Justice K.S.K. Surender Madras HC WRIT DISMISSED A 1933 scheme, a 2024 takeover,one pending tribunal case
[ Madras High Court ]

Chennai mosque loses writ bid against Wakf Board takeover: Madras HC says Tribunal must decide

Justice K. Surender refused to bar the Tamil Nadu Wakf Board from interfering with the Edgah Charities and Mosque, whose scheme dates from a 1933 court decree, because the same challenge to the 2024 takeover is already pending before the Wakf Tribunal.

The Edgah Charities and Mosque in George Town, Chennai, is governed, its committee says, by a scheme the Madras High Court framed in 1933. On 12 November 2026 the High Court declined to stop the Tamil Nadu Wakf Board from interfering with it, and sent the dispute to the Wakf Tribunal.

Justice K. Surender dismissed the writ petition filed by H.M. Shamsuddin, president of the managing committee. He expressed no opinion on the facts or on the committee's claims. The order was reserved on 29 October and pronounced on 12 November.

A 1933 scheme and a 2024 takeover

The petitioner said the mosque is a registered and notified wakf, numbered G.S. No. 183/Chennai. It is governed, he said, by a scheme framed in C.S. No. 159 of 1931 on 13 November 1933. The scheme placed the administration with a committee of seven persons holding office for life, with vacancies filled by co-option.

On 10 January 2023 the Board's Chief Executive Officer issued a show cause notice proposing action under Section 64 of the Waqf Act. The committee challenged that notice in W.P. No. 2657 of 2023, arguing that the Chief Executive Officer had no jurisdiction to start removal proceedings. That petition was disposed of, leaving it open to the committee to explain.

The committee submitted its explanation on 15 February 2024. A Gazette Notification of 23 February 2024 followed. Issued under Section 65 on a Board resolution of 15 February 2024, it placed the wakf under the Board's direct management from that date and named the Executive Officer for the Chennai and Poonamallee zones as its manager.

One year, a Full Bench, a tribunal case

The notification does not say how long the takeover lasts. The petitioner contended that it could run for only one year, until 22 February 2025. He said the Board's officers were still relying on the resolution and interfering with the committee's administration.

Mr Nissar Ahamed, Senior Advocate, appeared for the petitioner. He argued that a court-framed scheme must be followed on appointments and removals, and that only the State Government, in consultation with the Board, can modify it. The Board and its officers, he said, cannot alter it on their own.

He relied on a Full Bench judgment in J. Ilayas and Another v. Government of Tamil Nadu and Others, W.P.(MD) No. 24333 of 2025. In his submission, the gazetted proceeding had become infructuous and its period had expired. He asked for a writ of mandamus restraining the respondents under Section 66 of the Waqf Act.

Mr Avinash Wadhwani, for the respondents, said no error was made in issuing the Gazette. The issues now raised, he said, are pending before the Tribunal.

The Tribunal is already seized

The court began from what is under challenge: the Board resolution and the published notification. The committee's Secretary has questioned both before the Wakf Tribunal in O.A. No. 42 of 2024, which is pending. The writ petition sought to restrain interference because only the State Government may change the scheme.

Justice Surender then set out the statutory route. Section 83(2) of the Waqf Act lets a mutawalli, a person interested in a wakf or any person aggrieved by an order under the Act approach the Tribunal. Section 83(5) gives the Tribunal the powers of a civil court.

The Tribunal, the court noted, is already examining the governing scheme, the Board's jurisdiction, the resolution, the notification and its alleged expiry.

Section 65(2) separately empowers the State Government to examine the correctness, legality or propriety of a Board notification under Section 65(1). The court called Section 66 material, since it lets the State Government act in consultation with the Board.

What the court said about the scheme

The judge called it trite law that, while a judicial scheme remains in force, direct control cannot be assumed unless the State Government has specifically modified it under Section 66 (para 17). That did not become a ruling on the committee's case.

These aspects, the court said, can be raised before the Tribunal in O.A. No. 42 of 2024.

The operative reason was the pending proceeding. The writ petition was dismissed on that ground, and the court refused the open-ended relief the petitioner wanted:

“No blanket order as claimed by the petitioner can be granted” (para 18)

Order

The writ petition is dismissed on the ground of the pendency of O.A. No. 42 of 2024 before the Wakf Tribunal. The High Court expressed no opinion on the facts or the petitioner's claims.

The Tribunal is at liberty to consider the issues on their merits after hearing the petitioner and the affected parties. There is no order as to costs, and the connected miscellaneous petition, W.M.P. No. 45188 of 2026, is closed.