LegalRepublic.in
LegalRepublic.in › Student Corner › BNS

MCQs

20 questions 20 minutes +1 correct · −0.25 wrong · 0 blank Read first: the explainer

Before you begin

  1. Answer in any order. Use the numbers on the right to jump between questions.
  2. Mark a question for review if you want to come back to it.
  3. Each correct answer gets 1 mark and each wrong answer loses a quarter mark. A question left blank scores zero, so skip when unsure.
  4. Submit when you are done. You will see your score, then every question with the correct answer and why.
  5. Nothing you do here is saved or sent anywhere.
15:00 0 of 15 answered
Question 1

    0 / 15
    Correct 0 Wrong 0 Blank 0 Time 0:00

    All 20 questions with answers

    Prefer to read? Every question is listed here; open a question to see the answer and why.

    1. Which provision of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 declares that an accomplice is a competent witness against an accused person?

    1. Section 137
    2. Section 139
    3. Section 138
    4. Section 119(1)
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) Section 138

    Section 138 BSA says an accomplice shall be a competent witness against an accused person, and that a conviction is not illegal if it proceeds upon his corroborated testimony. Section 137 deals with compelled answers that may incriminate a witness, Section 139 with the number of witnesses, and Section 119 with presumptions the court may draw.

    Authority: Section 138 BSA

    2. A witness is compelled to answer a relevant question although the answer may incriminate him. Which section of the BSA provides that such an answer cannot be used to arrest or prosecute him, except for giving false evidence?

    1. Section 137
    2. Section 136
    3. Section 119
    4. Section 139
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) Section 137

    Section 137 BSA stops a witness from refusing to answer merely because the answer may incriminate him, but protects him: the compelled answer cannot be used to arrest or prosecute him, except in a prosecution for false evidence. Section 119 is the presumptions section and Section 139 says no particular number of witnesses is required to prove a fact.

    Authority: Section 137 BSA

    3. Regarding the meaning of 'accomplice' in the BSA, which statement is correct?

    1. Section 2 defines an accomplice as a person jointly charged with the accused
    2. Section 138 defines an accomplice as a person who has turned approver
    3. Illustration (b) to Section 119(1) defines an accomplice as a witness who has confessed
    4. It is not defined, and bears its ordinary meaning of a guilty partner or associate in crime
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) It is not defined, and bears its ordinary meaning of a guilty partner or associate in crime

    Neither the BSA nor the old Evidence Act defines 'accomplice'. In M O Shamsuddin v State of Kerala the Supreme Court held that the word carries its ordinary meaning: a guilty associate or partner in the crime. Section 138 and illustration (b) to Section 119(1) use the word but do not define it; an approver is only one kind of accomplice.

    Authority: Sections 119(1) illustration (b) and 138 BSA; M O Shamsuddin v State of Kerala (1995) 3 SCC 351

    4. Three men burgle a jewellery shop. Joseph, who stood guard, turns prosecution witness and names Harbans and Dilip as the planners. Stolen ornaments are recovered from Harbans's house at his instance. Nothing other than Joseph's word connects Dilip with the burglary. Which is the correct position?

    1. Both can be convicted, since Joseph is a competent witness against each of them alike
    2. Harbans's link is independently supported by the recovery; Dilip is likely to get the benefit of the doubt
    3. Both must be acquitted, since the recovery proves only that Harbans received stolen goods
    4. Neither can be convicted, since an accomplice's evidence can never be acted upon
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) Harbans's link is independently supported by the recovery; Dilip is likely to get the benefit of the doubt

    Joseph shared in the crime, so he is an accomplice. He is competent, and his evidence is admissible, but the court asks whether anything independent supports his story against each accused. The recovery connects Harbans with the burglary. Against Dilip there is only the accomplice's word, so the presumption in Section 119(1)(b) is not displaced.

    Authority: Sections 119(1) illustration (b) and 138 BSA; Balwant Kaur v Union Territory of Chandigarh AIR 1988 SC 139

    5. A contractor, who was forced to pay Rs 40,000 to a public servant to get his bill cleared, deposes against the public servant. The defence argues that the contractor is an accomplice and that his evidence is unworthy of credit without corroboration in material particulars. What is the correct view?

