Madras HC faults Master for marking nine papers as one exhibit but keeps disputed deed on record
Justice N. Anand Venkatesh said a typed set of nine documents should not have been marked as one exhibit in cross-examination, yet held the disputed partition deed had separately come in through another defendant.
A bundle of nine documents was marked as a single exhibit during a defendant’s cross-examination in a Chennai partition suit. On 17 November the Madras High Court called that practice unheard of and criticised the Master who allowed it, yet it left in place a disputed partition deed that sat inside the bundle.
Justice N Anand Venkatesh dismissed a challenge under Article 227 to a City Civil Court order that refused to eschew the exhibit. He held that the disputed deed had also been marked separately through another witness.
The suit and the disputed deed
The plaintiffs, Chithra Balakrishnan and another, sued for partition and allotment of 714 square feet in a property and for a permanent injunction. The suit began on the Original Side of the High Court as C.S.No.848 of 2014 and was tried before an Additional Master.
It was later transferred to the City Civil Court at Chennai and renumbered O.S.No.5499 of 2019. The petitioner, V Radhakrishnan, is the second defendant.
The document in dispute is a copy of a deed of declaration confirming an oral partition, dated 21 June 2002, among V Balakrishnan, V Rangarajan and V Radhakrishnan. The petitioner denied it.
Objection, a 2018 order and a bundle
When the plaintiffs tried to mark the deed through the petitioner while he was being cross-examined, he objected. A Single Judge rejected the plaintiffs’ application to do so on 27 September 2018. The order left it open to them to mark the deed through their own witness.
On 1 November 2018, cross-examination of the petitioner went on, and a typed set of documents was marked as Ex.P.11 over his objection. The set had been filed by the first defendant in his own suit. The petitioner said the deed had been brought on record indirectly, in violation of the 2018 order.
The Master’s procedure
The High Court called for the records and found that the entire typed set had been marked as one exhibit. It contained nearly nine independent documents, including the 2002 deed.
Justice Venkatesh expressed displeasure at the Master. He said the procedure was:
“unheard of” (para 13)
He added that the Master is virtually unable to decide anything during trial and mistakes are made in marking documents.
What cross-examination exhibits are for
The court explained the place of such marking. Section 145 of the Indian Evidence Act, now Section 148 of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023, lets a cross-examiner contradict a witness with a prior written statement.
That is done mainly to impeach the witness’s credit and not as substantive proof of facts. In this case the whole set was marked without explaining the contradiction sought, so its evidentiary value became questionable.
Why the deed stayed
The court then turned to the actual question. The deed had also been marked through D.W.2, who was the first defendant. He admitted it existed and supported the plaintiffs, so he was taken as a witness for them.
Marking it through him was therefore not, in itself, a violation of the 2018 order. The City Civil Court had noted that relevancy and proof would be considered independently and that the petitioner raised his objection only at final arguments.
The High Court said the deed was independently marked, and that even if the typed set as a whole was questionable, the deed’s marking through D.W.2 must be separately assessed. The City Civil Court’s refusal to eschew it:
“cannot be held to be perverse or illegal” (para 21)
The petitioner remained free to question the deed’s evidentiary value before that court.
Order
The civil revision petition is disposed of, and the City Civil Court’s order of 9 October 2025 in I.A.No.9 of 2025 is sustained. There is no order as to costs, and the connected petition is closed.
The first defendant died during the revision, and his legal heirs were brought on record on 12 November. Mr N Suresh appeared for the petitioner and Mr B Ravi for the first respondent.