Justice S.V. Marne Bombay HC PARTLY ALLOWED Transfers meant to get rid ofworkers cannot stand
[ Bombay High Court ]

Bosch scattered 500-plus workers across India to shed them: Bombay HC orders Rs 25 lakh each

Justice Sandeep V. Marne rejected the three technical grounds on which the Industrial Court struck down the Nashik transfers, but upheld its finding of malice in law and replaced reinstatement with lumpsum compensation.

The transfer order told a Nashik workman, a union representative, that he now belonged to Bosch Limited’s aftermarket division at Aizawl in Mizoram. It gave him five days to report, and asked him to turn up first at a co-working office in Guwahati.

On 19 November, the Bombay High Court held that more than 500 such orders, all issued on one day, were not ordinary transfers. Justice Sandeep V. Marne found they were a device to get rid of temporary workmen the company no longer wanted to pay.

He still refused to send the workers back to Nashik. He ordered Bosch to pay each of them Rs 25 lakh within six weeks.

Red-light days and a Supreme Court affidavit

Bosch Limited makes diesel injectors at its plant in the MIDC area at Satpur, Nashik. Under a March 2018 settlement with the recognised Bosch Employees Union, on-job trainees were adjusted into a new category, the New Entrant Temporary Workman or NETW. It sits between trainee and permanent employee.

Bosch said its major customer, Maruti Suzuki, left the diesel passenger-car market after the BS-VI emission norms, and demand for injectors fell by about half. The company then began what it called “Red-Light Activation”: NETWs whose services were not needed were stopped at the gate.

The affected workers filed unfair labour practice complaints in 2021 and got an interim order for full wages even on days they were kept out. The High Court dismissed Bosch’s challenge on 1 July 2022. The Supreme Court dismissed its special leave petitions on 22 July 2024.

While those petitions were pending, Bosch told the Supreme Court that no work was available at Nashik and offered to transfer the workers to other locations. In the alternative it offered Rs 14 lakh each to 457 NETWs as a full and final settlement. The Supreme Court had asked for names, places and the nature of work.

The dismissal order added that once the workers were taken back, they would be subject to the conditions of service that govern them. Bosch read that as room to transfer them.

Five days to report, one day of orders

Bosch called the NETWs back on 21 August 2024 and paid back wages: Rs 3.5 lakh to 128 workers and about Rs 8.5 lakh to 470. Within about 15 days, on 7 September 2024, it issued transfer orders sending them to locations across the country.

The orders gave five days to report, and many named only a city or state. None of the workers reported at the new places.

They filed a fresh complaint, numbered ULP 46 of 2024, before the Industrial Court at Nashik.

The Industrial Court refused to stay the transfers on 30 September 2024 but barred coercive action. The High Court, on 15 January 2025, asked it to decide quickly. The Supreme Court stayed the no-coercion part on 14 August 2025, and Bosch began disciplinary proceedings.

Several workers were dismissed. In February 2026 the Supreme Court disposed of the cross-petitions and said the dismissals would depend on the outcome of the complaint.

The union told the High Court that 235 of the 521 NETWs had been dismissed. The judge noted that Bosch’s petition did not mention the dismissals, but decided the case on merits rather than on suppression.

What the Industrial Court held

On 29 September 2026, the Industrial Court held that Bosch had engaged in unfair labour practices under Items 3, 9 and 10 of Schedule IV of the Maharashtra Recognition of Trade Unions and Prevention of Unfair Labour Practices Act, 1971. It set aside the transfer orders and ordered the company to let the workers join at Nashik within a month.

It dismissed the complaint against the recognised union. Only Bosch challenged the judgment.

Senior Advocate C U Singh argued for Bosch that the Industrial Court had accepted most of its case yet still found an unfair practice. It had held that NETW work had not gone to contract workers or apprentices, and that the plant made only diesel components.

It had also accepted that production had fallen and that the management could transfer NETWs.

T.K. Prabhakaran, for the union, said the findings rested on evidence and the High Court should not interfere under Article 227. He argued that Bosch’s own figures showed turnover rising from Rs 3,700 crore in 2017-18 to Rs 7,700 crore in 2024-25, so the claim that no work remained was false.

Three findings that fell

The High Court first dealt with authority. The transfer orders were signed by the Senior General Manager (HR). The Industrial Court held he was not shown to be authorised to transfer workmen across India.

Justice Marne noted that the complaint raised the point only vaguely, in a single paragraph, and held the finding could not stand.

The second ground was Section 9A of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. It bars an employer from changing conditions of service listed in the Fourth Schedule without 21 days’ notice. The Industrial Court had found a breach under Items 7, 9 and 11, which cover grades, rules of discipline and the number of persons employed.

Justice Marne held those findings speculative. Nothing showed that a worker’s grade or discipline rules would change at the new place. Item 11, he said, concerns a change in numbers within a department or shift, not retrenchment.

Transfer liability was also part of the appointment letter. Clause 14 allowed transfer to any establishment in India. Bosch had told the Industrial Court there would be no change in service conditions, and the orders said wages would be protected.

