Seven years, no trial: Madras HC refuses to move family partition fight, sets six-month deadline
Brothers who split a business empire have fought since 2019 over a disputed partition deed. Justice P. Vadamalai held that a trial judge pressing the plaintiffs to start the trial shows no bias, and ordered the cases finished in six months.
Two brothers have been in court since 2019 over how to divide a family business, and no trial has begun in seven years. When one side asked to move the case because the trial judge seemed biased, the Madras High Court said no.
Justice P. Vadamalai of the Madurai Bench dismissed the transfer petition on 18 November. He told the trial court to finish the suit and the connected execution proceedings within six months.
A deed signed on New Year's Eve 2018
The petitioners are Jegatheesan and five others. The respondents are his brother Vaikundarajan and six others, including a paternal uncle who acted as conciliator.
Two more brothers had already left the family business with their shares.
The first respondent relies on a Kaithadi Partition Deed dated 31 December 2018 and a conciliation award of 2 January 2019. The petitioners say the deed was obtained by coercion as a mere draft and that the papers were fabricated.
They add that three respondents were abroad or in Chennai that day, so the deed could not physically have been executed. Apart from the uncle, nobody signed the minutes.
Seven years of litigation
The respondents filed execution petitions in 2019 to enforce the award. The petitioners lost their arbitration petitions in the High Court on 6 September 2019, and their special leave petition and review were dismissed by the Supreme Court.
A High Court order of 8 April 2021 refused to strike off the execution petitions. The petitioners then filed objections under Section 47 of the Code of Civil Procedure and a suit in 2022 for a declaration that the deed does not bind them.
On 30 June 2023 this court declined the first respondent's request to move the execution petitions to Madurai. It asked the Principal District Judge at Tirunelveli to decide the suit and the execution cases, preferably within 12 months.
The trial court rejected the plaint on 29 August 2024 and the High Court upheld that on 31 January 2025. On 10 February 2026 the Supreme Court restored the suit and directed that it be tried along with the Section 47 objections.
After a territorial reorganisation the cases went to the V Additional District Court at Valliyoor. The suit was restored on 19 June 2026.
The bias complaint
The petitioners had an amendment of their plaint allowed on 18 August 2026 and a partial recasting of issues on 9 September 2026. They filed a second amendment application on 18 September.
The trial court returned that application. Its docket order said the execution petitions had been pending for over five years and that the plaintiffs were delaying the suit by not starting trial. It gave one more chance to begin trial on 21 September.
Senior Counsel Mr V. Prakash argued that this order showed bias. He said the trial judge had misread the Supreme Court, which had told the court to try the suit along with the Section 47 objections, and that the judge was bent on disposing of the execution petitions first.
He also said the presiding officer had been promoted to District Judge subject to a pending vigilance inquiry, so the petitioners had lost confidence in him.
The respondents' reply
Mr V. Raghavachari, Senior Counsel for the first respondent, said the petitioners had kept filing applications at every stage. They had asked for 14 issues on the Section 47 objections and sought to amend the plaint again after four years.
The other respondents added that the trial court had listed the suit and the execution petitions on the same dates, as the Supreme Court required. They also relied on a Supreme Court direction of 6 March 2025 that execution petitions be decided within six months.
What the judge found
Justice Vadamalai called for a report from the presiding officer, received on 5 October 2026. The officer said he had been fair and that the petitioners were stalling the execution cases by filing one application after another.
The judge read the Supreme Court's order of 10 February 2026 and found that it asked for the suit and the Section 47 objections to be tried together. The e-court diaries showed both were listed on the same dates.
On the docket order, he noted that the presiding officer had only said a suitable order would be made for disposing of the suit if trial did not begin. Seven years had passed without any trial or inquiry.
The petitioners, he found, had suppressed this court's 2023 direction for early disposal. They had filed a memo saying the Supreme Court set no time limit.
“co-operate for expeditious disposal of a case is not a bias” (para 22)
The judge treated the vigilance inquiry as a matter between the officer and the High Court. The petitioners, he said, had shown no biased interim or final order against them.
Order
The Transfer Civil Miscellaneous Petition is dismissed with no costs. The petitioners are to cooperate in early disposal.
The V Additional District Court, Valliyoor, must now proceed with the suit and the Section 47 applications in the three execution petitions. It must dispose of all the matters within six months of receiving the order.
Both sides are to get sufficient opportunity to lead evidence.