In short
Can you be guilty of a crime you never committed, only because you pushed, planned or helped? Yes, if it is abetment: the crime of bringing about someone else's offence. A person abets when they push another into committing it, join a plot that is then acted upon, or deliberately help it along. The law treats this as an offence in its own right, so the abettor can be punished even when the main crime is never carried out.
Three ways to abet, and four rules that widen the net
Section 45 recognises three kinds of abetment.
- Instigation. Actively urging, provoking or encouraging someone to do the thing. No set form of words is needed, and conduct alone can be enough. Under Explanation 1, a person also instigates when they get something done by deliberately lying, or by deliberately hiding a material fact they were bound to disclose. So a person who falsely points out an innocent man to a police officer holding a warrant for someone else abets the wrongful arrest.
- Conspiracy. Joining one or more others in a plan to do the thing, but only if some act or illegal omission then takes place in pursuance of that plan and towards doing it. An agreement on its own is not abetment by conspiracy.
- Intentional aid. Helping, by an act or an illegal omission, with the purpose of making the act happen. Explanation 2 to Section 45 puts it this way: "Whoever, either prior to or at the time of the commission of an act, does anything in order to facilitate the commission of that act, and thereby facilitates the commission thereof, is said to aid the doing of that act."
Section 46 (old IPC 108) then sets four rules that widen the net.
- The offence need not be committed. If A urges B to murder C and B refuses, A is still guilty of abetting murder.
- The person abetted need not be guilty. They may be incapable in law of committing an offence, or may act with no guilty mind at all. If A, intending to kill Z, gets a child under seven to do an act that causes Z's death, A is punished as if the child had committed murder.
- Abetting an abetment is itself an offence. A chain of instigators can all be liable.
- A conspirator need not deal directly with the person who commits the crime. Joining the plot is enough.
How abettors are punished
- Offence committed as a result of the abetment (Section 49, old IPC 109). If the law has no specific provision for punishing that abetment, the abettor gets the punishment for the offence itself.
- Person abetted acts with a different intention (Section 50). The abettor is judged by their own intention or knowledge.
- A different act is done (Section 51). The abettor is liable for it if it was a probable consequence of the abetment and was done under its influence. If that extra act is a separate offence on top of the act abetted, Section 52 makes the abettor liable for both.
- The act abetted has a different effect (Section 53). The abettor answers for that effect if they knew the act was likely to cause it.
- Abettor present at the scene (Section 54, old IPC 114). A person who would be liable as an abettor if absent is treated as having committed the offence if present when it is committed.
- Offence not committed (Sections 55 and 56). Abetting an offence punishable with death or life imprisonment carries up to seven years and fine, rising to fourteen years if an act causing hurt is done. For offences punishable with imprisonment, the limit is one-fourth of the longest term for that offence, or one-half where the abettor or the person abetted is a public servant whose duty was to prevent it.
Key numbers
- Section 57: up to seven years (earlier three) for abetting the public, or more than ten persons.
- Sections 55 and 56: offence not committed. Up to seven years, or fourteen if hurt is caused, for death or life offences. Otherwise one-fourth of the longest term, or one-half for a public servant.
Myth vs law
| Myth | Law |
|---|---|
| I only talked; the other person did the crime, so I am safe. | Instigation is abetment, and an instigator can be convicted even if the main offender is acquitted (Jamuna Singh). |
| Nothing happened, so there is nothing to punish. | The offence is complete on instigation or an act done under a plot. Sections 55 and 56 punish it with a lower ceiling. |
| If a child did the act, nobody is guilty. | Using a child under seven or a person of unsound mind makes you answerable as if they were capable. |
An example: a grudge in Jaipur's cloth market
Kabir bears a grudge against Naveen, who sells cloth in Jaipur's Johari Bazaar. He urges his cousin Dilip to "teach Naveen a lesson" with a few blows, tells him the hour when Naveen is alone in the shop, and waits at home.
- Dilip hits Naveen and causes hurt. Kabir has abetted by instigation and by aid. Under Section 49 he faces the same punishment as Dilip.
- Dilip refuses. Kabir's offence is already complete, punishable under Section 56 with its lower ceiling.
- Dilip hits Naveen and also empties his cash box. Kabir is not liable for the theft, a separate act that was not a probable consequence of his instigation. An illustration to the old Section 111 reaches the same answer for an arsonist who also steals.
Had Kabir gone along and stood guard outside the shop, Section 54 would treat him as having caused the hurt himself.
When is a person not an abettor?
- Intention is essential. Carelessness, or an act that merely makes a crime easier, is not abetment.
- Angry words are not instigation. Something said in a fit of temper, without meaning it to be acted on, does not amount to instigation.
