Justice R. Devdas Justice K.M. Rao Karnataka HC APPEAL ALLOWED Custody petition restored
[ Karnataka High Court ]

Karnataka HC revives Bengaluru custody petition that Family Court returned without an inquiry

Justice R Devdas, for a Division Bench, held that a plea of no territorial jurisdiction belongs under Order VII Rule 10 of the CPC, not Rule 11, and that where a child ordinarily resides needs an inquiry.

A Bengaluru Family Court sent a mother’s custody petition away without an inquiry into where her son lives. On 16 November the Karnataka High Court sent it back. A Division Bench held that the father used the wrong provision of the Code of Civil Procedure, and that a child’s ordinary residence cannot be settled without an inquiry.

Justice R Devdas wrote the judgment for the bench with Justice K Manmadha Rao. It was reserved on 12 November and pronounced on 16 November.

A custody petition filed in Bengaluru

The mother, Ruma Tomar, filed G&WC No. 123/2026 in the Family Court at Bengaluru. She invoked Sections 7 and 8 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, read with Section 13 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act.

She asked to be declared the guardian of the couple’s minor son and given permanent and exclusive custody. She also asked the court to restrain her husband, Shashank Chaudhary, from interfering with that custody without the court’s leave.

The father’s application

Mr Chaudhary applied under Order VII Rule 11 of the Code of Civil Procedure to have the petition rejected. He said it disclosed no cause of action and was barred by law, because it did not plead that the child ordinarily resides within the Bengaluru Family Court’s jurisdiction, as Section 9 of the Act requires.

He said the boy had been studying at a school in Noida when the mother took him away without his permission.

He said she asked the school to let the child take examinations online. He alleged that she then fraudulently told the school she had an order from the Family Court at Bengaluru, obtained a transfer certificate and enrolled him in a Bengaluru school.

The Family Court returned the petition

The Family Court accepted that argument. Its reasoning, as the High Court recorded it, was that when a custody petition is filed soon after a child is removed from his ordinary residence, the new place must be ignored.

The new place can become the ordinary residence only after the child has settled there for a reasonably long period. The court therefore allowed the application and directed its office to return the petition so that she could present it to the competent court.

The mother appealed under Section 19(1) of the Family Courts Act, 1984.

What the two sides said

Mr Udaya Holla, Senior Counsel for the mother, relied on Ruchi Majoo v Sanjeev Majoo ((2011) 6 SCC 479). The Supreme Court held there that the sole test under Section 9 is where the minor ordinarily resides, and that this is primarily a question of intention and therefore of fact.

Unless the jurisdictional facts are admitted, he said, the Family Court could not conclude without an inquiry that the child lives in Noida.

He added that the father’s petitions at the Family Court in Noida were stayed by the Supreme Court in a transfer petition, and that his habeas corpus petition at the Allahabad High Court was dismissed on 28 March 2026.

Ms Sruti Chaganti, for the father, said the Family Court had relied only on admitted facts, drawn from the mother’s own petition, and had followed the requirements of Order VII Rule 11.

She cited two recent decisions of the High Court, Smt Priyanka V v Sri Prashanth D Veerapur (MFA No. 1492/2026, decided on 20 August 2026) and Smt Sneha Harischandra Sumithra v Mr Sudhir Das Venkata Das (decided on 19 December 2025).

As described in the judgment, those decisions say a court must look at where the child was living, for how long, and how he came to be removed. A later removal cannot by itself change ordinary residence so as to defeat the jurisdiction of the court that had it.

The wrong rule of the CPC

The bench began with what it called a technical defect in the father’s application. Rule 10 of Order VII deals with return of a plaint to be presented to the court where the suit should have been filed. Rule 11 provides for rejection of a plaint on listed grounds.

The father had invoked Rule 11(a) and (d). But his affidavit argued that the child ordinarily resides in Noida, so the real contention was about Section 9 of the Guardians and Wards Act. The court said little had been said about cause of action.

A plea to return a petition for want of jurisdiction falls under Rule 10, it held, and cannot be made under Rule 11 on the footing that the petition is barred by law.

The Family Court’s own direction to the office to return the petition was an order under Rule 10(2). On technicalities alone, the bench said, the application should have been rejected.

An inquiry on ordinary residence

The bench then accepted Mr Holla’s argument on the merits as well. Following Ruchi Majoo, it held that where a minor ordinarily resides is primarily a question of intention, and so of fact. Unless the jurisdictional facts are admitted, it is never a pure question of law.

It said:

“the least that the Family Court should have done is to hold an enquiry” (para 11)

The court drew a comparison with a plea of res judicata under Order VII Rule 11(d). The Supreme Court has held in Keshav Sood v Kirti Pradeep Sood (2023 SCC OnLine SC 2459) and Pandurangan v T Jayarama Chettiar ((2025) 10 SCC 279) that such a plea cannot be decided on bare assertions in the application.

It requires a look at the earlier pleadings and judgments. In the same way, the bench held, ordinary residence of a child must be decided on admitted facts or after an inquiry in which both sides lead evidence.

Order

The appeal is allowed. The order of 9 June 2026 in G&WC No. 123/2026 is quashed and set aside.

The petition is restored to the file of the V Additional Principal Judge, Family Court, Bengaluru, which will proceed in accordance with law.

The parties must appear before that court on 23 November 2026 without waiting for notice. The High Court did not decide where the child ordinarily resides.

The father has liberty to file a fresh application on the same cause of action, citing the correct provision. If he does, the Family Court must consider it in light of the High Court’s observations and dispose of it as quickly as possible. Pending applications stand disposed of.