delete the settling defendants and confine the suit to Mr Rajani's share. The court rejected the builder's late application to join the heirs of defendant No. 2 as pointless.

Mr Rajani's revision was withdrawn on 26 November 2025 with liberty to ask for an additional issue. On 23 April 2026 the Civil Judge, Senior Division, Vasai, framed one.

The issue the trial court framed

The issue read:

“Whether the entire suit would abate as a whole in view of abatement of the suit against the some of the defendants on the ground that, the legal heirs and representatives of deceased defendants are not brought on record?” (para 2)

Mr Rajani said the contract was a single, indivisible transaction over one composite parcel. The suit had abated against defendants 1 and 2, so it could not go on against the rest.

Arguments from both counsel

Mr Karl Tamboly, for the builder, said an issue cannot rest on vague statements, and that the sole defendant had not even pleaded abatement in a written statement. The right to sue against the settled defendants was gone, he said, and the amended plaint had attained finality.

Ms Aafreen Shaikh, for Mr Rajani, said the High Court should not disturb a procedural order.

She argued that a suit on an undivided interest cannot be split among co-owners, and relied on Nathu Ram and Sri Chand. She also said the settlement was under attack in other suits, so the dispute with the other defendants was not over.

When a suit abates

The judge turned to Order XXII Rule 4 of the Code of Civil Procedure. If a defendant dies and the right to sue does not survive against the others alone, the heirs must be joined. If they are not, the suit abates against the dead defendant.

“it does not abate necessarily as a whole” (para 17)

The case for abatement as a whole arises only if no effective relief can be given against the survivors without the heirs.

The judge held that everything turned on whether the right to sue survived against the heirs of the dead defendants. He read Section 306 of the Indian Succession Act, under which only rights that existed at the time of death pass to the representatives.

Why the right to sue did not survive

Defendants 1 and 2 had signed conveyances of their shares before they died. According to the builder, that meant they had performed their side of the contract, so there was nothing left to enforce against their heirs.

The judge noted that Section 37 of the Contract Act binds promisors' representatives if they die before performance. Here, on the builder's case, performance had already happened.

In the judge's view the right to sue therefore did not survive against the heirs of defendants 1 and 2, and the suit did not abate against them. That removed the foundation for abatement as a whole.

A contract to sell an undivided share can be enforced, he added, leaving the purchaser to seek partition. Whether to grant a decree remains in the court's discretion.

Why the appeal cases did not help

Ms Shaikh's authorities concerned abatement of appeals. There, the risk is two conflicting decrees on the same subject if an appeal proceeds against some respondents but not others.

A suit where a co-defendant settles and is deleted stands on a different footing, the judge said. The indivisible cause of action does not stop the court from proceeding to the extent the dispute survives.

The judge also noted that he had given a series of orders fixing time limits for deciding the suit. The extra issue would widen the inquiry into matters not germane to whether the builder is entitled to a decree for Mr Rajani's share.

The trial court had in any case framed an issue on maintainability of the suit in its present form.

Order

The petition is allowed and the order of 23 April 2026 is quashed. The additional issue is deleted. Rule is made absolute to that extent, with no costs.

The trial court is requested to hear and decide the suit as expeditiously as possible, in line with the directions this court has already issued.