Justice M.N. Jadhav Bombay HC CASE QUASHED Cheating case against directorsquashed
[ Bombay High Court ]

Bombay HC quashes cheating case against 85-year-old director lodged 27 days after refund suits

Justice Milind Jadhav held that three directors of Rizvi Land Development were prosecuted for MOUs signed by a son who died in 2017, with no role attributed to them, after buyers failed to win interim relief in civil suits.

Four brothers paid Rs 70 lakh each in 2013 for office units in a proposed development. After approaching at least eight forums, one of them lodged an FIR against the developer’s 85-year-old director, 27 days after the brothers filed civil suits for a refund.

The Bombay High Court quashed the FIR, the chargesheet and the pending case on 18 November. Justice Milind N. Jadhav held that no cognizable offence was made out against the director, his daughter and his former wife, and that the dispute was purely civil.

Four MOUs signed by a son

The company, Rizvi Land Development, is the first accused. Its director Dr Akhtar Hasan Rizvi, 85, is the second. His daughter Meena and his former wife, aged 84, are the third and fourth.

His son Abis Rizvi, the fifth accused, died on 1 January 2017.

The complainant, Junaid Ebrahim Khan, and his three brothers signed four separate MOUs with the company on 22 April 2013. Each paid Rs 70 lakh, half the price, for a commercial unit in a proposed development.

Abis Rizvi alone signed all four for the company. The court recorded that no company resolution authorised him and that the other directors did not know of the MOUs.

Flats offered, complaints filed

After his son’s death, Dr Rizvi negotiated with the brothers. At their request, four 3 BHK flats were reserved for them in place of the commercial units, and he wrote that the sums paid would be forfeited if the balance was not paid.

The complainant went to MahaRERA on 15 November 2017 and withdrew the complaint unconditionally on 11 January 2018, when it was about to be dismissed. He had also complained to Bandra police, Vakola police and the DCP, Zone VIII.

The Vakola senior inspector consigned the complaint to record on 31 May 2018, saying the complainant had not appeared to pursue it and no cognizable offence was detected.

Suits, a Rs 6 crore deposit, an FIR

The brothers filed commercial suits in July 2022, and the High Court rejected ad-interim relief in them on 22 December 2022. One brother’s suit claims Rs 5.57 crore with 24 per cent interest on his Rs 70 lakh.

The FIR was registered on 28 July 2022 at Vakola police station, and the case was later transferred to the Economic Offences Wing. The charges were Sections 409, 420 and 34 of the Indian Penal Code and Sections 3, 4, 8 and 13 of the Maharashtra Ownership of Flats Act.

Dr Rizvi sought anticipatory bail and was protected from coercive steps. On 8 August 2023 the court directed him to deposit Rs 6 crore, and he paid Rs 3 crore on 11 August and Rs 3 crore on 13 August. The EOW filed its chargesheet on 16 October 2023.

Defence: a son’s deals, no vicarious liability

Mr Aabad Ponda, Senior Advocate for Dr Rizvi, said cheating needs a dishonest intention from the start, while breach of trust needs a lawful entrustment, so the two charges cannot stand together. He said Dr Rizvi signed none of the MOUs.

The Penal Code has no vicarious liability for directors, he argued, and the FIR did not describe any act of his client. He added that the civil suits came first and the buyers had not exercised their buy-back option in time.

The High Court had rejected ad-interim relief in the suits, he noted, on the ground that the claim was a simple money claim. That, in his view, showed the contractual and commercial nature of the dispute.

Mr Ponda also said the four MOUs disclosed a claim of Rs 2.80 crore, yet the complainant alleged a loss of Rs 12 crore without documents. In his submission the claim was raised to bring the matter within the EOW’s remit.

Mr Niranjan Mundargi appeared for the other two petitioners in Writ Petition 502 of 2024 and adopted those submissions. They were named only as directors, he said.

The complainant’s answer

Mr Mandar Soman, for the complainant, said construction of the Rizvi Corporate Park was not finished in the stipulated 24 months, so the brothers invoked the buy-back option. The company refused, he said, because the option had to be exercised within 21 months of the MOU.

MahaRERA, he added, had opined that the dispute arose before the regulator came into force, which is why the complaint there was withdrawn.

