Justice B.P. Sharma Madhya Pradesh HC BAIL REFUSED Bail refused over codeine coughsyrup seizure
[ Madhya Pradesh High Court ]

MP HC refuses bail over 20 bottles of codeine syrup: the whole mixture counts toward quantity

Justice B P Sharma held that commercial quantity is judged on the entire preparation and not the codeine alone, and that an unlicensed seller could not escape the NDPS Act because the syrup is a medicine.

Police in Satna said they found 20 bottles of Onrex cough syrup, each of 100 ml, on a man standing near a ground in Jamuna Colony. Both independent witnesses to the seizure later denied seeing any recovery. The Madhya Pradesh High Court still refused him bail on 16 November.

Justice B P Sharma held that the quantity was commercial because the whole preparation counts, not just the codeine in it. He left the effect of the witnesses' stand to the trial court.

Twenty bottles near Jamuna Colony

The applicant, Amar Yadav, is accused in Crime No 399/2026 of City Kotwali police station, Satna.

The charges are under Sections 8(b), 21 and 22 of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985, and Section 5/13 of the MP Drug Control Act.

According to the prosecution, the police received information on 27 April 2026 that he was standing near the Jamuna Colony ground with cough syrup for sale. They went there and, the case says, recovered 20 bottles of Onrex, which contains codeine phosphate.

The police arrested him and have filed a chargesheet.

This was his second bail application, under Section 483 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023. His first, MCrC No 24232/2026, was dismissed as withdrawn on 23 July 2026.

Witnesses who did not support the police

Ms Smita Varma, his advocate, said he was falsely implicated and nothing was recovered from him. Both independent seizure witnesses, Dheerendra Sen and Suneet Jaiswal, had denied the recovery, she said.

She argued that the police did not record the search and seizure by audio-video means, as Section 105 of the BNSS requires. Section 52-A of the NDPS Act, she said, had not been properly complied with either.

She also argued that the syrup is a medicinal preparation outside the NDPS Act and that the quantity is not commercial. She relied on Jagdish v State of MP ((2003) 9 SCC 159), Dilip v State of MP ((2007) 1 SCC 450) and the Supreme Court's decision in Sanjeet Kumar Singh v State of Chhattisgarh.

The last of those, she said, holds that recovery must be established before the presumption under Section 54 of the NDPS Act arises. She added a Delhi High Court decision, Iqbal Singh v State, and a Patna High Court order in Bharat Kumar v State of Bihar, both said to grant bail in Onrex cases.

The State's answer

Shri N S Solanki, Panel Lawyer for the State, said 20 bottles of Onrex with codeine phosphate were a commercial quantity. The applicant had produced no licence or document allowing him to possess or sell the syrup.

He argued that hostile independent witnesses cannot by themselves sink the prosecution case at this stage. The applicant also has four criminal antecedents, one of them an earlier case under the NDPS Act and the Drugs and Cosmetics Act, and Section 37 of the NDPS Act bars bail.

Why the whole bottle is weighed

Justice Sharma first dealt with quantity. Under Note 4 of the notification of 19 October 2001, inserted on 18 November 2009, small or commercial quantity is worked out on the entire mixture or preparation and not merely the narcotic content.

He read the Supreme Court's decision in Hira Singh v Union of India ((2020) 20 SCC 272), paragraphs 8 to 10, as upholding that principle for codeine-based cough syrups. The argument that only the codeine content counts, he held, could not be accepted. In his words:

“The alleged recovery is of commercial quantity.” (para 5)

Cough syrup is not a shield

On the medicinal-preparation argument, the judge relied on Mohd Sahabuddin v State of Assam ((2012) 13 SCC 491). That decision held that unlicensed transport of large quantities of codeine-based cough syrup without valid documents attracts the NDPS penal provisions, even though the product is a pharmaceutical preparation.

He noted that the Calcutta High Court had taken a similar view in Rashid Sk v State of West Bengal. Here, he said, the applicant was not a licence holder and had shown no valid document, so Sahabuddin applied.

Hostile witnesses left for trial

The court held that the applicant's cases were distinguishable on facts. That two independent seizure witnesses did not back the prosecution did not, at the bail stage, allow the recovery to be disbelieved without the remaining evidence.

The effect of their depositions and the alleged procedural lapses would be considered by the trial court, the judge said. On the case diary, the applicant's involvement with a commercial quantity could not be ruled out. He held that the applicant had:

“failed to satisfy the twin conditions prescribed under Section 37 of the NDPS Act” (para 7)

Order

The second bail application under Section 483 of the BNSS is dismissed. The court made no other direction.