MP HC refuses a second inquiry for petrol dealer whose four pumps carried double-gear fittings
Justice Sanjeev Kalgaonkar held that a committee of the company, pump makers and the weights and measures department had examined seized fittings, and that intact seals and the lack of a site visit did not undo its finding.
A petrol pump dealer with a dealership dating to 1966 lost it after the oil company's inspectors reported double gear assemblies in all four of its dispensing units. Its petition against that finding has been pending since 2010. On 17 November the Madhya Pradesh High Court dismissed its latest petition.
Justice Sanjeev S Kalgaonkar held that the committee ordered by a Division Bench had examined the seized fittings and the manufacturers' statements. He found no reason to order another inquiry.
Two clean inspections, then a surprise check
M/s Angan Lal Raj Kumar ran a retail outlet under a dealership agreement of 2 August 1966 with Burma Shell. Bharat Petroleum Corporation Ltd, its successor, continued the agreement.
The Inspector of Weights and Measures, Rewa, inspected the outlet's dispensing units on 28 August 2005. A Bharat Petroleum technician did the same on 24 September 2005. Both reports found nothing improper.
The company's Quality Control Cell then made a surprise inspection and reported on 28 September 2005 that double gear assemblies had been fitted in four dispensing units and were operated through a pin. When the mechanism was used, the units dispensed less fuel.
A show cause notice followed, and the company terminated the dealership by a letter of 13 October 2006.
Writ, appeal and a Supreme Court deadline
The dealer challenged the termination in Writ Petition No 15556 of 2006. A coordinate bench disposed of it on 13 September 2007, and the dealer took the order to a writ appeal, WA No 1514 of 2007.
On 15 December 2009 a Division Bench allowed the appeal and quashed the termination. It held that the company should have included the Weights and Measures Department in its inspection of 10 October 2006, and that an opinion resting on presumption has no sanctity of law.
It ordered a fresh inquiry by a team of officials and technicians of the company, the manufacturer of the dispensing units, and a nominee of the Controller of Weights and Measures of the Madhya Pradesh Government, of at least Deputy Controller rank. The dealer was to be allowed to take part and the report was due in three months.
The Division Bench also directed that the outlet be restored to the dealer, subject to the outcome of the inquiry. If the findings went against him, he could seek remedies in civil law.
The company went to the Supreme Court. By its order of 26 March 2010 in Civil Appeal No 2759 of 2010, the Supreme Court said that if the inquiry had not been completed in terms of the High Court's directions, it must be done within two months.
What the committee found in May 2010
The committee met on 7 May and 18 May 2010. At the first meeting, Mr Anil Dalmia, who represented the dealer, said no additional fitting could be installed without tampering with the seal of the Weights and Measures Department.
Representatives of the two manufacturers, MIDCO and L&T, said their units had left the factory without any double gear or non-standard assembly. Mr K K Bhawsar, the Deputy Controller of Weights and Measures, said the issue could not be decided on verbal statements alone and wanted drawings, photographs and the physical parts.
At the second meeting a sealed envelope was opened in front of everyone. It held four seized double gear fittings, three from MIDCO units and one from an L&T unit, and a clip with a wire.
The MIDCO representative confirmed that the fittings and the opening in the gear cover were not supplied by the company. The L&T representative confirmed that the assembly in its unit was non-standard.
The L&T representative and the Deputy Controller said the gear assembly of the modified L&T unit could be removed and replaced by taking out the connecting rod without disturbing the seal. For the MIDCO units, the opening in the gear cover allowed a pin or clip to alter delivery without touching the seal.
The MIDCO representative could not say whether the entire double gear fitting could be installed without breaking the seal. Weights and Measures officials explained that verification checks the accuracy of delivery, so a unit with an unauthorised fitting that delivered within limits could be stamped and sealed without opening its gears.
The company said all four units had delivered below permissible limits at the surprise inspection and that the dealer was the sole beneficiary. It reaffirmed the termination on 11 June 2010.
The dealer's case and the company's
Mr Prabhat Shukla, advocate for the dealer, said the Weights and Measures inspection and the company technician's check in August and September 2005 had found the units in order. He said the Quality Control team then opened the department's seal on 28 September 2005 and reported manipulation.
He said the committee did not follow the Division Bench and Supreme Court orders. It never inspected the units, especially the one at Mangawan in Rewa district, and concluded that manipulation was visible without breaking the seal.
The dealer's written objection of 21 May 2010 alleged that the committee relied on unverified photographs and that Mr Dalmia was threatened into signing under duress. It also said the committee suppressed what the technical experts had said about the seal. Mr Shukla argued that the company acted with mala fides and the dealership should be restored.
Mr Kapil Jain appeared for Bharat Petroleum and the other respondents. He argued that the committee was properly constituted, looked at every aspect and relied on the manufacturers' statements that they never fitted double gears.
He also said the land on which the outlet stood was leased to the company, that the lease had expired and that the company no longer held possession. The petition, he said, was therefore infructuous.
Judicial review of a technical finding
The judge framed the issue in these words:
“whether the fresh inquiry by the committee complied with the directions of the Division Bench and the Supreme Court and whether the decision based on that inquiry was fair and supported by relevant material” (para 16)
He began with Tata Cellular v Union of India ((1994) 6 SCC 651). A writ court does not sit in appeal over an administrative decision, but it may interfere where the decision is illegal, irrational or procedurally unfair.
He then cited Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd v Super Highway Services ((2010) 3 SCC 321). Termination of a dealership is serious, and the corporation must act fairly, follow applicable rules and give the dealer an effective chance to take part. The technical nature of a dispute does not excuse any of that.
Why intact seals did not help the dealer
The committee included the corporation, the manufacturers and the Weights and Measures Department, and the dealer took part. The seized fittings and metering assemblies were put before the members, and the manufacturers said they had not made or supplied the double gear assemblies.
Justice Kalgaonkar held that the finding of non-standard assemblies rested on relevant technical material and not on presumption or surmise.
On the dealer's main point, he said the committee had looked at how the modified mechanism could change delivery while the seals stayed intact. Installing a whole assembly, in his words, is a different thing from operating one after modification.
So the MIDCO representative's uncertainty about installing the whole assembly did not undo the explanation of how a modified unit could be operated. The earlier clean inspection reports did not disprove the later finding, since checks on delivery did not necessarily involve opening the internal gears.
The Division Bench order, he noted, required a fresh inquiry and let the dealer participate, but did not direct an inspection at the outlet. The findings could not be discarded because members did not visit it, and the court would not substitute its own technical opinion.
The dealer had joined the inquiry, disputed the findings, and had his objection about seals considered. The judge said:
“Mere disagreement with the technical findings does not warrant another inquiry” (para 21)
Order
The writ petition is dismissed. The judge held that the request for a fresh inquiry could not be accepted merely because the seals were intact or no site inspection was made.
He added that restoration at the former premises was also unavailable because the lease had expired and the corporation had lost possession.
The liberty to pursue a civil remedy, expressly reserved by the Division Bench, remains unaffected. The court expressed no opinion on maintainability, limitation or merits of any such claim.