Supreme Court will not police Cauvery flows: CWMA found no backlog, Tamil Nadu pleas fail
Justice Vikram Nath and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh dismissed three applications in the Cauvery case, leaving release shortfalls and monitoring to the CWMA and its regulation committee.
In a deficient monsoon year Tamil Nadu asked the Supreme Court to make Karnataka release 26.954 TMC of Cauvery water in one application and 16.01 TMC in another, both “forthwith”. On 20 November the Court declined both.
A bench of Justice Vikram Nath and Justice Aparesh Kumar Singh held that the shortfall claims belong to the Cauvery Water Management Authority (CWMA) and its Cauvery Water Regulation Committee (CWRC). It also dismissed a third application, filed by the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam, which was not a party to the original proceedings before the Tribunal.
Justice Vikram Nath wrote the judgment. It records that the CWMA, at its 58th meeting on 24 September 2026, had already concluded that there was no backlog shortfall.
Three applications in a decided appeal
All three applications were filed in Civil Appeal 2453 of 2007, the long-decided inter-State dispute among Karnataka, Kerala, Tamil Nadu and the Union Territory of Puducherry. The Court had adjudicated it on 16 February 2018, in a judgment reported at (2018) 4 SCC 1. That judgment modified the award of the Cauvery Water Disputes Tribunal, dated 5 February 2007.
The Court had also directed the Union of India to frame a Scheme to put the judgment into effect. The Centre notified the Cauvery Water Management Scheme on 1 June 2018, creating the CWMA and the CWRC.
The two applications by Tamil Nadu are Miscellaneous Application 2445 of 2026 and Miscellaneous Application 2843 of 2026. The third is a diary-numbered application, number 46291 of 2026, from the DMK. The judgment mentions senior counsel for both States but names none.
The first plea: a 15-day order
Tamil Nadu wrote to the CWMA chairman on 14 July 2026, citing the rainfall deficit in the current irrigation year and asking for directions to Karnataka. At its 54th meeting on 30 July 2026 the CWMA reviewed conditions in the basin and the CWRC’s recommendations.
It directed Karnataka’s member to ensure releases from the Krishnaraja Sagara (KRS) and Kabini reservoirs together, so that flows of 3,500 cusecs reached Billigundulu for 15 days from 8 AM on 29 July 2026. Billigundulu is the inter-State border point where the flows are measured.
Tamil Nadu then moved the Court. It asked for an order that Karnataka implement the CWMA decision and deliver 3,500 cusecs for 15 days, which it put at 4.536 TMC, by 12 August 2026.
It also asked for a direction to the CWMA to have Karnataka make good a shortfall of 26.954 TMC for the period from 1 June to 12 August 2026. A third prayer sought a CWMA check on Karnataka’s reservoirs every ten days.
What each State argued
Tamil Nadu said that even if Karnataka obeyed the CWMA, a shortfall of 5.379 TMC would remain. It relied on the Centre’s notification of 1 June 2018 to argue that such a backlog should not be allowed to build up. It also alleged wilful non-compliance with the CWMA’s directions.
Karnataka answered that the ten-daily and monthly releases are not inflexible. A shortfall in one week or month, it said, can be carried forward and adjusted in later months up to the end of the season in January.
It added that in a year of distress the obligations under the 2018 judgment may be proportionately reduced, and that the present year falls in that category. The judgment records the point as an assertion of Karnataka. The Court did not decide it.
Two days late, then more than enough
The bench called the application misconceived, particularly because the expert body for monitoring Cauvery releases was already seized of the matter. Karnataka had filed a short reply affidavit that accepted an initial shortfall but said the deficit was made good once the Wayanad region received adequate rainfall.
Karnataka said it released 1,65,080 cusecs of water from its reservoirs. It fairly acknowledged a delay of two days in complying with the CWMA direction. Flow at Billigundulu was then recorded at 86,797 cusecs, against the 45,500 cusecs stipulated at the 54th meeting.
The Court noted that Tamil Nadu itself had fairly acknowledged this position in its response to the affidavit. The figures are set out as the judgment records them.
Why the Court stayed out of it
The release schedule runs on an annual cycle from June to May, the bench observed. Tamil Nadu’s fear that its yearly allocation would not be met therefore appeared premature.