    1. The contractor is an accomplice because a bribe-giver always shares in the offence
    2. The contractor is not an accomplice because he was a victim of the demand, so the special rule for accomplices is not attracted on that basis
    3. The contractor is an accomplice but the corroboration rule does not apply to payers of money
    4. The contractor is an approver because he gave evidence for the prosecution
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) The contractor is not an accomplice because he was a victim of the demand, so the special rule for accomplices is not attracted on that basis

    A person forced to pay a bribe is the victim, not a partner in the crime. The Supreme Court in CM Sharma held that such a witness is not an accomplice, so the suspicion attaching to accomplices does not attach to him by reason of that label. His evidence is still tested like any other, but not on the footing of Section 119(1)(b).

    Authority: Section 119(1) illustration (b) BSA; CM Sharma v State of Andhra Pradesh (2010) 15 SCC 1

    6. Ravi saw a gang murder a shopkeeper. Out of fear for his life he told nobody until the police traced him weeks later, and he then testified against the accused. The accused contend that his silence makes him an accomplice. Which statement is correct?

    1. Ravi is an accomplice because he concealed the offence
    2. Ravi is an accomplice because he failed to inform the police promptly
    3. Ravi is an accomplice, but only to the offence of concealment and not the murder
    4. Ravi is not an accomplice; fear-driven silence does not make a person a partner in the crime
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) Ravi is not an accomplice; fear-driven silence does not make a person a partner in the crime

    An accomplice must have shared in the guilt of the crime. A person who merely saw it and stayed silent out of fear is a witness, not a participant. The Supreme Court so held in Vemireddy Satyanarayan Reddy. His delay may affect how the court weighs his credibility, but it does not convert him into an accomplice.

    Authority: Section 138 BSA; Vemireddy Satyanarayan Reddy v State of Hyderabad AIR 1956 SC 379

    7. At a trial for dacoity, the only evidence against Mohan is the testimony of accomplice Sunil. To support Sunil, the prosecution relies solely on the confession of co-accused Prakash implicating Mohan. How should the court treat this?

    1. As not independent corroboration; it can only lend assurance to other evidence
    2. As sufficient corroboration, because Prakash is a source distinct from Sunil
    3. As substantive evidence against Mohan, which makes Sunil's evidence unnecessary
    4. As wholly inadmissible against Mohan for every purpose whatsoever
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) As not independent corroboration; it can only lend assurance to other evidence

    A co-accused's confession is not substantive evidence against others. It has only corroborative value, lending assurance to other evidence, and it cannot found a conviction. It cannot by itself corroborate an accomplice, because corroboration must come from an independent source. Haricharan Kurmi and Kalpnath Rai state this rule.

    Authority: Section 138 BSA; Haricharan Kurmi v State of Bihar AIR 1964 SC 1184; Kalpnath Rai v State through CBI AIR 1998 SC 201

    8. In a trial of Rakesh for theft, a prosecution witness Naresh, who took part in the theft, is made to answer a relevant question and admits his role. Naresh is later put on trial for the same theft. Which is correct?

    1. It can be used against him, because he gave the answer as a witness on oath
    2. It can be used, because the protection does not extend to witnesses who are accomplices
    3. It cannot be used to prosecute him for the theft, only in a prosecution for false evidence
    4. It can be used against him only after the court has first granted him a pardon
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) It cannot be used to prosecute him for the theft, only in a prosecution for false evidence

    Section 137 BSA bars a witness from refusing a relevant question merely because the answer may incriminate him, but an answer he is compelled to give cannot be used to arrest or prosecute him, except for giving false evidence. The protection is not confined to non-accomplices; the Supreme Court in R Dineshkumar noted it is reinforced by the Constitution.

    Authority: Section 137 BSA; R Dineshkumar @ Deena v State AIR 2015 SC 1816

    9. In a rape trial the accused argues that the prosecutrix's testimony must be treated like that of an accomplice and cannot be acted upon without corroboration in material particulars. How should the court respond?

