NCLAT COMPANY APPEAL IBC NCLAT Pending guarantor petitions losethe interim moratorium shield
[ NCLAT ]

Moratorium of December 2024 no shield: NCLAT applies Section 96(4) to pending guarantor cases

Two personal guarantors said Equentia Financial Services filed its Section 95 petitions in November 2025, while an earlier Canara Bank petition had an interim moratorium running, so the filings were non-est. The Principal Bench holds the May 2026 amendment applies to pending proceedings and no moratorium existed when the NCLT admitted the petitions.

The National Company Law Appellate Tribunal (NCLAT) at New Delhi has held that the new sub-section (4) of Section 96 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016 (IBC) applies to pending cases. Personal guarantors to corporate debtors no longer have an interim moratorium, even where their Section 95 proceedings began before the amendment.

The common judgment of 6 November 2026 dismisses the appeals of Sri Narain Aggarwal and Sangeeta Aggarwal against orders of the National Company Law Tribunal (NCLT), New Delhi, Bench II. Justice Mohammad Faiz Alam Khan, Member (Judicial), wrote it, sitting with Naresh Salecha, Member (Technical).

Sangeeta Aggarwal's appeal is Company Appeal (AT) (Insolvency) No. 1804 of 2026, and Sri Narain Aggarwal's is No. 1805 of 2026. The bench disposed of both together because the issues were identical.

Two lenders chase the same guarantors

On 6 December 2024 Canara Bank filed Section 95 applications against both guarantors before the NCLT Ahmedabad Bench, CP (IB) Nos. 22 and 23 of 2024. An interim moratorium under Section 96 began that day, and Sunil Kumar Kabra was appointed resolution professional on 22 January 2025.

On 1 April 2025 the NCLT New Delhi, Bench V, started corporate insolvency resolution against the corporate debtor, in CP (IB) No. 413 (ND) of 2025. Equentia Financial Services Pvt Ltd filed a claim of Rs 13.40 crore in that process.

Equentia then filed its own Section 95 petitions at the NCLT in Delhi. The one against Sangeeta Aggarwal, CP (IB) No. 651 of 2025, was filed on 5 November 2025, and the one against Sri Narain Aggarwal, CP (IB) No. 653 of 2025, on 7 November 2025.

Canara Bank withdrew its Ahmedabad proceedings on 21 November 2025. On 19 December 2025 it filed fresh petitions at the NCLT in New Delhi, which are stated to be pending.

Loveneet Handa was the resolution professional on Equentia's petitions. His Section 99 reports of 17 and 27 February 2026 recommended starting personal insolvency resolution against each guarantor. On 31 August 2026 the NCLT accepted both petitions and initiated the process.

The guarantors: petitions filed mid-moratorium

Rahul Gupta, Advocate for the guarantors, said the facts were admitted. Canara Bank's filing on 6 December 2024 started an interim moratorium, and Equentia's petitions came during it. Proceedings filed in that window, he argued, are non-est.

Canara Bank's withdrawal on 21 November 2025 and fresh filing on 19 December 2025 made no difference, he said. On 5 November 2025 the moratorium from 6 December 2024 was still in force.

The NCLT had relied on the new Section 96(4), which came into force on 26 May 2026. He called the amendment not retrospective and said it could not reach petitions already pending. He relied on Alchemist Asset Reconstruction Co. v. Hotel Gaudavan, (2018) 16 SCC 94, and on the tribunal's own decision in Sushant Chhabra v. Catalyst Trusteeship.

He noted that the Bombay High Court had called the amendment retroactive, not retrospective, which he said means it applies prospectively to existing facts. A purely prospective amendment, he argued, would reach only petitions filed after 26 May 2026.

He also said the Delhi High Court's ruling in IDBI Trusteeship Services v. Manish Jain decided only an Order VII Rule 11 application. The circular of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Board of India (IBBI) dated 21 September 2026, he added, contravened the tribunal's decision in Sundaresh Bhat, Liquidator of ABG Shipyard.

Equentia and the resolution professional

Counsel for Equentia and the resolution professional said the guarantors' whole case rested on an interim moratorium that Section 96(4) had removed. Inserted by Section 51 of the Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code (Amendment) Act, 2026, it says Section 96 does not apply to an application for initiating insolvency resolution against a personal guarantor to a corporate debtor.

The Bombay High Court in Tata Capital Financial Services v. Neel Motors LLP and the Delhi High Court in IDBI Trusteeship, he said, had applied Section 96(4) to pending proceedings. The IBBI circular, number IBBI/II/106/2026, recorded the effect.

