Madras HC acquits man sentenced to 10 years: FIR at 3.30 am, hospital records never produced
Justice Sunder Mohan found the wife of the dead man, the only witness to the stabbing, highly doubtful, noted an unexplained eyebrow injury on the accused, and set aside a culpable homicide conviction from Ariyalur.
The stabbing happened at about 9 pm on 13 June 2019. The FIR was registered at 3.30 am the next day, and the police had probably been at the hospital long before that. On 17 November the Madras High Court acquitted the man convicted of causing the death.
Justice Sunder Mohan allowed an appeal by Kannan of Ariyalur district against a ten-year sentence under Section 304 Part II of the IPC. The judgment was reserved on 11 November and pronounced on 17 November.
A property quarrel and a fatal night
The prosecution said Kannan was related to a man named Manoharan, who was a friend of the deceased, Senthil alias Soundararajan. The two relatives were quarrelling over property, and Senthil had backed Manoharan.
On the night in question, Kannan went to Manoharan’s house to discuss the dispute. Senthil, who had come there, intervened. The prosecution said Kannan pushed him, picked up a knife from the roof of the house and stabbed him in the right shoulder, left chest and left arm.
Murder charge, culpable homicide conviction
The FIR, on a complaint by Senthil’s wife, was registered under Section 302. The Principal District and Sessions Court, Ariyalur framed a murder charge, and the prosecution examined 16 witnesses and marked 15 exhibits.
On 16 February 2022 the trial court held that murder was not proved and that the act followed a sudden quarrel. It convicted Kannan under Section 304 Part II and sentenced him to ten years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs 4,000.
The defence and the prosecution
P. Tamilavel, for Kannan, said most witnesses had turned hostile and the earliest complaint had been suppressed. He said the wife could not have seen the incident, that the complaint and its despatch to the Magistrate were delayed, and that his client’s injuries were unexplained.
Additional Public Prosecutor Sharada Vivek said the wife’s evidence proved the case and that the accused himself admitted a fight. She added that the defence witness, Kannan’s wife, would naturally support him.
Hostile witnesses and a missing ambulance driver
The judge went through the witnesses. The two men said to have seen the incident and gone to the hospital turned hostile, as did Manoharan and the witnesses to the scene mahazar, the arrest and the alleged confession.
The dead man’s wife, the complainant, said she saw Kannan attack her husband, heard him claim he had killed him, and watched him stamp on the chest and hands of the fallen man. The judge called it strange that the ambulance driver was never examined.
The daughter said she followed her mother and heard Kannan proclaim the killing. The court called her presence highly doubtful because no other witness, including her mother, mentioned her.
A six-hour gap in the FIR
The judge said there was absolutely no reason for the delay in registering the FIR. It reached the Magistrate at 9.45 am. The Constable who carried it said the Sub-Inspector handed it to him only at 8.45 am, and the Sub-Inspector gave no explanation.
The prosecution had not collected any record from the Ariyalur Government Hospital, where the deceased was declared dead. Without it, the court said, nobody knows when the hospital told the police, and the defence had made it probable that the police were at the hospital well before the FIR.
It found it hard to believe that the police first learned of a killing like this only at 3.30 am. It held that the earliest complaint had been suppressed.
The wife who said it was an accident
Kannan’s wife, the sole defence witness, gave a different account. She said the deceased first attacked her when she tried to stop a quarrel, and tried to pull her saree. Kannan intervened, and the deceased hit him with a bamboo stick, cutting his right eyebrow.
In the scuffle that followed, she said, the deceased fell on a sharp bamboo stick. The post-mortem doctor said that a fall on a sharp bamboo stick could cause the injuries found on the body.
The investigating officer admitted that when Kannan was remanded he had an injury on his right eyebrow with stitches. The prosecution never explained it, and the complainant did not say how Kannan got it.
A knife that changed in the witness box
The court also noted that the complainant wavered over the knife. She first said the weapon was bigger than the one shown to her, then agreed it was the same knife. She also said the blade looked new while the handle was old.
The knife was not sent for forensic examination, and the investigating officer admitted it had no blood stains. The defence had suggested that the police bought a new knife to implicate Kannan. The court assumed she could not be discredited on that discrepancy alone.
The judge concluded that the case could not rest on the complainant’s evidence:
“highly unsafe to hold the appellant guilty of the offence” (para 13)
Her presence at the scene was highly doubtful, he said. Kannan’s wife, who was not discredited except by her relationship to the accused, appeared more probable, especially as the appellant had himself been injured.
Order
The appeal was allowed. The conviction and sentence passed on 16 February 2022 by the Principal District and Sessions Judge, Ariyalur, were set aside. Kannan was acquitted.
Any fine paid is to be refunded and his bail bond, if any, stands discharged.