Justice H. Tandon Justice C. Dash Orissa HC CUSTODY REFUSED A mother in Hanoi, a daughter inJajpur
[ Orissa High Court ]

Orissa HC refuses Philippine mother custody of her toddler, orders daily video calls

A Division Bench led by Chief Justice Harish Tandon held a habeas corpus petition maintainable against a parent but declined to hand a girl born in Bengaluru in 2023 to her Philippine mother, leaving her with her paternal grandparents and ordering daily video calls and father-funded visits.

A kindergarten teacher in Hanoi asked the Orissa High Court for her toddler daughter, who has lived with her paternal grandparents since a few months after birth. On 10 November 2026 the court refused, but ordered daily video calls and time with the girl whenever the mother visits India.

Chief Justice Harish Tandon, writing for a Bench with Justice Chittaranjan Dash, held that the habeas corpus petition was maintainable. On the merits, it said the child’s welfare did not call for a change of custody.

A girl born in Bengaluru, raised in Jajpur

The petitioner, Ms Nenelle Beronilla Dayandayan, is a Philippine citizen who works in Hanoi as a kindergarten teacher. She had a long live-in relationship with Mr Mrutunjaya Kar, and their daughter was born in Bengaluru on 26 November 2023.

The birth certificate names both as parents. The relationship broke down, and the girl stayed in India as an Indian citizen. Her passport was granted on 1 January 2026.

The mother said she was not allowed to meet the child, even on video calls. When neighbours helped her see the girl on screen, she said, the child did not seem to be properly looked after.

She also said the relationship rested on a misrepresentation, because Mr Kar had concealed an earlier relationship and a child from it.

Care, a visa and a custody agreement

The mother said she had done everything a mother does after the birth, including breastfeeding, daily care and vaccination. When her visa was rejected rather than extended, she went back to her country.

She alleged that Mr Kar then put the child with his parents at Jajpur, and that he travels often to Singapore and other countries. When he is in India, she said, he is in Bengaluru.

Mr Kar, a principal technology architect with Lumen Technologies Singapore, said he visits his parents’ house often and looks after the girl. He said the mother knew the grandparents were caring for the child, and that an agreement kept custody with him.

He added that the girl goes to kindergarten and is well cared for. The mother, he said, has children from an earlier marriage in the Philippines, works in Vietnam on a work visa and has no one to look after the child while she works.

He relied on WhatsApp chats to show the mother agreed the grandparents should keep the child. In her rejoinder she did not deny the agreement. She said it was signed under coercion.

Mr Rajat Kumar Panda appeared for the mother, and Mr Gautam Mukherji, Senior Advocate, for Opposite Parties 1 to 3.

Habeas corpus against a parent

The opposite parties argued that habeas corpus did not lie, since the custody was not illegal or unlawful. The Bench said the point needed no deep scrutiny. Courts, including the Supreme Court, have held the writ maintainable for the custody of a child held by a parent.

It relied on Yashita Sahu v. State of Rajasthan, decided on 20 January 2020. There the Supreme Court called it too late in the day to say a habeas corpus petition fails because the child is with the other parent.

The court cited Nithya Anand Raghavan (2017) and Kanika Goel (2018) on the same line. Those say the question is the child’s best interest, and that the order of a foreign court must yield to the child’s welfare.

From Rajeswari Chandrasekar Ganesh v. State of Tamil Nadu (2022) it drew that the jurisdiction is inherent and not tied to any statute. It rests on the court’s parens patriae role.

It also cited Vivek Kumar Chaturvedi v. State of U.P. (2025 INSC 159), which says there is no hard and fast rule on maintainability. That depends on the facts of each case.

Natural guardian status does not decide welfare

The Bench said every judgment cited by the parties holds that the court is not to be swayed by the fact that a parent is the natural guardian. The paramount consideration is the child’s welfare.

Where a foreign court has taken up a custody matter, it noted, the Supreme Court has applied comity of courts. But the child’s best interest must still be borne in mind. If a change would harm the child, nothing stops the court from declining custody.

The court said best interest cannot be put into a straitjacket formula or treated as a Euclidean theorem. It relied on Vivek Singh v. Romani Singh (2017) for the idea that the child’s optimal growth and development comes first.

Welfare, it said, covers psychological, spiritual and emotional wellbeing, and not only physical comfort or material advantage.

Why the grandparents keep the girl

On the facts, the girl lives with her grandparents, who care for her, and is an Indian citizen. Mr Kar visits often, and the mother talks to the child on video calls, though she says she is sometimes denied them.

The Bench also weighed two further facts. The mother is a Philippine citizen earning her living in Vietnam, and no one else can look after the child while she is at work. She also has other children from a first marriage who live in the Philippines.

The court said it would not be conducive for the girl’s development to live in another country when she is a citizen of India. It added that, in Indian society, grandparents play a very important role in a child’s development.

The photographs filed with the petition showed no sign of a psychological problem, and the child looked happy. The Bench held:

“uprooting the child from the settled position could invite a cascading effect on her” (para 20)

The court did not rule on the mother’s claim that she signed the custody agreement under coercion, or on her allegation of misrepresentation.

Order

The prayer for custody is refused. The mother, the Bench said, has every right to visit and interact with her daughter, and it is inconceivable that she would be denied that.

The opposite parties must let her speak to the child on video call every day, according to the child’s routine. The calls must cause no discomfort and must not disturb her sleep.

When the mother visits India, she may spend time with the girl, including exclusive time, and the child is to be handed back to the grandparents before she returns to Vietnam or the Philippines.

Mr Kar must provide her air tickets and her stay in Odisha, and all other facilities for the visit. The petition was disposed of on those terms.