Justice R. Kainthla Himachal Pradesh HC FIR QUASHED Settlement undoes apost-conviction case
[ Himachal Pradesh High Court ]

Himachal HC quashes Section 325 IPC case after conviction upheld on appeal, on settlement

Justice Rakesh Kainthla relied on three Supreme Court rulings to hold that a settlement can undo a conviction while a revision is still pending, in an FIR registered in 2003.

Two men were convicted in 2013 for an offence under Section 325 read with Section 34 of the Indian Penal Code, from an FIR registered in January 2003. The Additional Sessions Judge at Ghumarwin upheld the conviction. On 16 November 2026 the Himachal Pradesh High Court quashed the FIR and everything that followed, on the strength of a compromise.

Justice Rakesh Kainthla held that the High Court can annul a conviction on a settlement even after an appeal has failed, so long as the matter is still pending before some court.

Convicted in 2013, revisions pending since 2014

Raj Kumar and Pradeep Kumar were accused in FIR No 14 of 2003, registered on 17 January 2003 at Police Station Ghumarwin, District Bilaspur. The trial court convicted and sentenced them under Section 325 read with Section 34 by a judgment of 30 March 2013 and an order of 1 April 2013.

The Additional Sessions Judge, Ghumarwin, camp at Bilaspur, upheld the conviction and sentence. Each man then filed a revision petition in the High Court, numbered 273 and 274 of 2014. The judgment does not state the sentence.

In 2026 the two applied to have the compromise taken on record and the conviction and sentence set aside. The informant had settled with them, the applications said, and had no grievance or objection to the quashing.

The informant’s statement

The informant’s statement was recorded on 19 August 2026. She said she had entered the compromise voluntarily and without influence from anyone.

She did not want to proceed with the FIR and had no objection if the FIR and the proceedings arising from it were quashed. Ms Sheetal Vyas appeared for both petitioners and Mr PK Nadda, Additional Advocate General, for the State.

Three Supreme Court rulings on post-conviction compromise

Justice Kainthla first turned to Ramawatar v State of MP ((2022) 13 SCC 635). The Supreme Court had held there that an FIR can be quashed even after a conviction, as long as the matter is pending before some court.

The conviction does not attain finality until the accused has exhausted his remedies, the Supreme Court reasoned. It added a caveat on the other side:

“the annulment of proceedings based on a compromise would be impermissible” (para 6)

That bar applies where the settlement comes after all legal remedies are over. The Supreme Court said the bar prevents an accused from gaining indefinite leverage and that the power is meant for genuine settlements, not hollow agreements.

The second ruling was Ramgopal v State of MP ((2022) 14 SCC 531). It held that proceedings for non-heinous offences, or offences predominantly of a private nature, can be annulled even after the trial has ended or the appeal been dismissed.

The High Court quoted the Supreme Court’s remark that:

“Handing out punishment is not the sole form of delivering justice” (para 7)

The Supreme Court added that the High Court must use the discretion with rectitude. It must weigh the circumstances, how the compromise was reached, the nature and seriousness of the offence and the conduct of the accused before and after the incident.

Where heinous offences are proved, the passage says, no such benefit should be extended. It refers to Narinder Singh v State of Punjab and State of MP v Laxmi Narayan on that point.

The third was Rajendra Bhagat v State of Jharkhand ((2022) 18 SCC 465). There the Supreme Court quashed a Section 498A conviction on a settlement, with the parties living together and the appellant undertaking to nominate the other party in his service record.

Section 325 is compoundable

On those binding precedents, the court held that it can use its power under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to quash an FIR and consequential proceedings on a compromise. It said this holds even after the trial court has passed judgment and the appellate court has affirmed it.

It then checked whether the offence could be compounded. Section 325 IPC is compoundable under Section 320 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. Section 320(3) provides that where an offence is compoundable and a person is liable through Section 34, it may be compounded.

So Section 325 read with Section 34 could be settled by compromise, the court held. The informant’s statement showed that she had settled voluntarily and did not want to continue.

The judgment does not describe the facts of the original incident or the injuries. It rests on the compromise, the compoundability of the offence and the three Supreme Court rulings.

Order

The applications, CrMP 1012 of 2026 in Revision 273 of 2014 and CrMP 1013 of 2026 in Revision 274 of 2014, are allowed. FIR No 14 of 2003 and the consequential proceedings are quashed on the compromise.

Both revisions are disposed of as infructuous. The fine, if deposited, is to be refunded to the accused after the period of limitation expires if no appeal is filed. If an appeal is filed, it will be dealt with as the Supreme Court orders.

A copy of the judgment and the records of the courts below are to be returned forthwith.