Rs 2 lakh added with no workings: Supreme Court rebuilds a leg-injury award at Rs 11.75 lakh
Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar held that a High Court must reason head by head, and refixed a leg-injury claim at Rs 11,75,106.
A motorcyclist with a permanently disabled right leg got Rs 2,33,130 from a tribunal and Rs 2 lakh more from the Madhya Pradesh High Court, which did not say how it reached that figure. On 20 November the Supreme Court recalculated the claim head by head and fixed it at Rs 11,75,106, with 7 per cent interest.
Justice Ujjal Bhuyan and Justice Atul S. Chandurkar allowed the appeal of Mohammad Sabir in a judgment written by Justice Chandurkar. A High Court that raises an award, the bench said, has to go through each head and decide whether the Tribunal’s grant was just.
A truck, a motorcycle and a damaged leg
On 24 April 2013 Mohammad Sabir was riding his motorcycle with his wife near Kotwali in Datia when a truck hit them just after noon. Both were injured and treated.
Each filed a claim petition before the Motor Accident Claims Tribunal in Gwalior under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988. His petition was numbered 147 of 2013 and his wife’s 146 of 2013.
Mr Sabir produced a disability certificate showing 50 per cent permanent disability of his right leg. He said he earned Rs 15,000 a month collecting and selling milk, and that he was between 27 and 30 years old when the accident happened.
What the Tribunal awarded
The Tribunal held that the truck was driven rashly and negligently, and accepted the 50 per cent disability of the leg. Because a doctor had said treatment could reduce it, it took his overall disability at 40 per cent and used 20 per cent in its calculation.
Treating Rs 4,000 a month as notional income, it applied a multiplier of 17. That gave Rs 1,63,200 for loss of future earning capacity.
Five months of lost earnings added Rs 20,000 and medical expenses Rs 15,930. Special diet and transport carried Rs 5,000, pain and suffering Rs 25,000 and attendant charges Rs 4,000.
The total was Rs 2,33,130, with interest at 7 per cent a year from 28 June 2013, when the claim petition was filed.
An appeal dismissed in 2015, restored in 2024
Mr Sabir appealed to the High Court under Section 173(1) of the Act for more money. On 29 April 2015 the appeal was dismissed because defects in it were not removed in the time allowed.
On 26 April 2024 the High Court restored it on payment of Rs 1,000 as costs. It added a condition: if the compensation went up, he would get no interest for the years the appeal lay dismissed.
On 1 September 2025, in Miscellaneous Appeal 548 of 2014, a Single Judge raised the compensation by Rs 2,00,000 over the Tribunal’s award. Mr Sabir, still dissatisfied, came to the Supreme Court.
What the two sides argued
Mr N.K. Mody, Senior Advocate for Mr Sabir, said Rs 4,000 a month was below the minimum wage of an unskilled labourer. Courts, he argued, should be pragmatic and not insist on strict proof of income.
He said the disability certificate showed his earning capacity had been badly hit. Future prospects, medical expenses, attendant charges and pain and suffering were also under-assessed, and the High Court raised the award by only Rs 2,00,000.
The driver and the owner of the truck did not contest. Mr Sanathana Bhaarath, for the insurer, said both courts had awarded reasonable compensation and that no income had been proved. The doctor, he added, had said the disability would reduce with treatment.
The bench recorded that the finding on the driver’s fault and the insurer’s liability was not under challenge. Only the amount of just compensation was in issue, and Mr Sabir deserved more than the High Court gave.
Rs 2 lakh with no workings
The Tribunal had worked through separate heads. The High Court added Rs 2,00,000 without saying how it reached the figure, though it ought to have taken each head in turn and asked whether the Tribunal’s grant was just.
A composite increase with no stated basis, the bench said, could be termed:
“an exercise of guesswork rather than applying the law laid down” (para 8)
It reproduced Raj Kumar v. Ajay Kumar (2010 INSC 703), which splits personal injury damages into pecuniary heads and non-pecuniary heads. The first group covers treatment costs, loss of earnings during treatment, loss of future earnings from permanent disability and future medical expenses.
The second covers pain and suffering, loss of amenities and loss of expectation of life. In routine cases only treatment costs, earnings lost during treatment and pain and suffering are awarded, and the other heads need specific medical evidence.
The High Court had not done that exercise. The Supreme Court did it, head by head, beginning with income.
Income pegged to the minimum wage
Mr Sabir had produced no proof of his monthly income, and the High Court had not examined the point. Where there is none, the court said, the loss can be worked out from the minimum wage of an unskilled worker published by the Labour Commissioner’s office for the relevant period.
For April 2013 that figure was Rs 5,270 a month, or Rs 63,240 a year. Taking his age as 30, the bench applied the multiplier of 17.
Functional disability set at 50 per cent
The certificate recorded 50 per cent permanent disability of the right leg. The court asked what that meant for his work. He collects and sells milk by travelling from place to place, and his mobility would definitely be affected.
Taking an overall view, it assessed his functional disability at 50 per cent, against the Tribunal’s 20, and cited Indra Bai (2023 INSC 624). Net annual income came to Rs 5,37,540, which is Rs 5,270 for 12 months, multiplied by 17, at 50 per cent.
Future prospects and the smaller heads
Future prospects at 40 per cent added Rs 2,15,016, following National Insurance Company Limited v. Pranay Sethi (2017 INSC 1068). The net income figure became Rs 7,52,556.
For earnings lost during treatment the court allowed six months at Rs 5,270, or Rs 31,620. Medical expenses stayed at Rs 15,930, as they rested on receipts and vouchers.
Special diet and transport rose from Rs 5,000 to Rs 50,000, and pain and suffering from Rs 25,000 to Rs 1,00,000. Attendant charges went from Rs 4,000 to Rs 25,000, because his injuries meant he would need help with daily chores for some period.
The Rs 2,00,000 the High Court had added stays in the total. The sum came to Rs 11,75,106, against Rs 4,33,130 after the High Court’s ruling.
Interest and the lost years
Interest at 7 per cent a year, which the Tribunal granted and the High Court kept, was found reasonable. It runs from 28 June 2013, when the claim petition was filed, until payment.
The High Court’s condition of 26 April 2024 continues to operate. No interest is payable on the enhanced amount for the period from 29 April 2015 to 26 April 2024, when the appeal lay dismissed.
Order
The Supreme Court held that Mr Sabir is entitled to Rs 11,75,106 with interest at 7 per cent a year from 28 June 2013 until realisation, subject to the exclusion above. The High Court’s judgment of 1 September 2025 stands modified.
The civil appeal is allowed and disposed of. The parties bear their own costs, and the pending interlocutory application is disposed of.