Applying a new provision to facts that continue to exist, he argued, is prospective application and does not turn retroactive. The impugned orders came on 31 August 2026, after the amendment. Sushant Chhabra could not mean that a later statute had no effect on pending cases.

Counsel for the resolution professional added that the guarantors had concealed the earlier Ahmedabad petition, which was later withdrawn. They then used its pendency to attack the Delhi proceedings and filed their own application at the NCLT in Delhi, CP (IB) No. 707 of 2025, he said.

The one question the bench asked

The bench listed what no one disputed: Canara Bank's filing on 6 December 2024, Equentia's filings in November 2025, the withdrawal, the amendment on 26 May 2026 and the orders of 31 August 2026. That left one issue, which it put this way.

"whether the amendment made in Section 96 (vide Amendment Act, 2026), whereby Subsection 4 has been inserted in Section 96" (para 36)

The question, in the bench's words, was whether that provision would apply to the proceedings in which the impugned orders were passed. It noted that the NCLT had followed the Bombay High Court's ruling in Tata Capital and held Equentia's petitions were not hit by the interim moratorium.

Rulings from before the amendment

The bench set out the law the guarantors relied on. In Union Bank of India v. P.K. Balasubramanian (29 March 2023), the tribunal had said the Code does not contemplate multiple applications against the same personal guarantor. Once one insolvency process begins, all creditors are dealt with in it.

In Alchemist, the Supreme Court held an arbitration begun after the Section 14 moratorium was non-est. Sushant Chhabra (27 March 2026) applied that to Section 96. A Section 95 application had been filed during a moratorium triggered by Canara Bank's earlier petition, and withdrawal of that petition did not rescue it.

The bench recorded that all these decisions pre-dated 26 May 2026. In this case Canara Bank's petitions were filed on 6 December 2024 and Equentia's during that moratorium, but the impugned orders came after the amendment.

Retroactive, not retrospective

The bench then quoted the High Courts. In Tata Capital, the Bombay High Court read "is filed" in Section 96(4) as covering anything filed and still pending, and described that as retroactive, not retrospective. A moratorium that operated until 25 May 2026 ceased from 26 May 2026.

In IDBI Trusteeship (19 August 2026), the Delhi High Court looked at the Select Committee report on the 2025 amendment Bill. That report spoke of misuse of the interim moratorium by guarantors who file only to obstruct or delay recovery. The court held Section 96(4) retroactive, so a pending application was no longer shielded.

A Bombay High Court division bench in Indian Bank v. Shabbir Abbas Patel reached the same answer on the mischief rule. It said parties with pending proceedings cannot claim a vested right to the interim moratorium. It also said a proceeding filed during the moratorium is not void from the start, only ineffective while it lasts.

The bench added that the Supreme Court, on 28 October 2026, had dismissed special leave petitions against that Bombay ruling in Chitrasen Nagnath Gulave v. Apna Sahakari Bank. It found no error of law in the High Court's judgment.

The IBBI circular and the bench's experience

The bench also took note of IBBI Circular No. IBBI/II/106/2026 of 21 September 2026, issued under Section 196 of the Code. It directs that the interim moratorium for a personal guarantor to a corporate debtor ceased on 26 May 2026 in applications pending then. The judgment does not separately rule on the guarantors' objection to the circular.

It repeated what the Select Committee report said about the amendment's aim. The Ministry's stated reasons were that adjudicating authorities had voiced concern about guarantors using the personal insolvency process to take advantage of the interim moratorium. The Bill sought to remove that incentive, and the bench added its own view from experience.

"this provision has been widely misused" (para 50)

The tribunal said that whenever recovery begins against a guarantor, the guarantor rushes to the adjudicating authority to invoke the interim moratorium. It said it had flagged the problem in many judgments.

No moratorium on 31 August

The bench concluded that the 2026 amendment to Section 96 applies retroactively and to pending proceedings. After 26 May 2026 there was no moratorium. The orders of 31 August 2026 were passed when none was in operation.

"would apply retroactively, and also to the pending proceedings" (para 52)

It therefore found no illegality in the NCLT's orders. Its reasoning on this point rests on the date of the orders, not on the date Equentia's petitions were filed.

Order

NCLAT dismissed both appeals as lacking merit and left the NCLT's orders of 31 August 2026 in place. The personal insolvency resolution processes against Sri Narain Aggarwal and Sangeeta Aggarwal continue on Equentia's petitions.

There is no order as to costs, and pending applications stand disposed of.