LegalRepublic.in

BSA/Concept explainer

Accomplice Witness: Meaning, Corroboration and Section 138 BSA

Who is an accomplice, why courts want corroboration before trusting one, and how Section 138 BSA and Section 119 BSA treat accomplice evidence.

Updated 18 November 2026 · 7 min read

In short

One burglar turns on his partners and walks into the witness box. Should the court believe him? An accomplice is someone who took part in the crime alongside the accused and then gives evidence about it in court. The law allows such a person to testify. But because an accomplice has every reason to shift blame and save himself, courts treat the evidence with suspicion and, as a matter of practice, look for independent support before acting on it.

Which three sections of the BSA govern an accomplice?

Three provisions of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 (BSA) work together here:

  • Section 138 BSA makes an accomplice a competent witness and deals with convictions based on his evidence. It says: "An accomplice shall be a competent witness against an accused person"; and "a conviction is not illegal if it proceeds upon the corroborated testimony of an accomplice". 'Corroborated' means supported by other, independent evidence.
  • Section 119 BSA lets the court presume facts from the common course of natural events, human conduct and business. Illustration (b) to sub-section (1) says the court may presume that "an accomplice is unworthy of credit, unless he is corroborated in material particulars". Sub-section (2) lists facts the court must weigh before applying that presumption.
  • Section 137 BSA says a witness cannot refuse to answer a relevant question just because the answer may incriminate him, but an answer he is compelled to give cannot be used to arrest or prosecute him, except for giving false evidence.

The word 'accomplice' is not defined anywhere in the statute. The Supreme Court in M O Shamsuddin v State of Kerala (1995) said it carries its ordinary meaning: a guilty partner or associate in the crime.

Five questions a court asks about an accomplice's evidence

  1. Is the witness really an accomplice? The witness must have shared in the guilt. A person who merely saw the crime and stayed silent out of fear does not become an accomplice. Nor does a victim, such as a person forced to pay a bribe to a public servant.
  2. Is he competent? Yes. An accomplice can testify for himself, for a co-accused, or against the accused. The prosecution is not bound to prosecute him as well; it may use his evidence to reach the real culprits.
  3. Is his evidence legally admissible? Yes, provided the defence had a fair chance to cross-examine him.
  4. How much weight does it carry? This is where caution enters. The court may start from the presumption that an accomplice is not worthy of belief, and will usually look for corroboration in material particulars before convicting.
  5. What counts as corroboration? Independent evidence, from a source other than the accomplice, that connects the accused with the crime. It need not prove the whole case on its own, and it can be circumstantial.

A jewellery-shop burglary in Kozhikode

Three men break into a jewellery shop in Kozhikode. One of them, Joseph, stood guard outside. After his arrest he agrees to testify and describes how Harbans and Dilip planned the burglary and cracked the safe.

Joseph is an accomplice: he shared in the crime. His testimony is admissible, and the defence can cross-examine him. Before convicting Harbans and Dilip, the court will ask whether anything independent supports his story against each of them. If gold ornaments from the shop are recovered from Harbans's house, that links Harbans to the crime. If nothing at all ties Dilip to the burglary except Joseph's word, the court is likely to give Dilip the benefit of the doubt.

Who is not an accomplice, and when is the doubt lifted?

  • Not every person near a crime is an accomplice. Fear-driven silence does not make someone a partner in crime, as the Court held in Vemireddy Satyanarayan Reddy v State of Hyderabad (AIR 1956 SC 379). A woman who is the victim in a rape case, or a contractor forced to pay a bribe, is not an accomplice either (CM Sharma v State of Andhra Pradesh (2010) 15 SCC 1).
  • The presumption of unreliability is not automatic. Section 119(2) itself lists situations the court must weigh before applying it. One is where two people of high character took part in setting up machinery, one is tried for a death caused by negligence, and the other frankly explains the shared carelessness. Another is where three captured offenders, kept apart from each other, each name the same fourth person in accounts that match too closely to have been planned together.
  • Corroboration must be independent. The confession of a co-accused is not, by itself, corroboration. It can be used only to lend assurance to other evidence after false implication has been ruled out.
  • A retracted confession weakens him further. If an accomplice had confessed and later withdrew it, his credibility suffers (Sudevanand v State through CBI (2012) 3 SCC 387).
  • Protection against self-incrimination. An accomplice who incriminates himself in the witness box is protected, and the Supreme Court in R Dineshkumar @ Deena v State (AIR 2015 SC 1816) noted that the Constitution reinforces this protection.

