Justice M.K. Tiwari Justice S. Upadhyay Uttarakhand HC PETITION DISPOSED Gratuity recovery stays barred
[ Uttarakhand High Court ]

Uttarakhand HC keeps Rs 23 lakh recovery off constable gratuity, but lets State refix pension

A Division Bench declined to disturb a tribunal order quashing the recovery of Rs 23,08,264 from a retired constable, noting the State alleged no fraud and no refund undertaking, and let the State refix his pay and pension within ten weeks.

A retired Uttarakhand constable keeps the protection a tribunal gave him against a recovery of Rs 23,08,264 from his gratuity. On 17 November the Uttarakhand High Court refused to interfere, noting that the State had not alleged fraud or said he ever promised to refund an overpayment.

The Division Bench of Acting Chief Justice Manoj Kumar Tiwari and Justice Subhash Upadhyay made one change. Because the retired man did not object, the State may now refix his pay and pension.

Rs 23 lakh demanded from retiral dues

Gokulanand Pathak retired as a constable on 31 December 2022. His pension and other retiral dues were then withheld.

By an order of 1 June 2023, the department asked him to deposit Rs 23,08,264 as excess payment, or to give an undertaking that it could be recovered from his gratuity.

He went to the Uttarakhand Public Services Tribunal in Claim Petition No. 94/NB/DB/2023. On 20 December 2024 the tribunal allowed his petition, set aside the order of 1 June 2023 and directed the State to release his pension and all other retiral dues within 60 days.

The tribunal recorded that there was no misrepresentation by the constable in the excess payment made to him. It held his case squarely covered by the Supreme Court’s decision in State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer), (2015) 4 SCC 334.

The State’s case: 19 punishments

The State then came to the High Court under writ jurisdiction. Mr Ganesh Datt Kandpal, Additional Advocate General, appeared for it, and Dr Kartikey Hari Gupta for Mr Pathak.

Mr Kandpal said as many as 19 punishments were imposed on the constable between 1997 and 2003. He argued that Mr Pathak was therefore well aware he was not entitled to the amount he received as salary.

Yet, the State said, he never told the departmental authorities about the excess. He was equally responsible for the overpayment, it argued, and the competent authority was justified in recovering the money.

No fraud, no undertaking

Justice Tiwari, who wrote the judgment, noted that the tribunal had considered the matter in detail. It had relied on Rafiq Masih, and in paragraph 6 of its judgment it had noted the State’s own submission that the controversy was covered by that decision.

The Bench then listed what the State had not said. It was not the State’s case that Mr Pathak had played fraud to receive the excess amount, or had been instrumental in getting it released in his favour.

Nor was it the State’s case that he had given an undertaking before the tribunal to refund the excess if he was found not entitled to it. In the absence of any such pleading, the Bench held:

“we do not find any reason to interfere” (para 5)

It added that there was “hardly any scope for interference” in the tribunal’s judgment. The High Court did not itself restate the rule in Rafiq Masih.

The one concession on pay refixation

The Bench recorded one point from the respondent’s side. In paragraph 4 of his rejoinder affidavit before the tribunal, Mr Pathak had stated categorically that he did not wish to contest the refixation of his pay or salary.

Dr Gupta told the court he had instructions that his client had no objection to refixation of pension based on refixation of pay, if made by the competent authority. The Bench disposed of the petition on that footing.

Order

The writ petition is disposed of. It is open to the competent authority to refix the pay and pension of Mr Pathak and release all retiral dues to him.

The authority must do so within ten weeks from the date a certified copy of the order is presented.