    1. Accept it only if she delayed lodging the complaint
    2. Reject the argument; the prosecutrix is the victim, not a partner in the crime, and the law does not place her on par with an accomplice
    3. Accept it, because a woman's evidence on sexual offences is always presumed unworthy of credit
    4. Accept it, because Section 119(1)(b) applies to every witness who alleges an offence
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) Reject the argument; the prosecutrix is the victim, not a partner in the crime, and the law does not place her on par with an accomplice

    The prosecutrix is a victim, not an associate in the crime. The Supreme Court in State of Maharashtra v Chandraprakash Kewalchand Jain refused to equate her with an accomplice, and nothing in the law requires her evidence to be corroborated in material particulars before it is accepted. Section 119(1)(b) speaks only of an accomplice.

    Authority: Section 119(1) illustration (b) BSA; State of Maharashtra v Chandraprakash Kewalchand Jain AIR 1990 SC 658

    10. A and B, both persons of the highest character, jointly arranged certain machinery. A is tried for causing a death by negligence in that arrangement. B, who took part in it, describes exactly what was done and frankly admits and explains the common carelessness of both. How must the court approach B's evidence?

    1. It must treat B as an approver and require a pardon before using his evidence
    2. It must reject B's evidence, because a person who admits carelessness is incompetent
    3. It must hold B unworthy of credit, because the presumption in illustration (b) is mandatory
    4. It must weigh B's character and frankness while deciding whether the presumption against an accomplice applies at all in this case
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) It must weigh B's character and frankness while deciding whether the presumption against an accomplice applies at all in this case

    Section 119(1)(b) says the court 'may' presume an accomplice unworthy of credit. Section 119(2)(ii) directs the court to have regard to facts such as this very case, where an equally reputable participant gives a precise, self-incriminating account, in deciding whether the presumption applies. The presumption is therefore not automatic, and B remains competent under Section 138.

    Authority: Section 119(1) illustration (b) and 119(2)(ii) BSA; Section 138 BSA

    11. Consider the following statements about the evidence of an accomplice. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    1. An accomplice may testify for himself, for a co-accused or against the accused.
    2. The prosecution must also prosecute the accomplice before it can use his evidence against the others.
    3. Corroboration need not prove the whole case on its own and may be circumstantial.
    4. Corroboration must come from a source independent of the accomplice.
    1. 1, 3 and 4 only
    2. 2, 3 and 4 only
    3. 1 and 2 only
    4. 1, 2, 3 and 4
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) 1, 3 and 4 only

    Statements 1, 3 and 4 are correct. An accomplice is competent in all three capacities, and corroboration need only support his account on material points and link the accused with the crime, directly or indirectly, from an independent source. Statement 2 is wrong: the prosecution is not bound to prosecute the accomplice; it may use his evidence to reach the real culprits.

    Authority: Section 138 BSA; Balwant Kaur v Union Territory of Chandigarh AIR 1988 SC 139; Mohd Hussain Umar Kochra v K S Dalipsinghji AIR 1970 SC 45

    12. Consider the following statements. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    1. Section 138 BSA makes an accomplice a competent witness against an accused person.
    2. Illustration (b) to Section 119(1) obliges the court to presume that an accomplice is unworthy of credit.
    3. Section 119(2) lists facts the court is to regard in considering whether the maxims in the illustrations apply to the case.
    1. 1 only
    2. 2 and 3 only
    3. 1 and 3 only
    4. 2 only
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) 1 and 3 only

    Statements 1 and 3 are correct. Section 138 declares the accomplice competent, and Section 119(2) lists facts the court must regard when deciding whether a presumption fits the case. Statement 2 is wrong: Section 119(1) says the court 'may' presume, so the presumption that an accomplice is unworthy of credit unless corroborated in material particulars is discretionary, not obligatory.

