LegalRepublic.in
LegalRepublic.in › Student Corner › BNS

MCQs

20 questions 20 minutes +1 correct · −0.25 wrong · 0 blank Read first: the explainer

Before you begin

  1. Answer in any order. Use the numbers on the right to jump between questions.
  2. Mark a question for review if you want to come back to it.
  3. Each correct answer gets 1 mark and each wrong answer loses a quarter mark. A question left blank scores zero, so skip when unsure.
  4. Submit when you are done. You will see your score, then every question with the correct answer and why.
  5. Nothing you do here is saved or sent anywhere.
15:00 0 of 15 answered
Question 1

    0 / 15
    Correct 0 Wrong 0 Blank 0 Time 0:00

    All 20 questions with answers

    Prefer to read? Every question is listed here; open a question to see the answer and why.

    1. Section 45 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023, which defines when a person abets the doing of a thing, corresponds to which section of the Indian Penal Code, 1860?

    1. Section 108
    2. Section 109
    3. Section 107
    4. Section 120A
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) Section 107

    Section 45 BNS carries over Section 107 IPC, which defined abetment through instigation, conspiracy and intentional aid. The only change is that 'Court of Justice' in the illustration now reads 'Court'. Section 108 IPC is the definition of an abettor (now Section 46), Section 109 IPC is the punishment where the act is committed (now Section 49), and Section 120A is criminal conspiracy (now Section 61).

    Authority: Section 45 BNS; Section 107 IPC

    2. Where a person abets an offence punishable with imprisonment, and the offence is not committed in consequence of the abetment, no express provision being made for it, what is the ordinary ceiling of imprisonment under Section 56 BNS?

    1. One-fourth of the longest term provided for that offence
    2. One-eighth of the longest term provided for that offence
    3. One-third of the longest term provided for that offence
    4. One-half of the longest term provided for that offence
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) One-fourth of the longest term provided for that offence

    Section 56 BNS fixes the ordinary ceiling at one-fourth of the longest term provided for the offence abetted. One-half applies only where the abettor or the person abetted is a public servant whose duty it was to prevent the offence. One-eighth is the figure in Section 60(b) for concealing a design to commit an imprisonable offence that is not committed.

    Authority: Sections 56 and 60 BNS

    3. Under Section 54 BNS, a person who would be punishable as an abettor if absent, and who is present when the act or offence abetted is committed, is:

    1. Liable only to the lower punishment for abetment of an offence not committed
    2. Liable only if the principal offender is also convicted
    3. Liable only for the offence of criminal conspiracy under Section 61
    4. Deemed to have committed the act or offence himself
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) Deemed to have committed the act or offence himself

    Section 54 BNS provides that whenever a person who would be punishable as an abettor if absent is present when the act or offence is committed, he is deemed to have committed it. The Privy Council in Barendra Kumar Ghosh treated prior abetment plus presence as participation. The lower scales in Sections 55 and 56 apply only where the offence is not committed.

    Authority: Section 54 BNS; Barendra Kumar Ghosh v King Emperor, AIR 1925 PC 1

    4. A instigates B to slap Z during a village fair. B, who has his own reasons to be rid of Z, instead returns that evening with a country-made pistol and shoots Z dead. Is A liable for the murder of Z?

    1. Yes. Z's death resulted from A's instigation, so A is liable for murder under Section 49
    2. No. Shooting Z was not a probable consequence of an instigation to slap him, so Section 51 does not reach A for the killing
    3. Yes. B acted with a different intention from A, so Section 50 makes A liable for the graver offence
    4. Only if A was present at the fair when B fired, in which case Section 54 applies
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) No. Shooting Z was not a probable consequence of an instigation to slap him, so Section 51 does not reach A for the killing

    Under Section 51 an abettor is liable for a different act only if it was a probable consequence of the abetment and was done under its influence. Shooting a man dead is not a probable consequence of an instigation to slap. Section 50 deals with the same act done with a different intention, and Section 54 needs presence at the offence, so both options are wrong.

