Justice N.A. Venkatesh Madras HC REVIEW DISMISSED A bank fights a 2011 fraudclaim, and the review fails
[ Madras High Court ]

Axis Bank must return Rs 16.15 lakh siphoned in 2011: Madras HC applies a 2017 RBI circular

Justice N Anand Venkatesh rejected the bank review plea against an order to re-credit a pharma firm current account, holding that the beneficial 2017 circular on customer losses applies even to a fraud that took place in 2011.

Rs 16.15 lakh left a Chennai company’s current account at Axis Bank in 2011. The company pursued a criminal complaint until the police filed a closure report in October 2023, and then turned to the bank. On 17 November the Madras High Court refused to reopen its order that the bank must pay the money back.

Justice N Anand Venkatesh dismissed the bank’s review application against his order of 12 June 2025 in a writ petition filed in 2024. The order had been clarified on 3 July 2025.

The bank has already deposited the money, and the firm may now withdraw it.

An order passed without the bank in court

The writ petitioner is Dadha Pharma LLP, formerly Dadha Pharma Private Limited. It sought a mandamus directing Axis Bank to re-credit Rs 16,15,000 that had been siphoned from its current account.

The bank was served with notice but nobody appeared for it. The court heard the company’s counsel and the Government Advocate (Crime Side) for the State, and on 12 June 2025 directed the bank to act on the RBI circular and restore the amount within four weeks.

Contempt first, review later

The bank filed its review application 272 days late. Meanwhile, the company filed a contempt petition for non-compliance.

After notice in that petition, the bank said it was willing to deposit the sum. The court closed the contempt petition on 10 April 2026 and gave the bank two weeks to deposit it, which the bank did. The delay in the review was condoned on 22 July 2026.

Three grounds from the bank

Counsel Rahul Balaji, for Axis Bank, raised three grounds. First, the RBI circular does not apply to private sector banks. Second, the bank had not been given enough opportunity to contest the writ petition.

Third, the siphoning happened in 2011, when an RBI notification of 8 April 2002 governed such cases. The bank’s compensation policy under that notification capped its liability at Rs 25,000 (Clause 11.3), and the circular of 6 July 2017 on which the court relied, it said, is only prospective.

D Ferdinand, for the company, said the 2002 notification was withdrawn in 2017. The company had pursued a criminal complaint that ended only with a closure report on 4 October 2023.

Only then could it claim, he said, and by then the 2017 policy was in force.

Two grounds dismissed quickly

The court disposed of the first two grounds in a few lines. An RBI notification, it said, applies equally to all banks, because they all deal with deposits whose depositors the RBI protects.

On the second ground, the bank had notice of the writ petition and chose not to contest it. It could not now say it had no opportunity.

What the 2002 notification said

The third ground was, in the judge’s words, the only material one. He asked whether the order suffered from an error apparent on the face of the record.

The court extracted the relevant part of the 2002 notification. It said that where banks are at fault, they “should compensate customers without demur” (para 12).

Where neither bank nor customer is at fault but the fault lies elsewhere in the system, banks should still compensate customers up to a limit, as part of a board-approved customer relations policy.

The judge said the 2002 circular had fixed an upper cap. The bank’s policy then limited payment to Rs 25,000 whatever the amount siphoned.

The 2017 circular withdrew the earlier one and, he said, rectified that patent error in a rule that capped the bank’s liability irrespective of the sum lost by the depositor.

A beneficial circular reaches back

The court noted that the company had run from pillar to post to expose the fraud, and the investigating officer could not solve the case. It began recovery proceedings only after the closure report of 4 October 2023, when the 2017 circular was in force.

The judge said the 2017 circular was meant to benefit customers who lose hard-earned money to siphoning. A circular of that kind, he held:

“given a retrospective effect” (para 17)

He added that this ensures customers who lose money are treated with fairness uniformly. The court found no error apparent on the face of the records.

Order

The review application was dismissed and the connected miscellaneous petition closed. The company is permitted to withdraw the Rs 16,15,000 that Axis Bank deposited, together with accrued interest, if any.