Both the CWMA and the CWRC include representatives of Tamil Nadu and Karnataka, and the bench found it difficult to accept that those bodies would disregard the applicant’s concerns. Both States admitted that the CWRC meets every fifteen days, hears the parties and issues directions suited to the conditions of the day.
The application, the Court said, was an attempt to draw it into the continuing process of monitoring and enforcing the release schedule. That function was given to the CWMA and the CWRC under the Scheme that the 2018 judgment itself called for. Granting the relief would put the Court in the shoes of those authorities.
“neither warranted nor appropriate” (para 13)
With that, the first application was dismissed and pending applications were disposed of.
The second plea: 6,000 cusecs and 16.01 TMC
By the second application Tamil Nadu sought three things. It wanted Karnataka directed to ensure the CWMA decision of 8 September 2026, a supply of 6,000 cusecs from 9 to 23 September, and to make good a shortfall of 16.01 TMC for the period from 1 June to 9 September 2026.
The judgment records that Karnataka had by then made good the shortfall under the 30 July directions. On 8 September the CWMA held its 57th meeting to consider deficient monsoon inflows into the reservoirs of the basin.
It weighed live storage in Karnataka and Tamil Nadu, and the declining inflows into Karnataka’s four reservoirs. It also looked at gauge and discharge data from the CWC site upstream of KRS and Kabini, and the IMD’s forecast for the next fortnight.
The CWMA recorded a deficient contribution from the un-intercepted catchment between the two dams and Billigundulu. It noted El Nino conditions, and that the north-east monsoon would benefit Tamil Nadu more than Karnataka.
On that basis it directed daily average flows of 6,000 cusecs at Billigundulu from 8 AM on 9 September 2026 for 15 days. It also asked the party States to conserve water, prioritise drinking, industrial and environmental needs, and issue advisories to farmers.
How the bench dealt with each prayer
On the first prayer, Karnataka disputed Tamil Nadu’s assertions and said it had complied with the 8 September directions and released more than the stipulated quantity. On the second, the bench held that the alleged shortfall and its quantification involve an assessment of distress and of flows across the entire basin.
That, it said, falls within the domain of the CWRC and the CWMA, which exist for exactly this purpose. The Court had already settled the inter-State allocation and the governing principles.
It would not issue a separate direction to either State on the strength of disputed calculations. The matter was left to the two bodies, to be considered in accordance with law.
Tamil Nadu’s senior counsel argued, lastly, that the CWRC and the CWMA were not addressing its concerns about the Billigundulu shortfall. The bench could not accept that.
The Court reads the minutes
An order of 31 August 2026 had recorded that the CWRC meets every fifteen days and issues directions after hearing the parties. The bench now went through the minutes of the CWRC and CWMA meetings of 8 September 2026.
They showed, it said, that both bodies considered the submissions of all the States, including the two parties before the Court, and specifically addressed the grievances of Tamil Nadu.
Karnataka had pointed out that the CWMA considered the flows into four reservoirs and also the intermediate catchment and the catchment below the inter-State border that lies in Tamil Nadu. It said this was done at the meetings of 30 July, 11 August, 25 August, 8 September and 24 September 2026.
The Court found support for that in the minutes of the 58th CWMA meeting. On the submissions of its Member (Water Resources), the Authority held that it could be concluded:
“there is no backlog shortfall” (para 24)
The CWMA then directed Karnataka to maintain the daily average flows stipulated by the Supreme Court, with compliance to be monitored by the CWRC and the CWMA. The second application was dismissed on that footing.
DMK told it was not a party
The third application, Miscellaneous Application Diary No. 46291 of 2026, was filed by the Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam in the disposed-of civil appeal. The bench said the party’s concerns were adequately represented by the State of Tamil Nadu.
The scope of the Tribunal’s award of 5 February 2007, as affirmed and modified on 16 February 2018, should not be enlarged, the Court held. It would not entertain and decide claims or objections raised by an applicant that was not a party to the original proceedings before the Tribunal.
Order
Miscellaneous Application 2445 of 2026 was dismissed. Miscellaneous Application 2843 of 2026 was dismissed, with the shortfall question left to the CWRC and the CWMA to consider in accordance with law.
The DMK’s application, Diary No. 46291 of 2026, was dismissed. Pending applications in each matter stand disposed of.