- Presence and silence are usually not enough. An illegal omission can be abetment only where the person was under a legal duty to act. A constable who guarded a husband in custody, doing nothing while a head constable raped the wife in another room, was rightly convicted of abetting rape (Ram Kumar v State of HP, AIR 1995 SC 1965). But a senior advocate who did nothing to save a junior who set herself on fire in front of him was held not guilty of abetment of suicide, as his inaction was not an "illegal omission" (Surendra Agnihotri v State of MP, 1998 Cr LJ 4443 (MP)).
What changed from IPC Sections 107 to 120?
Sections 45 to 60 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS) contain the general law of abetment. They carry over Sections 107 to 120 of the Indian Penal Code, 1860 (IPC) with very few changes:
- Section 45 (old IPC 107) defines when a person abets the doing of a thing. The only change is that "Court of Justice" in the illustration now reads "Court".
- Section 46 (old IPC 108) defines an abettor. In its illustrations, the old word "lunatic" has been replaced by "a person of unsound mind".
- Section 47 (old IPC 108A) covers abetment from inside India of an act done abroad that would be an offence if done in India. Section 48 is new. It covers the reverse case: abetting, from outside India, an act inside India that would be an offence here.
- Sections 49 to 57 (old IPC 109 to 117) fix liability and punishment. Section 57 (abetting the public, or more than ten persons, to commit an offence) raises the maximum prison term from three years to seven.
- Sections 58 to 60 (old IPC 118 to 120) punish hiding a plan to commit an offence.
Some offences have their own abetment provisions. The best known is Section 108 BNS, abetment of suicide (old IPC 306).
Which cases define the offence?
- Barendra Kumar Ghosh v King Emperor, AIR 1925 PC 1. The Privy Council treated abetment as an offence separate from the crime abetted: "Abetment does not in itself involve the actual commission of the crime abetted. It is a crime apart." Prior abetment plus presence at the crime, it held, amounts to participation (now Section 54 BNS).
- Jamuna Singh v State of Bihar, AIR 1967 SC 553. The abettor's guilt depends on the offence abetted and the mode of abetment, so an instigator can be convicted though the main offender is acquitted. Only a charge of intentional aid is expected to fail with the principal's acquittal.
- Shri Ram v State of UP, AIR 1975 SC 175. Aid must be intentional. Inviting someone over in friendship, even if that makes their murder possible, is not abetment unless the invitation was meant to help the murder.
- Chitresh Kumar Chopra v State (Govt. of NCT of Delhi), AIR 2010 SC 1446. To instigate is to goad or urge forward. Instigation may be inferred where the accused, by a course of conduct, left the deceased with no option but suicide. Words spoken in anger, without intending the result, do not qualify.
- Smt. Gian Kaur v State of Punjab, (1996) 2 SCC 648. A Constitution Bench, speaking through J.S. Verma, J., upheld Section 306 IPC (now Section 108 BNS). Abetment of suicide is a distinct offence. The abettor is treated differently from the person who attempts suicide, because the abettor helps end someone else's life.
Abetment, conspiracy and common intention: how do they differ?
Criminal conspiracy (Section 61 BNS, old IPC 120A and 120B). The offence of criminal conspiracy is complete on an agreement to commit an offence. Abetment by conspiracy also needs an act or illegal omission carried out under that agreement (Pramatha Nath v Saroj Ranjan, AIR 1962 SC 876). The substantive offence of conspiracy is somewhat wider in amplitude than abetment by conspiracy (Noor Mohammad Mohd. Yusuf Momin v State of Maharashtra, AIR 1971 SC 885).
Common intention (Section 3(5) BNS, old IPC 34). Common intention makes each person who takes part in a joint criminal act liable for the whole act. In Suresh v State of U.P., (2001) 3 SCC 673, Thomas, J. observed that a person who shares the intention but takes no part at the scene may still be reached through the abetment or conspiracy provisions.
Common questions
Is abetment a separate crime or just a way of committing the main crime?
It is a separate, substantive offence. Except where the charge is intentional aid, the abettor's guilt does not depend on the main offender being convicted.
Can I be punished for abetting a crime that never happened?
Yes. Abetment is complete once you instigate or conspire. Sections 55 and 56 punish it with a lower ceiling than the completed offence.
What if I use a child or a person of unsound mind to commit the crime?
You are still an abettor, and you face the punishment for the offence as if the person you used were capable of committing it.
What changed from the IPC?
Very little. Section 48 on abetment from abroad is new, Section 57 raises the maximum from three to seven years, and some wording has been updated.
Written to help you understand the law; it is not legal advice for your case. Found a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.