Madras HC ties result of surgery student to a 44-day attendance gap, counting post-June training
Justice K. Surender let a student who wrote her final examination under an interim order have her result once her later attendance covers the shortfall against the 751-day requirement.
A surgeon completing a postgraduate degree has been told that her examination result will be released only when a 44-day attendance gap is closed. On 17 November the Madras High Court, which had earlier let her sit the final paper, directed the college to count her attendance after 30 June 2026 first.
Justice K Surender disposed of the petition of Dr Shruti Yeddula against the medical college and its university examination authorities. The order lets the result come out forthwith if later attendance covers the shortfall.
The dispute
The petitioner completed her MBBS at SRM Medical College Hospital and Research Centre in 2022. She began an MS in General Surgery at Chettinad Hospital and Research Institute in September 2023.
Before the third-year university examination on 3 August 2026, she could not pay the fee online or generate a hall ticket. She was told she had not met minimum attendance.
The interim order and the figures
On 31 July 2026 the court allowed her to write the examination and directed the respondents to enable the fee payment and issue the hall ticket. It said no equities would arise from this and the arrangement was subject to the final outcome.
She wrote the paper, and the university withheld her result. She wants it declared so that she can apply for a Super Specialty course, and the last date for fee payment for that examination was 18 November.
A three-year postgraduate course requires attendance on 751 of 939 working days, or 80 per cent. The National Medical Commission regulations of 2023 say training must be extended by the number of days of excess leave, so that attendance is made up.
The university said she was present on only 707 days up to a cut-off of 30 June 2026, a shortfall of 44 days.
Registers against biometrics
The petitioner’s counsel, Ms S Varsha, said the manual attendance register showed more than 751 days and pointed to discrepancies with the biometric records. The respondents said the biometric system is indisputable.
They added that she entered the premises but did not attend classes regularly. Mr M S Krishnan, Senior Advocate, appeared for the Dean.
The court found that biometric attendance cannot be tampered with. It asked about several days that showed a total duration of 00.00 hours, and the respondents explained that she punched in and out at the same time.
Counsel fairly told the court that those days were already included in the 707 days credited to her. The court did not decide the discrepancy between registers and biometrics.
Making up the 44 days
The court noted that the interim order specifically said she could not insist on her result until the petition was disposed of. Given the nature of the course and the minimum attendance set after due consideration by the National Medical Commission, it said the ends of justice would be met if the petitioner was required to:
“make up the alleged attendance shortfall of 44 days” (para 13)
Her counsel said she had attended in July 2026 and afterwards, which would bring her to 751 days. The respondents agreed that attendance after 30 June would be counted.
Order
The respondents must take her attendance after 30 June 2026 into account. If it makes up the 44-day shortfall, the result must be published forthwith.
If she has not yet made up the full shortfall as of the date of the order, the result must be published forthwith once she completes the remaining days of training. The writ petition is disposed of with no order as to costs.