NCLAT COMPANY APPEAL IBC NCLAT A pledge of receivables can makeyou a guarantor
[ NCLAT ]

Hypothecation deed read as guarantee: NCLAT keeps four Imagine companies in Delhi insolvency

Bindu Kapoor, suspended director of four Imagine companies registered in Mumbai, said they only hypothecated receivables and never guaranteed a Bliss House loan, so the NCLT in Delhi had no jurisdiction. The Principal Bench holds the loan agreement and deed together made them guarantors, and that Imagine Estate also owes Rs 596 crore directly.

The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) at New Delhi has upheld the admission of four Imagine group companies into corporate insolvency resolution (CIRP) on petitions by J C Flowers Asset Reconstruction Pvt Ltd. It held that companies which hypothecated their receivables for a Rs 105 crore loan to Bliss House Pvt Ltd were corporate guarantors.

That finding brought them within Section 60(2) of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC), so the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT) in New Delhi could hear the petitions although their registered offices are in Mumbai. The judgment is dated 6 November 2026.

Justice Yogesh Khanna, Officiating Chairperson, sat with Barun Mitra and Ajai Das Mehrotra, both Technical Members. The four appeals by suspended director Bindu Kapoor are Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) Nos. 933, 934, 935 and 943 of 2026.

Four companies, one NCLT order

All four appeals challenge a common order of 7 April 2026, in which the NCLT admitted four companies into CIRP. They are Imagine Estate (CP (IB) No. 36 of 2026), Imagine Home (No. 32), Imagine Residence (No. 31) and Imagine Habitat (No. 30). Mamta Binani was appointed interim resolution professional.

Kapoor appealed as suspended director of each company. The judgment says the issues are common and takes up the facts of Imagine Estate, J C Flowers Asset Reconstruction Pvt Ltd v. Imagine Estate, as the lead appeal, No. 933.

Three sets of loans, one hypothecation deed

J C Flowers, acting as trustee of JCF ARC Trust 2024-2025, based its petition on three sets of loans. First, Imagine Estate's hypothecation against a Rs 105 crore loan that Bliss House Pvt Ltd took from Indiabulls Housing Finance Ltd (IHFL) under an agreement of 29 March 2019.

Second, loans of Rs 160 crore and Rs 90 crore that Imagine Estate itself took from IHFL on 5 September 2018. Third, loans of Rs 172 crore and Rs 174 crore from Indiabulls Commercial Credit Ltd on 7 October 2019. Together the second and third sets total Rs 596 crore.

IHFL issued loan recall notices on 9 March 2020, saying an event of default had occurred through a material adverse effect. The appellant says it gave no justification for that.

IHFL went to arbitration. Hearings ended on 8 May 2021 and the sole arbitrator reserved the awards, which came on 28 February 2023, a delay of one year, nine months and twenty days in the appellant's account. Bliss House and Imagine Estate challenged them under Section 34 of the Arbitration Act in the Delhi High Court in September 2023.

How a Mumbai company reached Delhi

IHFL assigned its rights under the Rs 105 crore and Rs 596 crore loans to J C Flowers on 29 March 2025. On 24 October 2025 J C Flowers filed a Section 7 petition against Bliss House, which the NCLT in New Delhi admitted on 21 January 2026.

On 4 December 2025 it filed the Section 7 petition against Imagine Estate in New Delhi too, though the company's registered office is in Mumbai. It called the company an obligor under the Rs 105 crore loan and the hypothecation deed a guarantee, which let the NCLT use Section 60(2).

The appellant calls the NCLT's order of 7 April 2026 entirely unreasoned. The NCLT held that the companies had liability as corporate guarantors and rejected the plea of territorial jurisdiction.

The appellant: hypothecators, not guarantors

Krishnendu Datta, Senior Advocate for Kapoor, admitted that CIRP against Bliss House, the principal borrower, had been confirmed up to the Supreme Court. His case was that the four companies stood on different facts.

They had hypothecated assets, he argued, and had not guaranteed anything. Section 60(1) sends a corporate debtor's case to the bench where its registered office sits, here Mumbai, and Section 60(2) did not apply because no company was a corporate guarantor.

The petition itself, he said, called the companies corporate guarantors, and the NCLT accepted that. But none had signed a guarantee. The only guarantors named in the loan agreement were Rana Kapoor and Bindu Kapoor.

A guarantee under Section 126 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 needs a tripartite agreement, he argued. The hypothecators had not signed the loan agreements and the borrowers had not signed the deed of hypothecation. The NCLT relied on only clause 1 of the deed and ignored the rest.

He said the NCLT had misread China Development Bank v. Doha Bank, (2025) 7 SCC 729, which concerned a tripartite deed. He also relied on Punjab National Bank v. Vikram Cotton Mills and the tribunal's own ruling in J C Flowers Asset Reconstruction v. Vithal M. Dahake.

The word "obligor" in the loan agreement, he said, covers borrowers, guarantors, mortgagors, pledgors and hypothecators alike. Each is liable only to the extent of the documents it signed, so the hypothecators were not co-extensive with the borrower.

Abhijeet Sinha, Senior Advocate, appeared for J C Flowers and Sandeep Bajaj, Advocate, for the interim resolution professional. The judgment records only that the respondents rebutted each argument.

The single question

The judgment states the issue in the course of recording the appellant's case.

