Justice D. Roshan Jharkhand HC PETITION DISMISSED A Bal Police recruit asked for aconstable post too late
[ Jharkhand High Court ]

Jharkhand HC: Bal Police recruit who waited 4 years 8 months cannot claim a constable post

A policeman died in harness in 2015 and his 17-year-old son joined the Bal Police. The High Court held that Clause 8 of Police Order 209/88 depends on the son asking after turning 18, and he did not ask until August 2021.

Aditya Narayan Tiwary was 17 when his father, a Chatra district police constable, died in harness on 30 January 2015. He joined the Bal Police, the scheme for sons too young to be constables, and was paid until January 2017. On 18 November the Jharkhand High Court held that he had waited too long to ask for the permanent post.

Justice Deepak Roshan dismissed the writ petition, which had been reserved for judgment on 19 August 2026. The order is marked for reporting.

A son appointed at 17

The petitioner’s mother applied on 30 March 2015 for compassionate appointment for her elder son. He was about 17, still studying, and below the age of 18 required for a constable.

Under the police order, a ward below 18 is taken in as a Bal Police. The Superintendent of Police, Chatra, appointed him with effect from 11 September 2015 by an order dated 16 September 2015, and gave him Bal Police number 37.

Relieved at majority, salary stopped

He was paid until January 2017. By then he had turned 18, in November 2016, and a Chatra district order of 7 February 2017 relieved him from the Bal Police and ended his salary.

The petitioner said he and his mother then wrote representations to the competent authorities, which went unheard. He went to court in 2023 as W.P.(S) No. 7168 of 2023.

What he asked the court for

He sought to quash two rejections: Memo 590 of 10 April 2024 from the Superintendent of Police, Chatra, and Memo 1083 of 27 June 2023 from the Deputy Inspector General of Police (Budget). Both said there was no provision to appoint a Bal Police as constable after a delay.

He also sought a mandamus to appoint or adjust him as a Constable with all consequential benefits.

Clause 8 and the petitioner’s case

Mr Diwakar Upadhyay, for the petitioner, relied on Police Order 209/88 of 11 August 1988, read with Police Order 277/2000 of 20 July 2000. Jharkhand adopted both after the state was carved out of Bihar.

Clause 8 says that a Bal Police who reaches the prescribed age, is willing to be appointed as constable and has the prescribed physical and educational qualification shall be appointed. The petitioner said limitation had no place once he had been appointed as a Bal Police.

He listed his qualifications: matriculation from Delhi Public School, Dhanbad in 2014, Class 12 from Kendriya Vidyalaya, Dhanbad in 2016, a BA (Honours) in Political Science from Delhi University in 2019 and an MA in Public Administration from IGNOU in 2022.

The letter sent to the wrong address

The counter affidavit relied only on the delay, the petitioner said. It also annexed a letter that, he argued, appeared concocted, because every document on record gave his address as Chatra.

That letter is dated 4 February 2017. It was addressed to his permanent home town in Bihar, and the petitioner argued that the department should have sent the offer to him.

The State: no relaxation for delay

Mr Aman Kumar, Assistant Counsel to the State counsel, said the rule allows no relaxation of time for a Bal Police who wants to become a constable after reaching majority.

The petitioner was discharged on 7 February 2017, the State said, and first approached the department on 7 August 2021 for a permanent post. That was a delay of 4 years and 8 months. The State referred to documents showing no room to excuse it.

The court reads one word in Clause 8

The court first set out the facts that were not in dispute. The father died in harness, the mother applied, the son was appointed a Bal Police because he was a minor, and he was relieved when he turned 18.

It then turned to Clause 8. The court said the word “interest” carries weight, because it is for the Bal Police who wants to be confirmed to apply to the department after reaching majority.

Only then does the department conduct a physical examination and verify educational qualification before appointing him as a permanent constable.

One letter, dated 2023

The petitioner reached majority on 26 November 2016, according to the judgment. Nothing on record showed that he applied soon after that date.

The only letter he annexed, part of the Annexure-6 series, is dated 20 April 2023. The parties agreed that his first approach to the department was on 7 August 2021.

On those admitted facts the court found the ground for rejecting his claim not unreasonable. It said a wait of about 4 years and 8 months for a first application could not be justified in a case of compassionate appointment.

Compassionate appointment, not stretched

The court described compassionate appointment as an exception to the general rule, and it declined to enlarge what the Police Order grants.

“compassionate appointment is an exception to the general rule” (para 13)

The mis-addressed letter does not help

On the home-town letter, the court agreed that the letter of 4 February 2017 had been sent to the petitioner’s permanent home town in Bihar.

It then assumed the petitioner was right and the department had not sent the letter to the address where he served as a Bal Police. Even so, the court said, that mistake could not give him the benefit, because he held a right to become a permanent constable and still waited 4 years and 8 months before his first representation.

The court added that nothing was placed on record to show he approached the department between getting relieved, with full and final settlement, and 7 August 2021.

Order

Justice Roshan held that no relief could be granted and dismissed the writ application. Pending interlocutory applications, if any, stand closed. There is no order as to costs.

Mr Diwakar Upadhyay appeared for the petitioner and Mr Aman Kumar for the State respondents. The judgment was uploaded on 18 November 2026.