Justice M.S. Kumar Madras HC PETITION DISMISSED Seven-day answer-key window leftunused
[ Madras High Court ]

Madras HC rejects answer-key challenge by TNPSC candidate who skipped the seven-day window

Justice Mummineni Sudheer Kumar held a candidate bound by the seven-day online window in the notification, and found the Expert Committee had duly examined the eight questions in a sealed-cover report.

A candidate who never filed a challenge to the tentative answer key within the seven-day window cannot rely on objections he says his coaching institute made. On 17 November the Madras High Court dismissed his petition against the Tamil Nadu Public Service Commission result for Assistant Engineer (Civil).

Justice Mummineni Sudheer Kumar also read the Expert Committee’s sealed-cover report and said the Committee had applied its mind to the eight disputed questions.

The recruitment

The petitioner, Durai Murugan S, applied under Notification 09/2025 of 21 May 2025 for Assistant Engineer (Civil), Subject Code 398, in the Combined Technical Services Examination for non-interview posts. He took the computer-based test on 10 August 2025 and the Tamil eligibility and General Studies paper on 17 August.

The tentative answer key went online on 2 September 2025, with seven days to object through the Commission’s website. The final key came on 22 January 2026, and the results the next day.

Eight questions

The petitioner said he was at his hometown and could not get study material, so he filed no objection. He said an academy where he studied had objected to 14 questions, and six answers were corrected.

On 29 January and 9 February 2026 he sent representations on eight questions, numbers 11, 50, 89, 95, 97, 112, 120 and 125. The Commission rejected them by letters of 9 February and 27 February 2026.

The letters said all candidates had a seven-day challenging window, that only candidates may object and not coaching institutes, and that challenges made through other modes would not be considered. The Commission said every question raised in the window had gone to the Expert Committee.

The petitioner asked the court to appoint an independent expert committee to re-evaluate the questions and revise the result. His counsel was Mr U Karunakaran, and Mr I Abrar Md Abdullah, Standing Counsel, appeared for the Commission.

The notification binds

The court said the only question was whether the Commission had to consider objections the petitioner had admittedly not raised in the manner the notification required. It noted that paragraph 2 of the notification allowed challenges only through the online window within seven days.

Paragraph 2.2 added that representations made after the window closed, online or offline, would not be entertained, and paragraph 17(D) repeated this in the instructions to applicants. The petitioner first petitioned on 29 January 2026, a week after the results.

The academy’s objections

The Commission’s counter affidavit categorically denied that the academy had raised any objection, and the petitioner filed no specific denial of that. The court therefore could not take it as true that the institute had objected to 14 questions.

The court concluded that the petitioner:

“cannot be permitted to raise any objections contrary to the terms and conditions” (para 7)

of the notification, and it could not direct the Commission to act in contravention of those terms.

Order

The court added that it had gone through the Expert Committee’s report, its reasoning and the supporting material. It was convinced the Committee had applied its mind and rightly rejected the objections to the eight questions.

The writ petition is dismissed.