    Authority: Sections 119(1) illustration (b), 119(2) and 138 BSA

    13. Consider the following statements. Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

    1. Every approver is an accomplice.
    2. Every accomplice is an approver.
    3. The confession of a co-accused is substantive evidence against the other accused.
    4. A retracted confession needs only general corroboration, whereas an accomplice's evidence needs corroboration in material particulars.
    1. 1, 2 and 3 only
    2. 1 and 3 only
    3. 2 and 4 only
    4. 1 and 4 only
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) 1 and 4 only

    Statements 1 and 4 are correct. An accomplice becomes a prosecution witness by turning approver, so every approver is an accomplice but not the reverse (Mrinal Das). Statement 3 is wrong: a co-accused's confession has only corroborative value (Kalpnath Rai). Subramania Gounder warned against equating a retracted confession with accomplice evidence.

    Authority: Section 138 BSA; Mrinal Das v Tripura AIR 2011 SC 3753; Subramania Gounder v State of Madras AIR 1958 SC 66; Kalpnath Rai v State AIR 1998 SC 201

    14. Read the Assertion (A) and the Reason (R) and choose the correct option.

    Assertion (A): A person who merely witnessed a crime and kept quiet out of fear is not an accomplice.
    Reason (R): An accomplice must be a guilty partner or associate who shared in the crime.
    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A

    Both are true and R explains A. The word 'accomplice' is not defined in the statute and, as Shamsuddin held, means a guilty associate in the crime. A silent onlooker has shared in no guilt, so, as in Vemireddy Satyanarayan Reddy, fear-driven silence does not make him an accomplice. Such a witness is tested like any other witness.

    Authority: Section 138 BSA; M O Shamsuddin v State of Kerala (1995) 3 SCC 351; Vemireddy Satyanarayan Reddy v State of Hyderabad AIR 1956 SC 379

    15. Read the Assertion (A) and the Reason (R) and choose the correct option.

    Assertion (A): The evidence of an accomplice is admissible, though the court treats it with suspicion.
    Reason (R): An accomplice is incompetent as a witness unless he has first turned approver.
    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is true, but R is false
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) A is true, but R is false

    The Assertion is true: Section 138 makes an accomplice a competent witness against the accused, and the defence cross-examines him, but Section 119(1)(b) lets the court presume him unworthy of credit unless corroborated in material particulars. The Reason is false: competence does not depend on turning approver. Laxmipat Choraria holds the corroboration rule applies to every accomplice, whether or not he is an approver.

    Authority: Sections 119(1) illustration (b) and 138 BSA; Laxmipat Choraria v State of Maharashtra AIR 1968 SC 938

    16. Match the decision in List I with the proposition it is cited for in List II, and select the correct code.

    List I: (a) Vemireddy Satyanarayan Reddy; (b) CM Sharma; (c) Laxmipat Choraria; (d) Balwant Kaur
    List II: 1. Corroboration is needed for every accomplice, whether or not he has turned approver; 2. Corroboration in material particulars must connect the accused with the crime from an independent source; 3. A person forced to pay a bribe is not an accomplice; 4. Silence out of fear does not make a person an accomplice
    1. (a)-3, (b)-4, (c)-1, (d)-2
    2. (a)-4, (b)-3, (c)-1, (d)-2
    3. (a)-4, (b)-2, (c)-3, (d)-1
    4. (a)-1, (b)-3, (c)-4, (d)-2
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) (a)-4, (b)-3, (c)-1, (d)-2

    Vemireddy Satyanarayan Reddy: fear-driven silence does not make a person an accomplice (4). CM Sharma: a person compelled to pay a bribe is not an accomplice (3). Laxmipat Choraria: the need for corroboration applies to every accomplice, approver or not (1). Balwant Kaur: corroboration in material particulars must come from an independent source and link the accused to the crime (2).