    Authority: Sections 49, 50, 51 and 54 BNS

    5. A, intending to kill Z, gives a loaded pistol to B, a child of six, and tells him to point it at the man in the red shirt and press the trigger. A then leaves. B does so, and Z, who wears a red shirt, dies. Which statement is correct?

    1. A is not liable, because B, being under seven, committed no offence for A to abet
    2. A is liable as an abettor and is punished as if B had been capable by law of committing the offence and had committed murder
    3. A is liable only under Section 55, since no offence was committed in consequence of the abetment
    4. A is liable only for culpable homicide, since he was absent when Z was shot
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) A is liable as an abettor and is punished as if B had been capable by law of committing the offence and had committed murder

    Explanation 3 to Section 46 says the person abetted need not be capable by law of committing an offence. Illustration (b) to that Explanation gives nearly this case: the abettor is punished as if the child had committed murder. Absence is irrelevant, and Section 55 applies only where the offence is not committed, whereas here Z died in consequence of the abetment.

    Authority: Section 46, Explanation 3 and Illustration (b); Section 49 BNS

    6. A and B plan a robbery on a jeweller and agree that B shall bring the weapons. B, without naming A, tells C of the plan, and C agrees to supply a pistol, which he delivers to B. A and B then commit the robbery with it. C never met A. Is C an abettor of the robbery?

    1. No. An abettor by conspiracy must have concerted the offence with the person who actually commits it
    2. No. C is liable only for criminal conspiracy, because he was not present at the robbery
    3. Yes, but only if C knew A's name, which would show a common design with the principal
    4. Yes. It is enough that C engaged in the conspiracy in pursuance of which the robbery was committed
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) Yes. It is enough that C engaged in the conspiracy in pursuance of which the robbery was committed

    Explanation 5 to Section 45 BNS says that abetment by conspiracy does not require the abettor to concert the offence with the person who commits it; it is sufficient if he engages in the conspiracy in pursuance of which the offence is committed. C agreed and supplied the pistol, which is an act in pursuance of the plan, so he is an abettor even though he never met A.

    Authority: Section 45(b) and Explanation 5 BNS

    7. P and Q meet at a tea stall and agree to murder R. Nothing further is done by either of them, and they abandon the idea the next day. Which statement is correct?

    1. They are not abettors by conspiracy, since no act or illegal omission took place in pursuance of the plan, but they are liable for criminal conspiracy under Section 61
    2. Both are liable for abetment by conspiracy under Section 45(b), because the agreement itself is the abetment
    3. Both are liable for attempt to murder under Section 109, because they agreed to commit murder
    4. Neither is liable for anything, since a bare agreement to murder is not an offence
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) They are not abettors by conspiracy, since no act or illegal omission took place in pursuance of the plan, but they are liable for criminal conspiracy under Section 61

    Section 45(b) makes conspiracy abetment only if an act or illegal omission takes place in pursuance of the plan. But Section 61 criminal conspiracy is complete on an agreement to commit an offence (the proviso needs an extra act only for non-offence agreements), and a murder conspiracy is punished as if abetted. So P and Q are liable under Section 61 though not as abettors (Pramatha Nath).

    Authority: Section 45(b) and Section 61 BNS; Pramatha Nath v Saroj Ranjan, AIR 1962 SC 876

    8. Ravi, a passer-by with no official or contractual role, sees two men beat Y with rods outside a shop. He stops to watch for some minutes, says nothing, does not call anyone, and walks on. Y dies. Is Ravi liable as an abettor of the murder?

    1. Yes. By watching the attack he aided it by an omission, which is abetment under Section 45(c)
    2. Yes. Section 54 treats a person present at the offence as having committed it
    3. No. Presence and silence, without intention to aid and without any legal duty to act, are not intentional aid by an illegal omission
    4. Yes, but only to the extent of one-fourth of the punishment for murder under Section 56
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) No. Presence and silence, without intention to aid and without any legal duty to act, are not intentional aid by an illegal omission

    Abetment by aid needs an act or an illegal omission done intentionally to help the offence. An omission is illegal only where the person was bound by law to act, as in Ram Kumar v State of HP (constable on guard duty). Ravi had no such duty and no intention to help. Section 54 applies only to a person who would be an abettor if absent.

