A balance sheet he never signed keeps a guarantor on the hook for Rs 24.44 crore, NCLAT holds
Manoj Kumar Agarwal argued that IL and FS Financial Services invoked his personal guarantee in August 2018 and its Section 95 application came 284 days too late. The Principal Bench disagrees: clause 5(f) of his guarantee deed made the 2020 acknowledgment by the borrower his own, and the Supreme Court had already fixed limitation for the borrower.
The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) at New Delhi has upheld the start of personal insolvency proceedings against Manoj Kumar Agarwal, guarantor of a Rs 24.44 crore loan to Adhunik Meghalaya Steels Pvt Ltd. The lender had invoked his guarantee in 2018, but the steelmaker's 2019-20 balance sheet still kept the claim in time against him.
The order of 6 November 2026 was written by Justice Mohammad Faiz Alam Khan, Member (Judicial), who sat with Naresh Salecha, Member (Technical). It dismisses Agarwal's appeal against the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), Guwahati Bench, which admitted the Section 95 application of IL and FS Financial Services Ltd on 9 September 2026. There is no order as to costs.
A Rs 30 crore facility and two notices
Adhunik Meghalaya Steels (the corporate debtor) took a term loan facility of up to Rs 30 crore from IL and FS Financial Services (the financial creditor) under a loan agreement of 27 February 2015. Rs 24,44,44,456 was disbursed on 17 March 2015.
Agarwal signed a deed of personal guarantee on the same day the loan agreement was signed. The facility was also secured by a pledge of shares of Adhunik Metaliks Ltd, which the appeal describes as worth about Rs 50 crore at the time.
The account turned into a non-performing asset on 1 March 2018. The lender had invoked and realised part of the pledged shares in 2016-17 and 2017-18, recovering about Rs 8.30 crore.
It issued an event of default notice on 10 July 2018, giving seven days to cure the default. A recall facility notice of 10 August 2018 called for the whole loan, with interest and penalty, within 48 hours. The first went to the corporate debtor and others including guarantors and pledgers, and the second to the corporate debtor and Agarwal.
The borrower's case went to the Supreme Court
IL and FS first filed a Section 7 petition against the steelmaker, CP (IB) No. 02/GB/2024. The NCLT dismissed it as time-barred on 16 May 2024, and the NCLAT affirmed that on 25 March 2025.
The Supreme Court set both orders aside on 30 July 2025 in Civil Appeal No. 5787 of 2025. It sent the petition back to be decided as one filed within limitation, relying on an acknowledgment dated 12 August 2020 and the Covid exclusion from 15 March 2020 to 28 February 2022.
A review petition failed on 30 October 2025. The NCLT then admitted the Section 7 petition on 21 July 2026.
Alongside this, IL and FS had served a statutory Form B demand notice on Agarwal on 20 March 2024, delivered on 23 March. He replied on 22 April, disputing the liability, the amount and limitation. The Section 95 application, CP (IB) No. 12/GB/2024, followed on 8 May 2024.
The NCLT appointed Sanjay Poddar as resolution professional on 8 November 2024. His Section 99 report of 23 December 2024 recommended starting the insolvency resolution process, and the NCLT did so on 9 September 2026.
The guarantor: the clock started in 2018
Arun Kathpalia, Senior Advocate for Agarwal, argued that the date that mattered was the date the guarantee was invoked. That was the recall notice of 10 August 2018, and the Section 95 application was filed on 8 May 2024.
Even after excluding the Covid period, he said, the filing came 284 days after the last date, 29 July 2023. His time-flow chart in the written submissions made the same point.
Limitation against a guarantor, he argued, must be worked out independently of the borrower. The borrower's acknowledgment could not count as the guarantor's after a separate cause of action had arisen, and he cited Syndicate Bank v. Channaveerappa Beleri, (2006) 11 SCC 506.
Clause 5(f) of the deed, he said, was subject to Section 18 of the Limitation Act, 1963 and operated only until invocation. A later acknowledgment could not revive a period that had already expired, and the guarantee could not be invoked a second time just to extend limitation.
He called State Bank of India v. Bernard John, 2025 SCC OnLine NCLAT 1670, confined to its facts, since the guarantee there was not invoked before the borrower's acknowledgment. The Supreme Court's order of 15 May 2026 in that matter, he said, was a threshold dismissal.
He added that IL and FS had realised about Rs 8.30 crore from the pledged shares and still held roughly 78.87 lakh of them. The amount in the application was therefore wrong, and the borrower had not challenged the Section 7 admission of 21 July 2026.