When transfer is a condition of service, the judge held, a transfer does not by itself change that condition and call for a Section 9A notice. He relied on Gulf Air Bombay, decided by the same court.

The third ground was Certified Standing Order 32, which the union said confined outstation transfers to setters, tool makers and maintenance mechanics. Bosch relied on Standing Order 33, which says nothing in the standing orders prejudices rights under a contract of service.

The judge held the case covered by two Supreme Court decisions, Management of CIPLA Ltd v. Jayakumar R and Divgi Metal Wares Ltd. In both, a contract allowing transfer anywhere prevailed over a narrower standing order.

The finding of breach of Standing Order 32 was set aside.

Where malice in law came in

The Industrial Court had found no personal bias against anyone, and found malice in law instead. The High Court applied the twin tests in Rajneesh Khajuria v. Wockhardt Ltd.

Those tests are personal bias or oblique motive, and action contrary to the objects and conditions of a valid exercise of administrative power.

The judge accepted that transfers are ordinarily a legitimate way of rearranging a workforce. Some flexibility must be given to an employer whose workload falls at one plant and rises at another. That was not what happened here, he held.

The transfers were not routine administrative moves. Bosch’s own case was that there was no work at Nashik, so the only reason for moving more than 500 workers on a single day was to avoid paying them there.

He listed the circumstances that pointed to the absence of good faith. Bosch had used its aftermarket divisions to scatter the workers at about 100 locations. None was posted in Maharashtra, though the state possibly has the highest number of registered vehicles in the country.

The orders came within days of the recall. The workers had five days to report, and the orders did not name the exact workplace. There was no material that the divisions had asked for manpower.

The union representative’s order was the example the judge returned to. The Aizawl order asked him to report at a co-working office in Guwahati for induction, not for work. Justice Marne said the union leader was sent to a far-off place to inconvenience him most.

A tool found after Red-Light failed

Justice Marne traced a sequence. Bosch first tried to keep workers out through Red-Light Activation. When that was stayed up to the Supreme Court and it had to pay wages, it came up with transfers.

He accepted that Bosch handed out travel tickets and hotel bookings, and that the Industrial Court had not fully accepted the theory of fictitious locations. Even assuming some work existed at the new places, he held, the pattern showed a purpose.

He wrote that the aim appeared to be to divide the workers so that they did not unite against a large employer. They were temporary workers on modest wages who could not work at such distances and would be dismissed for not reporting.

“Ought to have been retrenched by following the process of law” (para 76)

Bosch, he said, ought to have retrenched the surplus workers lawfully or taken another lawful route. A large organisation was expected to act as a model employer.

“The vice of malice in law is clearly established in the present case” (para 80)

Work at Nashik, and the numbers

The reduction in production was disputed. Bosch filed a summary of SAP data running to over 10,000 pages, which it said showed a 57 per cent fall in injector output and 17 per cent in nozzles.

The union argued that permanent workmen fell from 1,528 to 913 between 2016-17 and 2024-25 while output per workman rose from 5,850 units to 20,258. It also pointed to the company’s own chartered accountant’s turnover figures.

Justice Marne did not decide that dispute. He said he would assume the fall in orders was real, partly because the Industrial Court itself had found no proof that NETW work went to contract labour, apprentices or other workers.

Even so, he held, a fall in work called for lawful retrenchment, not scattering workers to the far corners of the country.

Compensation instead of reinstatement

The judge asked whether the workers should be sent back to Nashik. He found them surplus there. Setting aside the transfers would mean Bosch had to retrench them by the statutory route, which would start another round of litigation after two visits to the Supreme Court.

He chose to end the dispute with a lumpsum. Settlement talks during the hearing had failed. Bosch showed willingness to go up to Rs 18 lakh, and the union said an unofficial offer of Rs 35 lakh had been made.

Mr Singh said Rs 18 lakh each would put a burden of Rs 150 crore on Bosch. The judge noted Bosch’s turnover of Rs 7,700 crore in 2024-25, admitted by its own chartered accountant.

He also weighed what the workers had already received: Rs 3.5 lakh to 128 of them and about Rs 8.5 lakh to 470. They had been out of continuous service since Red-Light Activation began in 2021.

Because the transfers were unlawful, wages would otherwise be due from 7 September 2024, along with retrenchment compensation and statutory dues. Rs 25 lakh, he held, balanced the equities.

Order

The High Court partly set aside and modified the Industrial Court’s judgment of 29 September 2026. The directions at serial numbers 1 to 4 were upheld. The direction to let the transferred workmen join at Nashik was set aside.

Bosch must pay each NETW covered by Complaint (ULP) No. 46 of 2024 a lumpsum of Rs 25 lakh within six weeks. If it does not, the amount carries interest at 8 per cent a year from the end of the six weeks.

The workers cannot claim any other financial or service benefit from Bosch beyond this sum. No order as to costs was made.

After pronouncement, the union asked for a four-week stay of the judgment. Justice Marne refused, noting that Bosch was being directed to pay compensation.