    Authority: Section 45(c) BNS; Ram Kumar v State of HP, AIR 1995 SC 1965

    9. A, desiring the death of Z, persuades B that striking Z once on the head with an iron rod is only a harmless prank, and B does so without any intention or knowledge that death is likely. Z dies. Under Section 50 BNS, how is A to be punished?

    1. Only with the punishment for B's offence, which depends on B's intention or knowledge
    2. Under Section 56, as an abettor of an offence which was not committed
    3. Not at all, since B had no guilty mind and no offence by B can be abetted
    4. With the punishment for the offence that would have been committed had the act been done with A's own intention or knowledge
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) With the punishment for the offence that would have been committed had the act been done with A's own intention or knowledge

    Section 50 BNS applies where the person abetted acts with a different intention or knowledge. The abettor is punished for the offence that would have been committed if the act had been done with his own intention or knowledge and no other. Explanation 3 to Section 46 confirms that the person abetted need not have any guilty intention. A therefore answers for murder.

    Authority: Sections 46 (Explanation 3) and 50 BNS

    10. Head Constable H instigates a civilian B to commit an offence which it is H's duty as a police officer to prevent. The offence is punishable with imprisonment up to eight years. B refuses and nothing is done. No express provision punishes this abetment. What is the maximum imprisonment for H under Section 56 BNS?

    1. Two years
    2. Four years
    3. Six years
    4. Eight years
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) Four years

    Section 56 BNS fixes the ordinary ceiling at one-fourth of the longest term, but where the abettor or the person abetted is a public servant whose duty it is to prevent the offence, the ceiling is one-half. H is such a public servant, so the maximum is half of eight years, that is four years, with the alternative of fine.

    Authority: Section 56 BNS (Illustrations (b) and (c))

    11. Consider the following statements about abetment under Sections 45 and 46 BNS. Which of them is/are correct?

    1. To constitute abetment it is not necessary that the act abetted should be committed.
    2. The person abetted must be capable by law of committing an offence.
    3. The abetment of an abetment is also an offence.
    4. The abetment of an illegal omission may be an offence although the abettor is not himself bound to do the omitted act.
    1. 1 and 3 only
    2. 2 and 3 only
    3. 1, 3 and 4 only
    4. 1, 2 and 4 only
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) 1, 3 and 4 only

    Explanation 2 to Section 46 makes the commission of the act abetted unnecessary, Explanation 4 makes an abetment of an abetment an offence, and Explanation 1 says the abettor of an illegal omission need not himself be bound to do the act. Statement 2 is wrong, because Explanation 3 says the person abetted need not be capable by law of committing an offence.

    Authority: Section 46, Explanations 1 to 4 BNS

    12. Consider the following statements about the kinds of abetment in Section 45 BNS. Which of them is/are correct?

    1. A person who wilfully conceals a material fact which he is bound to disclose, and thereby procures a thing to be done, instigates it.
    2. Aid within Explanation 2 can be given only before the commission of the act, not at the time it is committed.
    3. Abetment by conspiracy requires an act or illegal omission in pursuance of the conspiracy.
    4. An agreement alone to do the thing is sufficient for abetment by conspiracy.
    1. 1 and 3 only
    2. 1, 2 and 3 only
    3. 3 and 4 only
    4. 2 and 4 only
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) 1 and 3 only

    Explanation 1 to Section 45 treats wilful misrepresentation or wilful concealment of a material fact one is bound to disclose as instigation, and clause (b) needs an act or illegal omission in pursuance of the conspiracy. Statement 2 is wrong: Explanation 2 covers facilitation 'prior to or at the time of' the act. Statement 4 is wrong for the same reason as clause (b).