Which decisions fix the corroboration rule?

  • Haroon Haji Abdulla v State of Maharashtra (AIR 1968 SC 832): decided under the old Evidence Act wording, restated that an accomplice is competent against the accused and that a conviction on his uncorroborated evidence was not illegal on that ground alone.
  • State of Rajasthan v Arjun Singh (AIR 2011 SC 3380): an accomplice is regarded from the outset as open to grave suspicion.
  • Laxmipat Choraria v State of Maharashtra (AIR 1968 SC 938): the need for corroboration applies to every accomplice, whether or not he has turned approver.
  • Balwant Kaur v Union Territory of Chandigarh (AIR 1988 SC 139): corroboration in material particulars must connect the accused with the crime, directly or indirectly, and must come from an independent source.
  • Mohd Hussain Umar Kochra v K S Dalipsinghji (AIR 1970 SC 45): the corroboration needed is of a general kind that makes it probable the accomplice's version can be safely trusted.

Accomplice, approver, co-accused, victim and retracted confession compared

An approver. Every approver is an accomplice, but not every accomplice is an approver. An accomplice becomes a prosecution witness by turning approver (Mrinal Das v Tripura, AIR 2011 SC 3753). The corroboration rule applies to both. See Approver for how the courts test an approver's evidence.

A confessing co-accused. An accomplice gives sworn evidence in court and faces cross-examination. A co-accused's confession, by contrast, is not substantive evidence against the others. It has only corroborative value (Kalpnath Rai v State through CBI, AIR 1998 SC 201) and cannot be the foundation of a conviction (Haricharan Kurmi v State of Bihar, AIR 1964 SC 1184).

A victim-witness. A prosecutrix in a sexual offence case is the victim, not a partner in crime. The Supreme Court in State of Maharashtra v Chandraprakash Kewalchand Jain (AIR 1990 SC 658) refused to place her on par with an accomplice. Nothing in the law says her evidence must be corroborated in material particulars before it can be accepted.

A retracted confession. In Subramania Gounder v State of Madras (AIR 1958 SC 66), the Court warned against equating the two. A retracted confession needs only general corroboration, while an accomplice's evidence must be corroborated in material particulars.

From Evidence Act 133 to BSA 138: what changed?

Point Old law (Evidence Act) New law (BSA)
Accomplice's conviction Section 133: a conviction was not illegal 'merely because' it proceeded upon the 'uncorroborated' testimony of an accomplice Section 138: not illegal 'if' it proceeds upon the 'corroborated' testimony of an accomplice
Presumptions Section 114 Section 119: the general rule and illustrations (a) to (i) form sub-section (1); the facts that qualify them, numbered (i) to (x), form sub-section (2)
Compelled answers Section 132 Section 137

Under the BSA, both provisions point the same way: the accomplice remains a competent witness, Section 138 speaks of a conviction on his corroborated testimony, and Section 119 lets the court distrust him unless he is corroborated. The Supreme Court decisions on this page were given under the old wording, when courts treated such a conviction as lawful but seldom safe.

Common questions

Can a court convict only on an accomplice's evidence?

Under the old Evidence Act provision, such a conviction was not illegal, though courts seldom found it safe. Section 138 BSA, as enacted, speaks of a conviction on corroborated accomplice testimony, and Section 119 BSA still lets the court treat an uncorroborated accomplice as unworthy of credit. Either way, independent evidence linking the accused to the crime is what makes a conviction safe.

Does the corroboration have to prove the entire case?

No. It must support the accomplice's account on material points and link the accused to the offence. Circumstantial evidence can be enough.

Is a witness who saw a murder and kept quiet an accomplice?

No. Silence out of fear does not make a person a partner in the crime.

Can one accomplice corroborate another?

Corroboration must come from an independent source. A co-accused's confession, for instance, cannot by itself corroborate.

Can an accomplice be forced to answer questions that incriminate him?

He cannot refuse to answer a relevant question on that ground, but his compelled answer cannot be used to prosecute him, except for perjury.

Test yourself20 questions · 20 minutesExam-style questions with marking, a timer and an explanation for every answer.

Written to help you understand the law; it is not legal advice for your case. Found a mistake? Tell us and we will fix it.