"The main issue is whether these four companies are the corporate guarantors of the principal borrower." (para 7)

Before reaching it, the tribunal noted that Bliss House's admission into CIRP, on 21 January 2026, had been affirmed by the tribunal on 29 May 2026 and by the Supreme Court. That default had attained finality.

The only remaining issue, it said, was whether Section 60(2) had been validly invoked. The appeal raised the same grounds that Bliss House had raised and lost.

What the loan agreement made them

The bench read the loan agreement of 29 March 2019 with the deed. Schedule I undisputedly lists Imagine Estate as a "Hypothecator". Clause 1.1 defines "Obligors" to include the borrower and the hypothecators, and clause 2.1 makes all obligors jointly and severally liable for the dues.

Clause 12.2 lets the lender recall the debt on an event of default, whereupon the obligors, a term that specifically includes hypothecators, must pay immediately. Clause 2.2.4 obliges the obligors to pay from any source if there is a shortfall in the escrow account, a payment default or an event of default.

The company, the bench said, admittedly executed the deed of hypothecation and thereby assumed all the obligations in the loan agreement. Its recitals name the loan agreement and record that obligors include the hypothecator, a status the company admits.

Clause 1 of the deed repeats the assumption of those obligations, and clause 5 requires the two documents to be read together, with the loan agreement prevailing over the deed in case of inconsistency.

Recall, default and a Rs 260 crore demand

The loan recall notice of 9 March 2020 was issued after the arrest of Rana Kapoor, the judgment says. With no repayment within the five days stipulated, default occurred on 14 March 2020.

The arbitral awards of 28 February 2023 affirmed the liability of Bliss House and the other group entities. The award in IHFL v. Bliss House held Imagine Home and Imagine Residence jointly and severally liable for the Rs 105 crore debt.

Imagine Estate is also directly liable for the Rs 596 crore of loans, the bench said. The awards on those are under challenge in the Delhi High Court, in O.M.P. (Comm) Nos. 359, 363 and 365 of 2023, but no stay has been granted and nothing has been repaid.

Assignment agreements of 29 March 2025 and 30 August 2025 moved all rights to J C Flowers. Its demand notice of 29 September 2025 called for Rs 260,32,53,778.61, and the bench recorded that it went unanswered and unpaid.

Why Delhi, not Mumbai

Section 60(2), the bench said, opens with a non-obstante clause that carves an exception out of the registered-office rule in Section 60(1). The principal borrower and its guarantor are heard by the same tribunal, which avoids conflicting orders and double realisation.

Bliss House is in CIRP before the NCLT in New Delhi, and its admission is final up to the Supreme Court. So the CIRP of the corporate debtor, as a corporate guarantor, must go before the same bench.

The bench cited its judgment of 1 August 2025 in S. Vasudevan v. IDBI Trusteeship. That upheld proceedings at Chennai against a corporate guarantor registered in Bengaluru, because the principal borrower's case was there.

It also noted that the NCLT consolidated the CIRPs of Imagine Estate and Bliss House on 12 June 2026. The two are subsidiaries of RAB Enterprises with common ownership and promoters, the bench said, forming a single integrated group.

No tripartite deed, still a guarantee

Section 5(5A) IBC defines a corporate guarantor as a corporate person who is surety in a contract of guarantee. Section 126 of the Contract Act defines that contract as one to perform the promise or discharge the liability of a third person in case of default, and says it may be oral or written.

The bench found each element present: Bliss House as principal borrower, IHFL, now J C Flowers, as creditor, and Imagine Estate as surety by being an obligor. Clauses 2.1 and 12.2 made obligors jointly and severally liable and clause 2.2.4 required payment of any shortfall from any source.

The Supreme Court in China Development Bank had treated a covenant to pay on shortfall as a guarantee, it said. The covenant in that case was in substance identical to clauses 2.1 and 2.2.4 read with clause 1 of the deed.

"the substance of a document’s covenants, irrespective of its nomenclature, is decisive" (para 35)

So it did not matter that Imagine Estate was never called a guarantor. A contract of guarantee can be spread over several agreements, the bench said, if the intent to stand as guarantor is clear, and the loan agreement and deed together showed a tripartite arrangement among borrower, creditor and surety.

That Bliss House had not signed the deed was irrelevant, since the deed itself shows assumption of the loan agreement's obligations. The plea sat badly with Kapoor, the bench added, since she signed the loan agreement for Bliss House and the deed for Imagine Estate as common director.

It also noted that Punjab National Bank v. Vikram Cotton Mills, which the appellant himself cited, held that missing signatures on a single document do not defeat a guarantee. A guarantee can be inferred from conduct, an oral agreement or several agreements read together.

Liable for Rs 596 crore in any case

Even apart from the guarantee, the bench held, the company is liable for the Rs 596 crore of loans that it took itself. It cited Innoventive Industries v. ICICI Bank, (2018) 1 SCC 407, and E.S. Krishnamurthy v. Bharath HiTech Builders, (2022) 3 SCC 161: once debt and default are established, the adjudicating authority must admit the petition.

The appellant had not denied that the Imagine loan agreements were executed, that the money was disbursed or that it was not repaid.

Order

NCLAT held that the NCLT's order of 7 April 2026 suffered from no illegality and dismissed all four appeals, Nos. 933, 934, 935 and 943 of 2026. Pending applications stood disposed of.

The admission of Imagine Estate, Imagine Home, Imagine Residence and Imagine Habitat into CIRP by the NCLT in New Delhi stands.