Justice G. Jayachandran Justice E. Manoharan Madras HC PETITION DISMISSED Graduate quota for inspectorposts survives challenge
[ Madras High Court ]

Madras HC upholds 25% graduate quota for bus corporation inspector posts, rejecting union plea

A Division Bench said the quota in the Common Service Rules rests on education, level and group, and is flexible enough to be revised through settlements, so it does not offend Articles 14 or 16.

A union that challenged a 25 per cent graduate quota for promotions in Tamil Nadu’s state bus corporations has lost its 2008 writ petition. On 17 November a Division Bench of the Madras High Court held that the quota is a reasonable classification, not a breach of equality.

Dr Justice G Jayachandran and Justice E Manoharan dismissed the petition of the Tamil Nadu Government Transport Corporations Staff Federation. The Bench said the rule is flexible and has been revised through settlements with unions.

The rule under challenge

The federation challenged sub-rule 4(a) and (b) of Part C of Appendix II, read with Rule 59(b) of the Common Service Rules. The rules came into effect on 22 May 1987 and give graduates a 25 per cent quota for posts at and above the supervisory level in the Traffic, Administrative and Technical categories.

The federation said a 1977 settlement under Section 12(3) had fixed merit-cum-seniority as the policy for supervisory promotions. It called a graduate quota inconsistent with that settlement.

What the union argued

Its counsel, Mr V Govardhanan, relied on an industrial award of 1997 in a dispute that had begun in 1991. The award had upheld the settlement as binding on both sides when Senior Assistants who were graduates sought a quota.

The union said the same logic should cover Special Grade Conductors seeking promotion to Checking Inspector. As the union described the paragraph, 25 per cent of the posts of Checking Inspector were earmarked for conductors holding a degree in Arts, Science or Commerce, with the remaining 75 per cent filled by seniority.

What the corporations said

The Government and the corporations raised two objections. A trade union, they argued, cannot sue for one group of employees against another, particularly one that lost the recognition election.

They said a fresh Section 12(3) settlement on 8 January 2011 with the winning union and other recognised unions had already dealt with supervisory promotions. They added that graduate Senior Conductors, who would be affected, were not made parties.

The graduates had once gone to court to enforce the 25 per cent quota. That petition was dismissed as withdrawn after the management undertook to implement it.

On the merits, the respondents said quotas for graduates and non-graduates are permissible if distribution is fair, and that each distinct group needs promotion chances in proportion to its numbers. They pointed out that the rule had operated for 24 years with variations settled through the 12(3) process.

Differentia the Bench found

The Bench applied the test for a challenge to a rule’s validity: intelligible differentia and reasonableness, without arbitrariness. It noted that the Common Service Rules leave divisions free to modify them with Board approval.

It then read the paragraphs. For Checking Inspector and Junior Checking Inspector posts, direct recruits and promotees share the posts in a ratio of 3:1. Within the promotee share, three-quarters is split between two groups of Selection Grade Conductors.

The remaining quarter goes to Senior Conductors with a degree in Arts, Science or Commerce for first-level posts, or to direct recruitment. The Bench said the rule rests on education, level of post and the group the employee belongs to, so it makes a real differentia.

Quotas and equality of opportunity

The Bench relied on a Constitution Bench ruling, State of Mysore v P Narasinga Rao (AIR 1968 SC 349), which says Article 16 permits reasonable classification of employees for appointment and promotion. That ruling in turn quotes General Manager, Southern Railway v Rangachari on equality of opportunity.

It held that where one feeder category mixes grades, levels and qualifications, reserving shares in proportion to their strength is one way to ensure equality as far as possible. It said graduate quotas are:

“not an alien concept in Indian Service Jurisprudence” (para 12)

The judgment does not separately rule on the objections about the union’s standing and the missing parties. It decided the petition on the validity of the rule.

Order

The Bench held the rule is neither arbitrary nor discriminatory and cannot be declared void. It stressed that the rule is not rigid and has been changed by settlement between the Managing Directors of the corporations and union representatives.

The writ petition is dismissed with no order as to costs, and the connected miscellaneous petition is closed. Mr K Rajesh, Government Advocate, appeared for the State, and Mr C Senapathi and Mr A Sundaravadhanan for the Kumbakonam and Coimbatore corporations.