Madurai hill pillar: one-off lamp lighting allowed on 24 November, Supreme Court sets safeguards
Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi stayed Madras High Court findings and let a restricted team light the Karthigai Deepam lamp, deciding no right or custom.
The Supreme Court has allowed a restricted team to light the Karthigai Deepam lamp at a stone pillar on Thirupparankundram Hill, Madurai, on 24 November. The permission covers that festival only, and the bench said it settles nothing about who has a right to light a lamp there.
A bench of Justice Aravind Kumar and Justice Vipul M. Pancholi passed the order on 20 November. It stayed the findings in paragraphs 1 to 141 of a Madras High Court judgment of 6 January 2026, until further orders.
A festival four days away
The lead case is a writ petition by Hindu Dharma Parishad against the Union of India. It was heard with special leave petitions arising from the Division Bench judgment of the Madras High Court, Madurai Bench, on lighting the Karthigai Deepam at the hill.
Both the Single Judge and the Division Bench had directed that the ceremonial lamp be lit at the Deepathoon, with differing safeguards and qualifications. The correctness of those directions is under challenge in the Supreme Court.
The festival falls on 24 November 2026. The bench heard senior counsel for the parties at considerable length on interim relief before passing its order.
What the bench left undecided
The order lists the questions pressed before it. They include the nature and extent of religious freedom, whether an asserted religious practice can be enforced, and the temple administration’s authority over religious observance.
They also include the effect of earlier judicial pronouncements and the limits of judicial intervention. The bench noted that wider questions on Articles 25 and 26 are awaiting a Nine-Judge Constitution Bench, in the reference arising from the Sabarimala proceedings.
It saw no need, at this interlocutory stage, to examine any of them. The nature of the alleged custom, the legal character of the disputed site, rights flowing from earlier decrees and the statutory authority of the institutions will be taken up at the appropriate stage.
Declining to address the submissions, the bench said, must not be read as accepting or rejecting them.
Why the bench made an exception
What weighed with the court was the occasion itself. A festival day that is missed cannot be restored by any later ruling, the bench said, and a ceremony once held cannot be undone.
For that reason, it said, any interim arrangement had to be narrowly confined, carefully regulated and unable to create an enduring legal consequence. It settled on:
“a limited, one-time arrangement, subject to stringent safeguards” (para 11)
The bench also gave some weight, for interim relief only, to the fact that both the Single Judge and the Division Bench had directed the ceremony at the same spot. It added that this was no approval of the reasoning in either judgment.
Stay on paragraphs 1 to 141
The stay applies to the High Court findings in paragraphs 1 to 141 of the 6 January judgment, insofar as they concern the challenge in these proceedings. The bench said the stay expresses no opinion on whether those findings are correct.
Separately, it moulded the interim relief for the festival. The lamp may be lit on 24 November at the stone pillar identified as Deepathoon in Annexure-B to the High Court judgment, by a restricted team authorised by the Devasthanam.
The permission is a temporary arrangement, the bench said, and not recognition or enforcement of any customary, religious or proprietary right.
Six conditions for the ceremony
Only a team authorised by the Devasthanam may light the lamp. The District Collector, Madurai, will settle its composition and number after consulting the Temple Executive Officer, the Archaeological Survey of India and the Commissioner of Police, Madurai.
The Collector is the nodal officer for coordination and supervision. The Commissioner of Police must provide protection and regulate access. The Union of India is to examine and facilitate a CRPF contingent if the State asks for one, to supplement local police.
No member of the public may accompany the team to the Deepathoon. No procession, public congregation, demonstration, slogan-raising or other activity beyond the lighting is allowed, and access is limited to authorised persons and officials needed for supervision and security.
The district administration will fix the timing, route and duration, keeping in view public safety, fire prevention, archaeological protection and peace. The team must leave straight after the ceremony and leave no temporary article or installation behind.
The Archaeological Survey of India will prescribe conditions to protect the monument and its surroundings. The ceremony must follow the applicable statutory requirements, with no excavation, construction, structural alteration, permanent installation or damage.
Existing observances at the customary locations continue undisturbed. Lawful religious activities, access and enjoyment of the Dargah and other institutions must not be interfered with. The arrangement gives no one an added right of entry, occupation or control over any part of the hill.
No precedent for next year
The bench said the arrangement does not rest on any finding that the pillar is, or has historically been, a place of customary religious observance. Nor does it decide whether lighting the lamp there is an essential religious practice, or whether any person, denomination or institution has an enforceable right.
Questions of title, possession, customary usage, religious entitlement, temple administration and access to the site are expressly left open.
No party may cite the permission, or the ceremony held under it, as evidence of custom, precedent, a possessory right or an entitlement to access. It cannot be used to seek similar permission in a later year, and complying with the order brings no adverse inference.
The arrangement is confined to the festival on 24 November and does not govern the rights of the parties or the manner of observance in later years.
A call for restraint
The bench expected all concerned to extend full cooperation to the authorities and to act with restraint and responsibility. It said observing a religious festival in a constitutional society must go with mutual respect, public order and the rule of law. On the limits of its own order, it said:
“it is an arrangement made precisely because the dispute remains to be determined” (para 19)
What happens next
The District Collector must file a brief compliance report within three days after the festival. All contentions of the parties are expressly kept open.
The bench condoned delay, issued notice in the two petitions filed under Diary Nos. 70213 and 69967 of 2026, and granted leave. It admitted the writ petition by Hindu Dharma Parishad.
Counter affidavits are due within six weeks and rejoinders within three weeks after that, with pleadings in all the matters to be complete within eight weeks of 20 November. Advocates must give soft copies of their pleadings to the nodal counsel, who will prepare a convenience compilation.
Order
The interim applications stand disposed of in these terms, subject to further orders. The registry will tag all the matters and list them in the second week of January 2027.