He said the land for the proposed Rizvi Corporate Park was reserved for residential use, which the petitioners knew and did not disclose. He called that cheating.

He pointed to letters of 4 June 2021 and 9 August 2021 that demanded Rs 70 lakh per flat instead of the Rs 35 lakh agreed earlier. These, he said, showed dishonest intent.

The directors were jointly and severally liable, he argued, relying on Shivkumar Jatia v State of NCT of Delhi ((2019) 17 SCC 193) on corporate criminal liability. He also cited State of Rajasthan v Mst Vidyawati (AIR 1962 SC 933).

Pending civil suits, age and the Rs 6 crore deposit were no ground to quash, he said, because criminal prosecution is independent of civil remedies.

Twenty-seven days and eight forums

Justice Jadhav began with the timing. The brothers instituted commercial suits on 1 July 2022 for refund of their money. The complainant alone registered the FIR 27 days later, though the MOUs gave him contractual remedies of specific performance and buy-back.

That sequence, the judge said, showed mala fides, and the FIR was meant to badger the petitioners into settling the suit on a demand for four flats. He noted that Dr Rizvi had already deposited Rs 6 crore on the same cause.

The investigation was thin, he found. Only the complainant’s statement was recorded, and no statement of the other three brothers. No bank statement showed that any petitioner received any part of the Rs 70 lakh payments.

He called it shocking that the EOW took the case at all. A circular, not annexed to the chargesheet, shows the wing ordinarily takes offences above Rs 10 crore, and even the valuation obtained from the Sub-Registrar’s office put the claim well below it.

A string of complaints, no orders

The judge listed the complainant’s route over the same MOUs: Bandra police, Vakola police, MahaRERA, the DCP, four complaints in August 2022, the EOW on 31 October 2022, the commercial suits and a perjury application in the City Civil Court.

None had produced an order against the petitioners, he said. He described the FIR and chargesheet as a counterblast meant to push them into submission, and put it this way:

“a classic example of criminal law set into motion to resolve a civil dispute” (para 13)

No role for the other directors

The judge found nothing in the FIR or chargesheet that attributed any role, inducement or transaction to the two petitioners in Writ Petition 502 of 2024. One has lived in the US for about 20 years, and the other is an 84-year-old home maker.

The same applied to Dr Rizvi. The chargesheet describes him as a director but identifies no act of his in the MOU transactions. A director can be prosecuted, the judge said, only where incriminating material shows his own active role coupled with criminal intent.

There was no dishonest inducement at the start, and no entrustment of money to the three petitioners. Section 34, he added, requires a prior meeting of minds and participation, and the facts disclosed neither.

Dr Rizvi’s conduct belied dishonest intent, the judge said. The court had recorded his offer to refund the whole Rs 2.8 crore, and he had then deposited Rs 6 crore.

Bhajan Lal and a civil lis

The judge found the facts squarely covered by guidelines 1, 3 and 7 of paragraph 102 of State of Haryana v Bhajan Lal. Those cover allegations that disclose no offence, uncontroverted material that discloses none, and proceedings attended by mala fides.

He said the case showed “not a hint of criminality” (para 18). Continuing it, with civil suits pending, would be a travesty of justice and harassment in a lis that is primarily civil.

The record also showed attempts at settlement. On 5 April 2023 the court recorded that the complainant would not accept a flat that did not match the specification in the original agreement.

The court then appointed the Additional Public Prosecutor to help the parties. On 22 May 2023 it noted that he had made his best efforts but the complainant did not cooperate in finalising consent terms.

The suits are for money, he noted, and will be decided at trial on evidence. The complainant should have no fear of trial if sure of his case. He and his brothers may seek withdrawal of the deposited sum in accordance with law.

Order

Writ Petition 1489 of 2024 is allowed in terms of prayer (a). FIR 786 of 2022 dated 28 July 2022 of Vakola police station, later renumbered FIR 121 of 2022 of the EOW, the chargesheet and all consequential proceedings in CC 769/PW/2023 before the 47th Metropolitan Magistrate, Esplanade, are quashed against Dr Rizvi.

Writ Petition 502 of 2024 is allowed in terms of prayer (b). The FIR in CR 915 of 2022 dated 30 July 2022 of Vakola police station and the consequential proceedings in the same case are quashed against the two petitioners. Both petitions are disposed of.