Telangana HC lifts freeze on liquor privilege fee for 50 bars as interim order gave no reasons
A Division Bench said the single judge never explained why the 19 October Government Order was untenable and sent the writ petition back so the State can file its counter before a fresh decision.
A single judge froze a new liquor privilege fee for 50 Warangal and Hanamkonda bar licensees on 30 October. On 13 November a Division Bench of the Telangana High Court set that interim order aside, saying it did not explain why the Government Order was legally untenable.
The Division Bench of Acting Chief Justice P Sam Koshy and Justice Suddala Chalapathi Rao partly allowed the State’s writ appeal. It did not decide whether the privilege fee is valid. It sent the writ petition back for a fresh decision after the State files its counter-affidavit.
What the Government Order did
The writ petition challenged G.O.Ms.No.205 of the Revenue (Excise-II) Department, dated 19 October 2026, and a consequential circular of 22 October. According to the judgment, the Order introduced Rule 13-A into the earlier Government Orders and levied a privilege fee on licensees selling Indian-made foreign liquor (IMFL) and foreign liquor.
The respondents in the appeal are 50 licensed rest-and-bar businesses in Warangal and Hanamkonda. They were the writ petitioners before the single judge.
The appellants are the State of Telangana, the Commissioner of Prohibition and Excise, the Telangana State Beverages Corporation Limited (TGBCL) and its General Manager (MIS).
What the single judge ordered on 30 October
On 30 October the single judge issued notice before admission and listed the matter for 27 November. The order said the matter required further hearing.
In the meantime, it suspended the Government Order and the circular insofar as the petitioners were concerned. It directed the respondents to process the petitioners’ indents and supply IMFL and foreign liquor at the same issue price charged to A4 shop licensees until 27 November.
The State appealed under clause 15 of the Letters Patent. It also asked, in an interlocutory application, that the interim order be suspended while the appeal was pending.
The State: an addendum, and no reasons
Mr Mohd Imran Khan, Additional Advocate General, argued that the privilege fee was only an addendum to the earlier Government Orders. He said the single judge had assigned no specific reasons for finding the Order and circular contrary to law.
He submitted that the judge ought at least to have recorded a prima facie satisfaction. Without such reasons, he said, the interim order was liable to be set aside.
He also made it clear that the fee is levied only from the date of the Government Order, 19 October 2026. The licences have been in force since 1 October 2026, he said, and the Order does not enhance the licence fee. It levies only a privilege fee.
The licensees: renewal came first
Mr P Vishnuvardhan Reddy, Senior Counsel, appeared for the respondents with Mr Sai Dev Rohan Yasala. He said that their licences were renewed from 1 October 2026 after they paid 25 per cent of the licence fee on 30 September. The renewed licences run to 30 September 2027.
Imposing a privilege fee after renewal, he argued, would give the Government Order retrospective effect. It would load an additional financial burden on licensees that the prescribed procedure does not permit.
He relied on a Bombay High Court decision, Deepak v State of Maharashtra, which he said held retrospective imposition of such a fee impermissible.
He also argued that the intra-court appeal was not maintainable, because the State could instead apply to the single judge to vacate the order. The judgment does not rule on that objection separately.
Why the bench found the order unsustainable
Justice Rao, writing for the bench, began with what the single judge had not done. The bench found that the order did not explain how the Government Order was either erroneous or untenable.
The bench added that regulating excise policy is a subject in the State List, and that the State may regulate the sale of IMFL and foreign liquor. The Government Order was issued on 19 October 2026, and the State had been collecting the fee from that date.
Where the validity of a Government Order is under challenge, the bench said, a judge considering such relief should assign proper reasons and record specific findings. Here the judge should have said why the Order was not legally valid or was untenable.
The single judge had also observed that the matter needed further hearing. In that situation, the bench said, the State should have been allowed to file its counter-affidavit before a speaking order was passed after hearing both sides.
On retrospectivity, the bench noted that the Government Order imposes the privilege fee from its own date and does not enhance the licence fee so as to make it retrospective. It concluded that the interim order was:
“bereft of reasons and findings” (para 13)
Order
The writ appeal is partly allowed. The interim order of 30 October 2026 in W.P.No.36428 of 2026 is set aside and the matter is remanded to the single judge.
The single judge must give the State an opportunity to file its counter-affidavit. The writ petition is then to be decided afresh after hearing both sides.
There is no order as to costs, and pending miscellaneous petitions stand closed.