Justice M.S. Kumar Madras HC ORDERS QUASHED Reverted without notice afterregularisation
[ Madras High Court ]

Madras HC quashes reversion of two Deputy Tahsildars after State gave two reasons and no notice

Justice Mummineni Sudheer Kumar said the Tiruppur Collector reverted officers already regularised in the post without a hearing, and that the State offered different explanations in its counter affidavit.

Two Tiruppur revenue officers were promoted to Deputy Tahsildar, regularised in the post, and then sent back to Senior Revenue Inspector by a one-line proceeding that gave no reason. On 17 November the Madras High Court quashed both that reversion and a revised promotion panel, and ordered a fresh decision after notice within eight weeks.

Justice Mummineni Sudheer Kumar did not decide whether the reversion was justified on merits. He held that the State had failed to justify acting without hearing the officers.

Promotion, regularisation, reversion

T Vanitha and K Vinothkumar joined as Senior Revenue Inspectors on 1 July 2013 and 28 June 2016. By proceedings dated 7 March 2025 they were promoted to Deputy Tahsildar, and on 21 September 2025 their services in that post were regularised from their dates of joining.

On 9 January 2026 the District Collector, Tiruppur, reverted them to Senior Revenue Inspector. Three days later a proceeding of 12 January revised the 2025 promotion panel for the post, placing the petitioners below four other officers.

The challenge

The petitioners challenged both proceedings in a writ petition. A coordinate Bench granted an interim stay on 27 February 2026, recording the petitioners’ case that no show-cause notice or hearing had been given.

Four officers placed above them in the revised panel were later impleaded, by an order of 9 July 2026, and applied to vacate the stay. Senior Counsel Mr G Sankaran appeared for the petitioners and Additional Advocate General Mr T Gauthaman for the State.

Two reasons, neither in the order

The reversion order of 9 January did not disclose any reason, the court noted. The 12 January order did not show that the petitioners were given a chance to be heard before the panel was revised.

The Collector’s counter affidavit offered two different explanations. Paragraph 6 said the petitioners were promoted against training vacancies, a point the promotion order mentioned, and that the promotion was subject to reversion for want of an actual vacancy.

Paragraph 10 said the temporary promotions were cancelled to make room for Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe candidates in backlog vacancies for the 2025 panel. The court observed that the real reason for the reversion was therefore not clear.

Notice first, especially after regularisation

The court accepted that the promotion order showed the petitioners had been promoted in a vacancy created by officers going for training. But it was not in a position to acknowledge a reversion made without giving them any opportunity.

If trainees were rejoining or the reservation roster had to be applied, the authorities should have acted only after putting the petitioners on notice. The court said this applied with more force because their services in the post had already been regularised.

It concluded that the two proceedings:

“cannot be sustained for want of compliance with the principles of natural justice” (para 12)

It added that it would be wrong at this stage to examine whether the reversion was justified on facts and merits.

Order

Both proceedings, dated 9 January 2026 and 12 January 2026, are quashed and the matter is remitted to the District Collector. The Collector must pass fresh orders after giving an opportunity to the petitioners and other affected parties, including the four impleaded officers.

The Collector must complete the exercise within eight weeks of receiving the order. The writ petition is disposed of with no order as to costs.