    Authority: Section 138 BSA; Vemireddy Satyanarayan Reddy AIR 1956 SC 379; CM Sharma (2010) 15 SCC 1; Laxmipat Choraria AIR 1968 SC 938; Balwant Kaur AIR 1988 SC 139

    17. Match the provision of the BSA in List I with its subject in List II, and select the correct code.

    List I: (a) Section 138; (b) Section 137; (c) Section 119(1) illustration (b); (d) Section 139
    List II: 1. Accomplice presumed unworthy of credit unless corroborated in material particulars; 2. Competence of an accomplice and conviction on his corroborated testimony; 3. No particular number of witnesses is required to prove a fact; 4. Witness cannot refuse to answer on the ground of self-incrimination, but the answer cannot be used to prosecute him
    1. (a)-2, (b)-4, (c)-1, (d)-3
    2. (a)-4, (b)-2, (c)-1, (d)-3
    3. (a)-2, (b)-1, (c)-4, (d)-3
    4. (a)-3, (b)-4, (c)-1, (d)-2
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (A) (a)-2, (b)-4, (c)-1, (d)-3

    Section 138 makes the accomplice competent and speaks of conviction on his corroborated testimony (2). Section 137 compels the answer while protecting the witness from prosecution on it, except for false evidence (4). Illustration (b) to Section 119(1) is the presumption of unworthiness without corroboration (1). Section 139 says no particular number of witnesses is required (3).

    Authority: Sections 119(1), 137, 138 and 139 BSA

    18. An accomplice testifies for the prosecution. Which of the following, by itself, has been held to further weaken his credibility?

    1. His evidence being admitted after a full cross-examination by the defence
    2. The fact that the corroboration offered for his account is only circumstantial
    3. The prosecution's decision not to put him on trial along with the accused
    4. His having earlier made a confession that he later retracted
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (D) His having earlier made a confession that he later retracted

    In Sudevanand v State through CBI the Supreme Court noted that where an accomplice had confessed and later withdrew the confession, his credibility suffers further. The prosecution is not bound to try the accomplice before using his evidence; corroboration may be circumstantial so long as it is independent and links the accused; and cross-examination is what makes his evidence admissible. None of these, by itself, lowers his worth.

    Authority: Section 138 BSA; Sudevanand v State through CBI (2012) 3 SCC 387

    19. A, B and C, three of several persons who committed a crime, are captured on the spot and kept apart. Each gives an account implicating D, and the accounts agree in a way that makes previous concert highly improbable. D argues that all three are accomplices and so unworthy of credit. Under Section 119 BSA, the correct position is:

    1. The presumption in illustration (b) is conclusive, so D must be acquitted outright
    2. The court must weigh these facts in deciding whether the presumption applies at all
    3. Their accounts are worthless, as accomplices can never support one another in any case
    4. Their evidence becomes usable only if a pardon is first tendered to each of them
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (B) The court must weigh these facts in deciding whether the presumption applies at all

    Section 119(2)(iii) names this very situation as one the court must regard when asking whether the maxim in illustration (b) fits the case. Separately held accomplices whose accounts match too closely to be planned give the court reason not to apply the presumption mechanically. The presumption is only a 'may' presumption, and nothing requires a pardon for them to be heard.

    Authority: Section 119(1) illustration (b) and 119(2)(iii) BSA

    20. On the change from the Evidence Act, 1872 to the BSA, 2023, which statement correctly describes the wording on accomplice evidence?

    1. Section 133 IEA made such a conviction illegal, and Section 138 BSA has now made it legal
    2. Section 133 IEA has been merged into Section 119 BSA along with the presumptions
    3. The old 'merely because … uncorroborated' wording became 'if … corroborated' in Section 138
    4. The wording is unchanged; only the section number has moved from 133 to 138
    Show answer and explanation

    Answer: (C) The old 'merely because … uncorroborated' wording became 'if … corroborated' in Section 138

    The old Section 133 protected a conviction resting on the uncorroborated testimony of an accomplice from being illegal merely on that ground. Section 138 BSA instead says a conviction is not illegal if it proceeds upon the corroborated testimony of an accomplice. The presumptions in Section 114 IEA moved to Section 119 BSA, and Section 132 IEA to Section 137 BSA.

    Authority: Section 138 BSA (formerly Section 133 IEA); Section 119 BSA (formerly Section 114 IEA)

    More Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA) pages →