    Authority: Section 45(b) and Explanations 1 and 2 BNS

    13. Consider the following statements about punishment of abettors under the BNS. Which of them is/are correct?

    1. Under Section 55, abetting an offence punishable with death or life imprisonment, where hurt is caused in consequence of the abetment, may extend to ten years.
    2. Under Section 56, where the abettor is a public servant whose duty it is to prevent the offence, the ceiling is one-half of the longest term for that offence.
    3. Under Section 57, abetting an offence by the public generally, or by more than ten persons, is punishable with imprisonment up to seven years and fine.
    4. Under Section 49, where no express provision exists and the act is committed in consequence of the abetment, the abettor is punished with the punishment for the offence.
    1. 2, 3 and 4 only
    2. 1 and 2 only
    3. 1, 3 and 4 only
    4. 1 and 4 only
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) 2, 3 and 4 only

    Section 55 allows up to seven years, rising to fourteen years (not ten) where hurt is caused, so statement 1 is wrong. Section 56 gives one-half for the public-servant case, Section 57 gives up to seven years and fine (raised from three under the IPC), and Section 49 gives the punishment for the offence itself. Statements 2, 3 and 4 are correct.

    Authority: Sections 49, 55, 56 and 57 BNS

    14. Read the Assertion (A) and the Reason (R) and choose the correct option.

    Assertion (A): A person who instigates a child under seven to commit murder is liable to be punished as if the child had been capable of committing murder.
    Reason (R): For abetment, the person abetted must be capable by law of committing an offence.
    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) A is true, but R is false.

    A is true: Illustration (b) to Explanation 3 to Section 46 says the abettor of a child under seven is punished as if the child had been capable and had committed murder. R is false: Explanation 3 says it is not necessary that the person abetted be capable by law of committing an offence, which is exactly why A is liable.

    Authority: Section 46, Explanation 3 and Illustration (b) BNS

    15. Read the Assertion (A) and the Reason (R) and choose the correct option.

    Assertion (A): An abettor who is present when the offence he abetted is committed is deemed to have committed that offence.
    Reason (R): Abetment by conspiracy requires an act or illegal omission in pursuance of the conspiracy.
    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A.
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.
    3. A is true, but R is false.
    4. A is false, but R is true.
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A.

    A is true under Section 54 BNS (old IPC 114): an absent abettor who is present at the commission is deemed to have committed the offence. R is also true, as Section 45(b) requires an act or illegal omission in pursuance of the conspiracy. But R concerns the ingredients of one kind of abetment, not the reason an abettor present at the scene is treated as the offender, so it does not explain A.

    Authority: Sections 45(b) and 54 BNS

    16. Match List I (provision of the BNS) with List II (subject) and select the correct answer using the codes below.

    List I: (a) Section 47; (b) Section 48; (c) Section 52; (d) Section 57
    List II: 1. Abetting an offence by the public generally or by more than ten persons. 2. Abetment in India of an offence to be committed outside India. 3. Abetment from outside India of an act in India. 4. Cumulative punishment for the act abetted and the different act done.
    1. (a)-3, (b)-2, (c)-4, (d)-1
    2. (a)-2, (b)-3, (c)-1, (d)-4
    3. (a)-4, (b)-3, (c)-2, (d)-1
    4. (a)-2, (b)-3, (c)-4, (d)-1
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) (a)-2, (b)-3, (c)-4, (d)-1

    Section 47 covers abetment from within India of an act abroad that would be an offence in India; Section 48, which is new, covers the reverse case, abetment from outside India of an act in India. Section 52 makes the abettor liable for each offence where the different act done under Section 51 is a distinct offence in addition to the act abetted. Section 57 covers abetment to the public or more than ten persons.

    Authority: Sections 47, 48, 52 and 57 BNS

    17. Match List I (provision of the BNS) with List II (maximum imprisonment) and select the correct answer using the codes below.

