Chief Justice M.C. Tripathi Justice A.M. Sethna Bombay HC PETITIONS DISMISSED A BMC demolition notice for anAndheri estate stands
[ Bombay High Court ]

Bombay HC backs demolition of 50-year-old Andheri estate after five audits split three ways

A Division Bench held the Technical Advisory Committee had weighed every report, including one from an engineer the tenants hired, before accepting a college audit that called the units C-1. The court said a rival report does not by itself invalidate the committee finding.

Five engineers inspected the same single-storey industrial estate in Andheri East and returned three different verdicts: demolish now, repair heavily, or repair lightly. On 18 November the Bombay High Court held that the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation’s expert committee was entitled to pick the verdict of a college of engineering, and dismissed three tenants’ petitions.

A Division Bench of Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi and Justice Advait M. Sethna upheld a notice to evacuate and demolish the estate, known as “Krishna Dyeing and Printing Works”. Chief Justice Tripathi wrote the judgment.

Six units, five audit reports

The building, with units 16 to 21, stands on Old Nagardas Road in Andheri East. The three petitioners, Nilay Colour Industries, Dharmesh Book Manufacturing and Super Plast, are tenants or occupiers. The lead case is Writ Petition 21242 of 2026.

The BMC’s K/East Ward issued a notice on 24 September 2024 under Section 353B of the Mumbai Municipal Corporation Act, 1888. The owner, Abrol Enterprises, replied on 26 March 2025 with an audit by Avon Consulting Engineers classing the building C-1, meaning to be evacuated and demolished immediately.

Tenants then filed reports of their own. Aarch Consultants put units 16, 20 and 21 in C-3, which needs only minor repairs, and Tech-Resurgo put units 17 to 19 in C-2A, which needs major repairs and possibly partial demolition.

Because each report covered only some units, the ward asked on 3 May 2025 for an audit of the whole structure. Avon’s audit of 7 July 2025 again said C-1, and on 25 August 2025 the ward referred the conflict to the Technical Advisory Committee.

A third-party audit by a college

On 29 October 2025 the committee decided that an independent audit should be done by a BMC-empanelled consultant or by an institution such as VJTI, IIT or Sardar Patel College of Engineering. The BMC says 14 consultants and the college agreed to take it up.

The owner chose the college, which reported on 18 December 2025 that the estate was C-1. The tenants had their own report that day from B.J. Mehta Architectural and Structural Consultants, which said C-2A.

The committee inspected the site on 17 February 2026 and met the same evening, with engineers from all five firms present. Its order of 20 May 2026 accepted the college’s report, and the ward issued a notice under Section 354 on 29 May 2026.

What the tenants argued

Mr Anoshak Davar, for the tenants, said they never got the college’s report before the order. They had applied for a certified copy on 20 February 2026, he said, and so could not object to it.

He said the committee gave no reason for rejecting the Mehta report, and that three of five audits called the building repairable. The tenants, he said, were ready to do the repairs at their own cost.

He called the order non-speaking, and argued that the authorities failed to separate parts of the building that could be made safe. He also said the action ran against the BMC’s policy guidelines of 25 May 2018.

What the BMC and the owner said

Ms Shweta Patankar, for the BMC, said four contrary reports had come in before the committee visited the site, with notice to the parties, on 7 October 2025. It is an expert body drawn from the Corporation, she said, and there is little scope to dispute its findings.

Mr Sanjeev Singh, for the owner, said the committee decided on site inspections and all the reports. Demolition, he said, does not end the tenancy, since Section 354(5) of the Act and the Maharashtra Rent Control Act, 1999 protect tenants.

The respondents relied on the Supreme Court’s ruling in Shaha Ratanshi Khimji and Sons v. Kumbhar Sons Hotel, (2014) 14 SCC 1, and a Bombay ruling in Khimjibhai Harjivanbhai Patadia.

The order that listened to all five

The Chief Justice rejected the natural justice complaint. The committee’s order, he said, records the reports of all five consultants and the observations of an eight-member meeting that included the tenants’ engineer.

It had noted the college’s findings of cracked pillars, corroded and broken reinforcement, and tree roots in the walls and structure. It also noted the Mehta report’s cracks, spalled concrete and poor test results, and still found the estate to be C-1 and not C-2A.

The bench therefore held that the committee considered the matter holistically and gave reasoned findings. It was not persuaded that natural justice had been violated.

Why courts defer to the committee

The judgment traced the committee to an order of 23 June 2014 in Municipal Corporation of Greater Mumbai v. State of Maharashtra, where a Coordinate Bench set guidelines for conflicting audit reports. The BMC finalised them in 2018.

Later rulings, including Vivek Shantaram Kokate and Khimjibhai Harjivanbhai Patadia, said that Article 226 is not a tool

“to substitute their own views for technical/fact finding assessments made by the TAC” (para 42)

The bench said that holds unless gross perversity, fraud or complete non-application of mind is shown. It cited Andheri Purab Paschim Cooperative Housing Society, which called the committee a check against unilateral declarations of buildings as dilapidated.

The bench also extracted principles from that ruling. A writ court does not prefer one expert over another, and a rival report does not by itself invalidate a committee’s report.

Order

The bench found no fraud, gross perversity or non-application of mind, and said it would not adopt the approach of always preferring a report that recommends repairs. The order of 20 May 2026 and the notice of 29 May 2026 stand.

The writ petitions are dismissed, the rule is discharged and there is no order as to costs.