Missed a Rs 3,000 costs deadline, lost his defence: Madras HC revives it on a Rs 5,000 deposit
Justice N. Anand Venkatesh set aside a Commercial Court order that dismissed a 23-day delay condonation application for non-payment of Rs 3,000 costs, and gave the defendant one week to deposit Rs 5,000 or be set ex parte.
Harshan Jit Singh was 23 days late with his written statement in a Chennai commercial suit. The Commercial Court forgave the delay on one condition: pay Rs 3,000 in costs by 22 March 2026. He did not pay, and on 23 March his application was dismissed.
On 12 November 2026 the Madras High Court gave him another chance, at a higher price. Justice N. Anand Venkatesh set aside the dismissal and ordered Rs 5,000 to be deposited within a week.
The suit and the late written statement
Athenese DX Private Limited, a Chennai company, filed a commercial suit, C.O.S. No. 280 of 2025, in the Principal Commercial Court, Egmore. It seeks recovery of money with interest.
Mr Singh, proprietor of Clear Trax Circuits in New Delhi, is the defendant. He filed his written statement late and applied under Section 5 of the Limitation Act, in I.A. No. 5 of 2025, to condone a delay of 23 days.
Costs ordered, then application dismissed
By an order of 12 March 2026 the Commercial Court allowed the application. It made payment of Rs 3,000 as costs by 22 March 2026 a condition, failing which the application would stand dismissed.
The matter was listed on 23 March 2026. The costs had not been paid, and the court dismissed the application. The High Court record notes that the defendant's counsel appeared through video conferencing that day, and that the court below took note of the non-payment on the date of hearing.
A revision filed after the suit was restored
Mr Singh did not rush to the High Court. The reason, the court recorded, is that the suit itself was dismissed for default on 15 April 2026.
The suit was restored to file on 8 September 2026. Only then did the defendant file this civil revision petition under Article 227 of the Constitution, with a connected miscellaneous petition, CMP No. 30387 of 2026.
Why the court stepped in
Mr S. Srivatsa appeared for the petitioner. The judgment records no appearance for Athenese DX, and it records no argument beyond the petitioner's challenge to the 23 March order.
Justice Venkatesh said the petitioner must be given an opportunity to defend himself in the suit. He pointed out that it was the plaintiff that had failed to prosecute the suit, which was dismissed for default and restored only on 8 September 2026.
On that reasoning he set aside the order of 23 March 2026 in I.A. No. 5 of 2025. The revision was disposed of on terms rather than simply allowed.
Order
The petitioner must deposit costs of Rs 5,000 to the credit of the suit within one week of receiving a copy of the order. That is Rs 2,000 more than the amount he failed to pay in March.
On compliance, a memo is to be filed before the Commercial Court, which shall take the written statement on file and proceed with the suit in accordance with law. If he fails to pay, he shall be set ex parte and the Commercial Court shall proceed with the suit.
There is no order as to costs in the revision, and the connected miscellaneous petition is closed.