    List I: (a) Section 55, abetment of an offence punishable with death or life imprisonment, not committed, where hurt is caused; (b) Section 58(a), concealing a design to commit an offence punishable with death or life imprisonment, offence committed; (c) Section 58(b), the same, offence not committed; (d) Section 60(b), concealing a design to commit an imprisonable offence, offence not committed
    List II: 1. Three years. 2. Seven years. 3. Fourteen years. 4. One-eighth of the longest term for the offence.
    1. (a)-2, (b)-3, (c)-1, (d)-4
    2. (a)-3, (b)-2, (c)-4, (d)-1
    3. (a)-3, (b)-2, (c)-1, (d)-4
    4. (a)-3, (b)-1, (c)-2, (d)-4
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) (a)-3, (b)-2, (c)-1, (d)-4

    Section 55 allows up to seven years, rising to fourteen where hurt is caused. Section 58 punishes concealment of a design to commit a death or life offence with up to seven years if the offence is committed and up to three years if it is not. Section 60(b) gives one-eighth of the longest term where the imprisonable offence is not committed (one-fourth if it is committed).

    Authority: Sections 55, 58 and 60 BNS

    18. In Jamuna Singh v State of Bihar (AIR 1967 SC 553), the Supreme Court considered the effect of the principal offender's acquittal on the conviction of an abettor. Which statement represents the position?

    1. Acquittal of the principal bars the conviction of every kind of abettor, since abetment cannot exist without the main offence
    2. Acquittal of the principal does not by itself bar the conviction of an abettor, and only a charge of intentional aid is expected to fail with it
    3. Acquittal of the principal bars the conviction of an instigator but not of one who engaged in a conspiracy
    4. Acquittal of the principal bars conviction of an abettor who is not present when the offence is committed
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) Acquittal of the principal does not by itself bar the conviction of an abettor, and only a charge of intentional aid is expected to fail with it

    Abetment is a separate offence, and guilt turns on the offence abetted and the mode of abetment. An instigator can therefore be convicted though the main offender is acquitted. Only a charge of intentional aid is expected to fail with the principal's acquittal, because aid presupposes an offence that was actually aided. Barendra Kumar Ghosh's 'a crime apart' passage supports the same view.

    Authority: Jamuna Singh v State of Bihar, AIR 1967 SC 553; Section 46 BNS

    19. Which of the following does NOT amount to abetment under Section 45 BNS?

    1. Falsely telling a police officer holding a warrant for Z that C is Z, intending C to be arrested
    2. Wilfully concealing a material fact which one is bound to disclose, so as to cause a thing to be done
    3. Handing a plotter a weapon at the scene, in order to facilitate the offence, which is then committed with it
    4. Inviting a friend to dinner out of ordinary friendship, without any purpose of helping his murder, though a plotter then kills him at the house
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) Inviting a friend to dinner out of ordinary friendship, without any purpose of helping his murder, though a plotter then kills him at the house

    Intentional aid needs an act done in order to facilitate the offence. In Shri Ram v State of UP, an invitation given in friendship, even if it made the killing possible, was not abetment unless meant to help the murder. The other three are within Section 45: the false representation (Explanation 1 and its illustration), wilful concealment (Explanation 1), and facilitation at the time of the act (Explanation 2).

    Authority: Section 45 and Explanations BNS; Shri Ram v State of UP, AIR 1975 SC 175

    20. Which of the following correctly states a feature of the BNS law of abetment as compared with the Indian Penal Code?

    1. Section 48 is new and punishes abetment, from outside India, of an act in India that would be an offence if committed there
    2. Section 57 reduces the ceiling for abetting an offence by the public or more than ten persons from seven years to three
    3. Section 46 drops the rule that abetment of an abetment is itself an offence
    4. Section 45 requires an act in pursuance of the plan only for conspiracy to commit offences of a particular gravity
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) Section 48 is new and punishes abetment, from outside India, of an act in India that would be an offence if committed there

    Section 48 BNS has no counterpart in the IPC: it covers abetment from outside India of an act in India, the mirror of Section 47 (old IPC 108A). Section 57 raised the ceiling from three years to seven, not the other way. Explanation 4 to Section 46 keeps the abetment-of-abetment rule, and Section 45(b) applies the act requirement to every conspiracy.

    Authority: Sections 45, 46, 47, 48 and 57 BNS; old IPC Sections 107 to 117

    More Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS) pages →