Justice S.K. Sharma Delhi HC MATTER REMANDED A Rs 50 lakh stamp penalty for a four-daydelay goes back to the Collector
[ Delhi High Court ]

Delhi HC sets aside Rs 50 lakh stamp penalty for a four-day delay, sends AM Mining case back

Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma held the Collector of Stamps repeated the same penalty after a remand without saying why it fit, or why the 16 per cent guideline for voluntary filers was not followed. A fresh order is due within two months.

AM Mining India filed for stamp duty adjudication on preference shares worth about Rs 900 crore four days after the statutory window closed. The Collector of Stamps fined it Rs 50 lakh, then fined it Rs 50 lakh again after a remand. On 19 November the Delhi High Court set that second order aside.

Justice Swarana Kanta Sharma did not fix a penalty herself. She told the Collector to decide afresh with reasons within two months, and to credit the duty the company has already paid.

Preference shares and a four-day gap

On 3 May 2023 the company passed a board resolution to issue 21,22,00,000 Class A compulsorily convertible preference shares to ArcelorMittal Nippon Steel India Limited. The face value was Rs 10 and the premium Rs 32.40 a share, totalling Rs 899,72,80,000.

It filed its Form PAS-3 on 4 May 2023. On 5 June 2023 it applied on its own to the Collector of Stamps at Delhi under Sections 31(1) and 32(3)(a) of the Indian Stamp Act, 1899 for adjudication of the duty payable.

The period for that application had run out on 2 June 2023, so the application was four days late. The Collector heard the matter several times and on 17 March 2026 imposed a Rs 50 lakh penalty under Section 40(1)(b), citing the four-day delay and the time value of money.

The first round: a remand with a deposit

The company went to the High Court in W.P.(C) 4172/2026. On 1 April 2026 the court set the penalty order aside, noting that it did not explain why Rs 50 lakh was the only option.

It gave the company another chance to show that no penalty was warranted, on condition that it deposited the admitted principal duty of Rs 89,97,218 within 15 days. The company paid on 23 April 2026.

The Collector heard it again and passed an order on 2 July 2026 with the identical Rs 50 lakh penalty. It also fixed the total payable at Rs 1,39,97,280, with the principal duty at Rs 89,97,280.

What the second order said

The Collector recorded that the company applied about a month after the share certificates were issued and had not paid at the time of allotment. He said it failed to deposit the duty despite repeated notices and gave no satisfactory explanation.

He cited the delay, the substantial revenue involved, the lack of explanation and the continued failure to pay.

The company’s case

Mr Ashim Sood appeared for the company. He argued the order was arbitrary and non-speaking, and contrary to guidelines of 31 January 2024 issued by Respondent No. 2 that limit the penalty to 16 per cent a year for voluntary submissions.

He said the delay was four days and the Collector gave no reason for departing from the guidelines. He also asked that the Rs 89,97,218 already paid be treated as full discharge of the principal duty.

The Union’s answers

Mr Dhananjaya Mishra appeared for the Union of India. He first objected that the Delhi court had no territorial jurisdiction, because the company is registered at AMNS Township, Surat, and the shares were issued in Gujarat.

On merits he said the order followed a fresh hearing as directed on 1 April 2026. Section 40(1)(b), he said, allows a penalty of up to ten times the proper duty, so Rs 50 lakh was well inside the limit.

The company replied that the Collector sits in Delhi, the hearings were held and the order was passed there, and it had already come to this court against the first order in the same proceedings.

Why the Delhi court kept the case

The court noted that the dispute is not about the share issue or the liability to pay duty, which is admitted. The only question is the legality of the penalty.

The material facts, it held, are that the application was presented in Delhi, the Collector heard it in Delhi, and both orders were passed there. The Surat office and the board resolution were, at best, background facts.

Because the court had already heard the challenge to the first order and remanded it, it called itself the most appropriate and convenient forum. It rejected the objection.

Ten times is a ceiling, not a rate

Section 40(1)(b) lets the Collector require the proper duty with a penalty of Rs 5 or, if the Collector thinks fit, an amount not exceeding ten times the duty. The judge read those words to mean that ten times is only the outer limit and that the quantum is a matter of discretion to be exercised judiciously.

She relied on Chilakuri Gangulappa, (2001) 4 SCC 197, where the Supreme Court called ten times the upper limit and said the Collector must weigh all factors.

In Trustees of H.C. Dhanda Trust, (2020) 9 SCC 510, the Supreme Court held that a ten-times penalty is neither automatic nor to be imposed mechanically. Penalty, it said, is deterrence and not retribution.

The judge also cited Hindustan Steel, (1969) 2 SCC 627, which says penalty is not imposed merely because it is lawful.

A coordinate bench applied the same principles on 14 October 2026 in Galwalia Ispat Udyog, a share-allotment stamp case where the company had itself applied late.

Where the Collector’s order fell short

The judge listed the facts in the company’s favour. It had itself come forward under Section 31, the delay was four days, nothing was impounded, and no finding of evasion, fraud or dishonesty had been made.

The second order also blamed the company for a continuing default after the proceedings began. The judge found it did not say for which period, and found no finding that the pendency before the Collector was the company’s doing.

She added that the earlier order was set aside for lack of reasons. The new order added reasons such as the revenue involved, but did not explain how they justified exactly Rs 50 lakh.

The “time value of money” could not carry the penalty either, she held, because the file stayed with the Collector from 5 June 2023 to 17 March 2026 and the respondents named no conduct of the company that caused that delay.

Guidelines and the paid duty

On the 2024 guidelines, the court held that a voluntary applicant makes them a relevant consideration. Even if the Collector wished to depart from them,

“reasons for such departure were required to be recorded” (para 27)

The order recorded none, the judge said, citing Kranti Associates v. Masood Ahmed Khan, (2010) 9 SCC 496. It also proceeded as if the company was still in default although it had deposited the principal duty on 23 April 2026.

She concluded that

“the discretion under Section 40(1)(b) has not been properly exercised by respondent no. 1” (para 29)

She declined to fix the amount herself, since that power lies with the Collector.

Order

The order of 2 July 2026 is set aside insofar as it imposes the Rs 50 lakh penalty. The Collector must reconsider within two months of receiving the order and give the company a hearing.

He must weigh that the company approached the authority voluntarily, the four-day delay, the time the proceedings stayed pending, the later deposit of principal duty, and the 31 January 2024 guidelines. If he imposes any penalty, he must record why that amount is warranted.

The Rs 89,97,218 deposited on 23 April 2026 must be credited while fixing any principal duty payable. The petition and pending applications are disposed of, and the judgment was directed to be uploaded forthwith.