The lender: the Supreme Court has spoken
Raunak Dhillon, Advocate for IL and FS, said the Supreme Court's judgment of 30 July 2025 had settled limitation for this very debt, and the review dismissal made it final. Agarwal could not reopen it in proceedings on the same guaranteed debt.
Clause 5(f), he said, binds the guarantor to any written acknowledgment by the borrower for purposes of limitation. The point was covered by Bernard John, where a similar clause and a 2016 invocation did not stop the acknowledgment from extending limitation.
The guarantee was a valid, unconditional and continuing one, payable on first demand within 24 hours, with joint, several and co-extensive liability. He cited Laxmi Pat Surana v. Union Bank of India and BRS Ventures Investments v. SREI Infrastructure Finance, saying partial recovery does not extinguish a guarantor's liability.
What the guarantee deed said
The bench began with the contract. The rights and obligations of the parties, it said, depend on the terms of the guarantee deed, and it reproduced the clauses.
By clause 1, Agarwal undertook to pay on first demand, within 24 hours and without recourse to the borrower, up to Rs 30 crore along with interest and other dues. Clause 2 made the guarantee irrevocable and unconditional until the lender's whole claim was paid.
The lender could enforce it without first proceeding against the borrower. Clause 5(b) made his liability joint, several and co-extensive with the borrower's, and clause 13 declared it a continuing guarantee.
Clause 5(f) was the one that decided the appeal. For purposes of limitation, any written admission or acknowledgment or any part payment by the borrower binds the guarantor and is treated as given on the guarantor's behalf as well.
The tribunal read the deed as a continuing guarantee payable on demand. It held that a written acknowledgment by the principal borrower is deemed acknowledged and admitted by the guarantor too.
Counting the days on the Supreme Court's dates
The NCLT had not decided limitation afresh. It treated the point as settled by the Supreme Court's judgment on the borrower's Section 7 petition, and the bench agreed with that approach.
It set out the Supreme Court's reasoning. With default on 1 March 2018, limitation would ordinarily have run to 28 February 2021. The balance sheet for 2019-20, signed by the board on 12 August 2020, was a valid acknowledgment that carried it to 11 August 2023.
The Covid exclusion from 15 March 2020 to 28 February 2022 then applied, so limitation ran from 1 March 2022 to 28 February 2025. The Section 95 application was filed on 8 May 2024, before that date. The bench saw no reason why it should not be treated as within limitation.
A copy of the notice was enough
The tribunal also dealt with the plea that the guarantee had been invoked in 2018 and the clock had run from then. The event of default notice of 10 July 2018 was addressed to the corporate debtor but copied to Agarwal as personal guarantor.
That was sufficient invocation, the bench held, since the only purpose of invoking a guarantee is to make the guarantor aware that he must discharge his liability. The recall notice of 10 August 2018 was addressed to him as well as the corporate debtor.
The bench noted that, on the lender's own application, the date of default was 1 March 2018 and the corporate debtor had continued to acknowledge the debt in its 2019-20 balance sheet. The dates of default for borrower and guarantor were the same.
Why Syndicate Bank did not help him
On Syndicate Bank, the bench said the judgment shows that the terms of the guarantee decide its nature. Agarwal's deed was an unconditional and continuing guarantee, so his argument that the clock ran from invocation failed.
"no straitjacket formula divorced from the terms of the contract of guarantee" (para 43)
The bench also recalled Laxmi Pat Surana, in which the Supreme Court held that an acknowledgment only by the principal borrower does not absolve the guarantor, because liability is co-extensive under Section 128 of the Contract Act. It quoted its own rulings in Pooja Ramesh Singh v. SBI and Amit Bhatnagar v. UCO Bank for the same scheme.
It then set out Bernard John at length. A coordinate bench there held that clauses deeming the borrower's acknowledgment to be the guarantor's, read with Section 128, extend the effect of the acknowledgment to the guarantor.
The tribunal noted that the Supreme Court dismissed the appeal against Bernard John on 15 May 2026. It held the present case entirely covered by that ruling, and said the other cases Agarwal relied on did not apply.
Order
NCLAT found no illegality in the NCLT's acceptance of the Section 95 application and dismissed the appeal as lacking merit. There is no order as to costs, and pending applications stand disposed of.
The insolvency resolution process against Agarwal as personal guarantor to Adhunik Meghalaya Steels continues under the NCLT's order of 9 September 2026.
The ruling measures limitation for the guarantor to the same end date the Supreme Court gave the borrower's petition, 28 February 2025. The Section 95 application of 8 May 2024 fell before it.