MP HC lets brother buy out the outsider who bought half of their 290 sq ft family house
Justice Ashish Shroti set aside two concurrent decrees after finding that every condition of Section 4 of the Partition Act was met except the buyer undertaking, which the Supreme Court allows even at the execution stage.
Two brothers bought their ancestral house in Guna in 1999, and one later sold his half, 152.75 square feet, to an outsider for Rs 1,20,000. The other sued and lost in both courts below. On 17 November the Madhya Pradesh High Court at Gwalior gave him the chance to buy that half.
Justice Ashish Shroti held that Section 4 of the Partition Act, 1893 protects a co-owner of a family dwelling house from an outsider who sues for partition. Neither court below had considered it because nobody had pressed it.
A house bought back out of affection
The plaintiff, Arvind Kumar Rathore, and his brother Harish Kumar Rathore, defendant No 1, are sons of the late Devchand Rathore.
The disputed house in Ward No 15, Anuradha Gali, Guna, is double-storeyed and measures 26 feet by 11.9 feet.
The house had belonged to their uncle, Ramlal, who bought it in a court auction on 28 October 1960. He sold it to Puranchand Jain on 30 September 1969.
The brothers, out of affection for the ancestral house, jointly bought it back from Mr Jain by a sale deed of 2 November 1999. They became co-owners in joint possession.
The sale he says he never knew
On 24 August 2005 Harish sold his half to defendant No 2 for Rs 1,20,000, by registered sale deed Ex D/1.
The plaintiff says he learnt of it only when defendant No 2 sent a legal notice on 22 March 2012, which he answered on 30 March 2012.
He claims that as a joint purchaser he had a preferential right to buy his brother's half. On 21 May 2012 he served a notice asking Harish to cancel the sale and sell the house to him. The court recorded that no reply came.
He sued on 18 December 2012, seeking a declaration that the 2005 sale deed was void and a permanent injunction against interference with his possession.
The buyer's defence and two decrees
Defendant No 2 denied the plaint. He put the house at 305 square feet and said it was not joint family property but property the two brothers had bought together. He said he took possession after the sale and kept a ground-floor room as a store.
The plaintiff, he alleged, illegally occupied that room in 2012 while he was out of town.
He counter-claimed for a declaration of title to the purchased portion, partition and separate possession.
The Fourth Civil Judge Class-II, Guna, dismissed the suit on 20 August 2014. The trial court held that the house belonged jointly to the plaintiff and Harish, that the plaintiff had made no offer to buy and so had no preferential right, and that defendant No 2 owned half after the sale deed.
The Fourth Additional District Judge, Guna, upheld that on 12 December 2019 in RCA No 200018/2015. That court examined the claim under Section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 and held it was not attracted because the property was not joint family property.
One question, raised in second appeal
The High Court admitted the second appeal on 23 September 2026 on a single substantial question of law:
“Whether the judgment and decree passed by both the Courts suffered from irregularity inasmuch as provisions of Section 4 of The Partition Act, 1893 was not complied with?” (para 13)
Mr Faiz Ahmed Qureshi, for the plaintiff, said the courts below had erred by not considering Section 4. As a joint owner of a dwelling house, he argued, the plaintiff should have been given an option to buy Harish's half.
The defendants: a new case, a shifted stand
Counsel for defendant No 2 said the plaintiff never based his claim on Section 4 and had raised it for the first time before the High Court. No new issue, they argued, can be raised in second appeal without a foundation in pleadings and evidence.
They invoked the rule against approbating and reprobating and the doctrine of election. They relied on Suzuki Parasrampuria Suitings v Official Liquidator ((2018) 10 SCC 707), Kondiba Dagadu Kadam v Savitribai Sopan Gujar ((1999) 3 SCC 722) and Joint Action Committee of Air Line Pilots’ Association of India v DG of Civil Aviation ((2011) 5 SCC 435).
They added that Sections 2 and 3 of the Act gave defendant No 2 a right to buy too. The trial court had framed an issue on this but declined to answer it.
In rejoinder the plaintiff cited Ghantesher Ghosh v Madan Mohan Ghosh ((1996) 11 SCC 446) to say a Section 4 claim can be raised even in execution proceedings.
Section 22 out, Section 4 in
Justice Shroti began with the plaint. The plaintiff had asserted a preferential right to buy his brother's share in paragraph 4 of the plaint, though he founded it on Section 22 of the Hindu Succession Act.
That section lets an heir buy another heir's share in an intestate's property in preference to a stranger. It does not apply here, the judge said, because the brothers bought the house and did not inherit it. The first appellate court was right on that point.
The controversy therefore turned on Section 4. The court set out five conditions: the property is a dwelling house of an undivided family; the claimant is a family member and shareholder; one shareholder sold his share to a stranger; the stranger sued for partition; and the claimant gave an undertaking in court to buy that share.
The court read Section 4 as designed so that:
“a stranger is not allowed to intrude into a house” (para 23)
Four conditions met, one still open
On the Supreme Court's decision in Gautam Paul v Debi Rani Paul ((2000) 8 SCC 330), the right arises only when the stranger sues for partition. A stranger who simply buys a share and does nothing gives the co-sharer no right to pre-empt.
Here, the judge found, the house was a dwelling house of an undivided family, the brothers held equal shares, and the share had been sold to a stranger. Defendant No 2 had filed a counter-claim seeking partition. All conditions were met except the plaintiff's undertaking.
An undertaking even at execution
The court asked whether the plaintiff should be denied relief only because he had given no undertaking in the trial court. It relied on Ghantesher Ghosh, which held that Section 4 can be pressed pending the partition suit until the final decree and afterwards in execution, so long as the decree has not been fully executed.
The plaintiff could therefore give his undertaking in the execution proceedings. He had in fact filed it in this appeal, through IA No 10401/2026.
The court rejected each defence objection. There was no shift of stand, because the plaintiff's challenge to the sale rested on his claimed preferential right to buy. For that reason the cases on inconsistent stands, on unpleaded questions of law, and on election did not apply.
Defendant No 2, being a stranger, could not invoke Section 2, which in the judge's reading covers partition among family co-sharers. He noted too that the house was a kachcha structure of bricks and mud, the plaintiff lived there, and it could not conveniently be divided by metes and bounds.
The judge also found the house more beneficial to the plaintiff's residence than to a stranger's. He held that the plaintiff was:
“entitled to an opportunity to buy the share of defendant no.1” (para 38)
Order
The judgments and decrees of 20 August 2014 and 12 December 2019 are set aside. Execution proceedings for partition are still pending, because of an interim order passed in this appeal on 22 February 2022, so the court did not remand the case to the trial court.
It declared that the plaintiff may submit his undertaking under Section 4 before the executing court. That court must value the share sold to defendant No 2, give the plaintiff an option to buy it at that valuation, and let both parties place material on value.
The appeal is allowed and the parties bear their own costs.