Justice V. Agarwal Madhya Pradesh HC APPEAL DISMISSED Insurer plea built on newsclippings rejected
[ Madhya Pradesh High Court ]

MP HC rejects insurer plea of implanted vehicle built on clippings and a one-page report

Justice Vivek Agarwal said the insurer never examined its investigator or the reporter, filed only a sketchy single-page report, and could not gain from its own failure to lead proper evidence. Costs of Rs 10,000.

An insurance company told the Madhya Pradesh High Court that a fatal road accident was an implant, and that a vehicle had been falsely brought into the claim. Its evidence was a one-page investigator's report that described no facts of the accident, with two newspaper clippings attached. On 16 November the court dismissed its appeal with costs of Rs 10,000.

Justice Vivek Agarwal held that the insurer had not examined its investigator or the news reporter, and that no party could benefit from its own negligence in leading evidence.

A fatal accident and a plea of implant

The Manager of Shriram General Insurance Co Ltd appealed under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, against an award of 31 March 2022.

The Fourth Additional Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Sagar, had passed it in MACC No 159/2019, filed by Smt Rajju Raje and others against Rajendra and others.

The accident happened on 15 August 2018 at about 8 pm, and the deceased was Jitendra Singh. A merg intimation recorded at 12:15 am on 16 August 2018 (Ex P-3) said the accident involved an unknown truck.

The vehicle was seized on 24 October 2018, and the insurer pointed to that date.

The insurer's evidence

The insurer examined its Law Officer, Shri Bhawani Shankar, from its Indore regional office. He proved an investigation report by an investigator, Shri Surendra Gupta.

Mr Gupta had enclosed copies of newspaper clippings. According to them, the accident happened when the deceased came in contact with a stray animal on the road. From this, Mr Tejvinder Singh Lamba, for the insurer, argued that it was a case of implant.

Mr Manoj Kumar Mishra, for the claimants, supported the award and said no interference was called for.

A single page with no facts

Justice Agarwal looked at the report itself, marked Ex D-1. It ran to one page and gave no fact of the accident.

It said only that the investigator had obtained papers on the criminal case and enclosed them, along with two newspaper clippings.

The Law Officer could not point to how the report helped the insurer prove an implant. The court found no explanation for why the investigator was not examined to prove his own report, or why the complete report was not filed.

The claimants, by contrast, examined an eyewitness, Shri Rajkumar, who proved the accident.

What the Supreme Court says of newspaper items

On the clippings, the judge turned to Ghanshyam Upadhyay v State of Uttar Pradesh ((2020) 16 SCC 811), paragraphs 6 and 7. There the Supreme Court had said that courts must be circumspect about contentions resting only on newspaper reports. The court recalled that a:

“newspaper item without any further proof is of no evidentiary value” (para 5, quoting Ghanshyam Upadhyay)

That passage also quotes Kushum Lata v Union of India ((2006) 6 SCC 180). News reports are not evidence, it says, and a petition resting on unconfirmed reports without verification should not normally be entertained.

Justice Agarwal applied the same reasoning here. An unconfirmed newspaper report, with no check on its authenticity, should not normally be relied on.

No reporter, no investigator, no case

The insurer, the judge noted, had not led the evidence of the news reporter to show where the information came from or whether it was authentic. Its main plank was therefore unsubstantiated newspaper reports.

He also noted that the insurer's counsel, in cross-examining the eyewitness Rajkumar, had obtained an admission of the accident along with the number of the truck. He found no effective cross-examination of that witness.

The Law Officer had not produced the complete investigation report, and Ex D-1 was incomplete, sketchy and without detail. The investigator and the investigating officer of the criminal case were not examined. The judge concluded:

“no party can be allowed to take advantage of its own negligence” (para 7)

Order

The appeal is dismissed. The insurance company must bear the costs of the litigation for the claimants, fixed at Rs 10,000.

The court directed that the record be sent back to the Claims Tribunal. The judgment does not state the amount of the award.