Justice A.R. Choudhary Jharkhand HC MATTER REMANDED A 2006 colliery award goes backto the labour commissioner
[ Jharkhand High Court ]

Jharkhand HC sends ECL colliery award back: union proved papers for only 156 of 397 workmen

Justice Anubha Rawat Choudhary held the labour commissioner checked only whether the union met the 60-day deadline of the 2006 award, not whether it filed what the award required. She did not strike the award down.

Five collieries were taken over on 28 May 1974, and 397 men say they were on their rolls and were left out. On 18 November the Jharkhand High Court held that Eastern Coalfields Limited cannot yet be made to take them back, because nobody has checked what their union actually filed.

Justice Anubha Rawat Choudhary set aside a labour commissioner’s order of 14 July 2023 but left the 2006 award standing. She sent the file back with a date, 14 December 2026, and a one-month deadline for a reasoned order.

Five collieries and 397 names

The union’s case, as the judgment records it, was that the takeover under the Coal Mines Nationalisation Act brought a breakdown of law and order. Management, it said, left out genuine workmen and inducted new men at Jorekuri, Palesthali, Beldanga, Kasta and Pariharpur.

The dispute went to the Calcutta High Court and the Supreme Court before it was referred to the Central Government Industrial Tribunal No. 1, Dhanbad, in Reference 137 of 1991.

The question referred was whether the demand to reinstate the named workmen, with back wages and continuity from 28 May 1974, was justified. The reference listed 397 names. It gave no parentage, age or home address.

An award with a 60-day clock

The Tribunal decided on 29 August 2006 that it could not verify the men on paper. It said it needed the erstwhile owner’s Form B register, provident fund records and local voter lists, and neither side had produced them.

So it designed a screening process. Each worker was to file a proforma with name, parentage, age, address, a recent photograph and any proof of employment, through the sponsoring union, within 60 days of publication. The award said the period would not be extended in any case, and a worker who missed it would not be considered.

Management was then to form a screening committee with a nominee of the Regional Labour Commissioner and a union office-bearer, which would publish a list of genuine workmen. Those on the list were to get jobs with continuity and 25 per cent back wages within 30 days.

If management missed its own timeline, all 397 were to be presumed genuine. They would be reinstated with continuity from 25 August 1974 and 25 per cent back wages.

Notices from 2008, a writ in 2009

The award was not challenged. It was notified on 7 October 2006, and the Central Government had received it on 8 September 2006.

ECL says the 60 days ended on 6 December 2006 and the workmen missed the deadline. The union’s letter of 14 October 2006 enclosed only the award and asked for implementation, ECL says, and the proforma came on 7 December 2006, as the union itself admitted in a representation of 20 March 2007.

The Assistant Labour Commissioner (Central), Dhanbad-I, issued a notice on 10 July 2008 asking why action under Sections 29 and 32 of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 should not follow. The Ministry of Labour sent a show-cause notice of its own on 24 and 29 July 2009.

ECL replied on 8 August 2009 that the union had met neither the timeline nor the content of the award. It then filed W.P.(L) 4004 of 2009, seeking a declaration that the award was inoperative, and an interim order of 10 December 2009 followed.

In that petition the union said it lodged its claim in time. ECL pointed to a representation of 18 November 2006 from an advocate who described himself as a union office-bearer, saying no existing workman or real dependant had yet come to him to be sponsored. ECL also said no supporting document was filed.

That petition was disposed of on 17 May 2023. The court declined to declare the award inoperative while the facts were disputed, and told the commissioner to decide ECL’s show-cause reply after hearing ECL and the union.

The commissioner’s one-day answer

The commissioner recorded that ECL’s representative appeared on 19 June 2023, and that both sides agreed the union had filed its documents on 7 December 2006. He framed the question as the date from which the 60 days ran.

Counted from the notification of 7 October, the union was a day late. It argued that the notification, published on a Saturday, reached it only on Monday or later.

He rejected ECL’s stand and counted from 8 September 2006, when the Ministry received the award. He added that the 60 days was meant to speed up screening and did not restrict the award’s operation, and advised ECL to implement the award “in letter and spirit”.

ECL challenged that order of 14 July 2023 in W.P.(L) 6682 of 2023.

What ECL argued

Mr Anoop Kr. Mehta appeared for ECL. He said the one-day gap hardly mattered, because the real default was in content: the union filed only a chart, and the proofs it listed as enclosures were never filed.

He pointed to the High Court order of 17 October 2024, which asked the union to file the supporting documents and photographs for every workman. The union’s supplementary affidavit covered 156 of the 397, he said, though its covering letter claimed all.

Some of those papers, he showed, could not have been filed in 2006. One bore a date of 3 September 2008, and five carried a Tribunal certification of true copy dated 3 April 2019.

He also argued that the commissioner examined only the timeline and not one document. If the union had not complied with the award, he said, the award had become inoperative.

What the union said

Mr Ranjan Kr Singh appeared for the union, the third respondent. He said both sides had accepted before the commissioner that the documents went in on 7 December 2006, and ECL itself had pleaded the same date in its petition.

He added that the finding on the timeline needed no interference. Ms Bakshi Vibha represented the Union of India and the commissioner.

On the content, the judgment records, he could not explain why the documents were not filed despite the order of 17 October 2024. He also could not say why only 156 sets were produced, or how papers dated 2008 and 2019 were said to have gone in during 2006.

The gap in the commissioner’s order

The chart ECL placed on record is headed as a list of workmen of the five collieries with home address, designation, date of appointment and “supporting documents”. A covering letter of 6 December 2006 listed, as its second enclosure, name sheets with all required documents and certificates.

This was the second round before the High Court, and the judge read the earlier order as having left a live dispute: whether the documents were submitted in terms of the award. The commissioner, she held, had to decide that, and not only whether the filing was on time.

She found that the order did not discuss ECL’s show-cause reply at all on the point that the award had not been followed in letter and spirit. It recorded that the timeline was met because both sides agreed on 7 December 2006, and stopped there.

Only 156 files reached the court

The union’s supplementary affidavit of 20 December 2024 admitted that documents were filed with the chart for 156 workmen only. For some, it said, the letter from the old colliery management was lost, so a Sanha or FIR was enclosed.

The judge noted that the union had not annexed even one proforma in the form the award required. She also recorded the commissioner’s acceptance that the delay was at best one day, covered by the weekend.

She did not decide for the first time in writ jurisdiction whether the 156 sets complied with the award. That examination, she held, had to come from the commissioner before the award could be implemented.

The order of 14 July 2023 therefore could not stand, except that the filing of papers on 7 December 2006 was rightly treated as within time. The question left open was whether the papers for 156 of the 397 followed the award.

Order

The commissioner must examine the papers of each of the 156 workmen against the directions in the award. If those directions are found not complied with, no relief can be granted to that workman, because

“the award itself would be rendered unimplementable” (para 31)

ECL and the union are to appear before the commissioner at 11 a.m. on 14 December 2026. He must pass a reasoned order within one month and send it to the parties by speed post.

The court office was told to forward the union’s supplementary affidavit and annexures to him. The writ petition is disposed of and the pending interlocutory application is dismissed as not pressed. The directions cover the 156 workmen, and the judgment gives no separate direction on the remaining 241.