Madras HC quashes Namakkal patta cancellation: an inheritance dispute is for the civil court
Justice K. Surender held that a revenue divisional officer could not cancel a brother patta and enter his nephew as co-owner while the dispute over shares was unresolved. Title stays open for civil courts.
A revenue divisional officer in Namakkal cancelled a farmer’s patta over two survey numbers, restored his late father’s name and, within weeks, a nephew was entered as joint owner. On 18 November the Madras High Court quashed both steps, holding that a dispute over inheritance is for the civil court and not for a revenue officer.
Justice K. Surender allowed the writ petition in part. The farmer’s patta entries return as they stood, but the court did not declare who owns what.
A father’s land and two claimants
The land is 1.40.0 hectares in S.No.180/1 and 0.72.5 hectares in S.No.188/1 of Peramandampalayam village, Mohanur Taluk. It stood in the name of Kaliyanna Gounder under UDR Patta No.90, and he died on 3 October 1989.
His son, the petitioner, and his daughter, the sixth respondent, are the heirs. The revenue records later showed both survey numbers in the son’s name under Patta No.1136. He says his sisters orally gave up their rights in his favour.
The daughter sued for possession in O.S.No.154 of 2015 before the Additional Subordinate Court, Namakkal. She claimed a one-fifth share under an oral partition and said her brother had dispossessed her.
What the civil decree did not decide
On 29 February 2024 the civil court dismissed her suit without costs. She had not proved the oral allotment, it held, and the brother had not proved the oral relinquishment. It recorded that he was in possession and enjoyment.
The decree carried no declaration of exclusive title for him and did not fix anyone’s share by succession. The High Court read the judgment as a whole and found that possession was refused because her pleaded case failed.
Cancelled by the revenue divisional officer
After the suit failed, the sister petitioned the District Collector at a grievance meeting on 11 March 2024. She asked to be added to the patta on the strength of a legal heirship certificate.
The Revenue Divisional Officer obtained a Tahsildar’s report of 16 May 2024 and held enquiries on 30 May and 14 June. The village officer reported that the UDR register still showed Patta No.90 in the father’s name, while the computerised chitta showed the brother, who was in possession.
By an order of 27 June 2024 the officer cancelled the entries in Patta No.1136 and restored the father’s name.
He relied on the absence of a traceable order for the earlier mutation and on the brother’s failure to produce a release deed from the father. The parties were left free to apply for inclusion on the heirship certificate.
On 8 July 2024 the sister executed a registered gift settlement deed, No.1763 of 2024, in favour of her son, the seventh respondent. A mutation of 14 July 2024 under Patta No.2306 then showed the father and the nephew as joint pattadars, with no separate one-fifth share specified.
The brother challenged the officer’s order on 16 July 2024. The District Revenue Officer treated it as a revision, held enquiries on 25 November 2024 and 6 January 2025, and confirmed the cancellation on 10 January 2025. He did not separately decide whether the nephew’s entry could stand.
The patta rules and the Supreme Court
Section 10 of the Tamil Nadu Patta Pass Book Act, 1983 allows entries to be modified on death or transfer. Rule 4(4) of the 1987 Rules requires the parties to get a ruling on ownership from the competent civil court before existing entries change, where the dispute involves succession and the interested parties have not agreed in writing.
Under the proviso to Section 14, a person aggrieved by an entry may seek a declaration against the rival claimant. The entry is then amended in line with it.
The court relied on Edelweiss Asset Construction v. Perumalswamy, (2021) 11 SCC 98, paragraphs 17 to 19. There the Supreme Court held that title underlying a patta entry must be decided by the civil court.
It also cited a Division Bench ruling in Vishwas Footwear v. District Collector, Kancheepuram, 2011 (5) CTC 94. That ruling restored a prior patta pending the civil court’s decision.
Why the revenue orders fell
The sixth respondent said in her counter-affidavit that she is entitled to a one-fifth share, that the parties were heard in the revenue proceedings, and that her settlement covers only her share. The court framed the issue this way:
“whether the revenue authorities could alter the existing entries while those claims remained unresolved” (para 9)
It answered no. A genuine dispute was plain from her representation, the objections and the civil judgment. A missing transfer order called for verification, but did not show that the entry was a clerical error or made without authority.
The legal heirship certificate, the court said, names the heirs without resolving their rights in these lands. The existing entry had been displaced on grounds that rested on competing claims of devolution and relinquishment, and in the court’s words,
“Rule 4(4) required those claims to be left to the competent civil court.” (para 12)
The District Revenue Officer’s confirmation, it held, suffered from the same jurisdictional error.
What the civil decrees left open
The failure of the sister’s plea of oral partition did not wipe out any interest she may have by succession, the court said. The failure of the brother’s plea of oral relinquishment did not prove her one-fifth share either.
An appellate decree of 19 December 2024 in A.S.No.19 of 2023, arising from O.S.No.171 of 2016, dealt with a common pathway and confined its mandatory injunction to S.No.187/2B. It decided nothing on shares in the two survey numbers before the High Court.
The nephew’s patta
The nephew claims through his mother. A registered gift settlement operates only to the extent of the donor’s transferable interest, the court said, and registration does not prove the donor’s title or its extent.
His Patta No.2306 was made on the strength of the revenue officer’s order and the settlement deed. It could not survive once its revenue basis was set aside. The brother’s complaint that he got no notice of that mutation was left undecided.
The court also noted that the brother had already used the revision route before the District Revenue Officer. The counter-affidavit identified no provision for a further appeal to the Government.
Order
The writ petition is allowed in part. The orders of 27 June 2024 and 10 January 2025 are quashed insofar as they concern S.Nos.180/1 and 188/1, and the entries under Patta No.2306 for those numbers are set aside.
The Tahsildar, the third respondent, must restore the revenue entries as they stood under Patta No.1136 immediately before the 27 June 2024 order. That is subject to any subsisting decree or order of a competent civil court governing the entries.
The restoration is confined to the revenue records. Title, shares, partition and the effect of Gift Settlement Deed No.1763 of 2024 are left for civil proceedings, subject to the findings and decree in O.S.No.154 of 2015.
The pathway decree, as modified in A.S.No.19 of 2023, is to be given effect according to its terms. There is no order as to costs, and the connected miscellaneous petition is closed.