Justice M.N. Jadhav Bombay HC FIR QUASHED Cheating case against Rahejafirm quashed
[ Bombay High Court ]

Bombay HC quashes Raheja firm cheating FIR: complainant knew of the 2008 deal for 18 years

Justice Milind Jadhav held that New Era Advisor bought its debt in 2009 as is where is after its own due diligence, and that the EOW case followed its ranking as Other Creditor in the Unimers insolvency.

A registered agreement of 2008 to buy a factory plot in Thane became the basis of a cheating case in 2026. The Bombay High Court quashed that case against the buyer on 18 November, saying the complaint followed a creditor ranking the complainant disliked, not the discovery of an offence.

Justice Milind N. Jadhav allowed the writ petition of Raheja District III Private Limited and its director, who were the fifth and sixth accused in an Economic Offences Wing case. The complainant, New Era Advisor Pvt Ltd, had bought the debt of the plot’s owner a year after the agreement was signed.

A plot, a loan and two buyers

The plot belongs to Unimers India Ltd, which had borrowed from the financial institution IFCI to set up a chemical plant. It covers 1,52,419 square metres in Thane district and is held on lease from MIDC.

On 14 May 2008 Unimers signed an agreement for assignment with Raheja District III, registered on 14 August 2008. The price was Rs 184.29 crore, and Unimers took Rs 29,62,50,000 upfront.

In 2009 New Era bought IFCI’s loan for Rs 95,49,50,000 by a Deed of Assignment dated 1 October 2009. The FIR put Unimers’ dues at Rs 86.55 crore as on 1 July 2008.

From a complaint to a case in 2026

New Era filed a complaint with the EOW on 2 April 2026. It said its director had visited the site in February 2026 and found no trace of Unimers, no plant and no machinery.

A preliminary inquiry ran for four months. The petitioners gave the EOW documents on pending civil suits and the insolvency proceedings, and the EOW registered CR 78 of 2026 on 11 August 2026, arising out of FIR 1180 of 2026 at Oshiwara police station.

The offences invoked were Sections 318(1), 318(4) and 3(5) of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. The first four accused are Unimers and three people linked to it: J.P. Goenka, Vardhan Goenka and Satya Prakash Gupta.

The insolvency behind the criminal case

The NCLT admitted a company petition against Unimers by an order of 18 November 2022, starting insolvency and a moratorium. The resolution professional admitted Raheja District III as a secured financial creditor for about Rs 1,257 crore, which gave it 86.41 per cent of the committee of creditors.

New Era had lodged a secured financial creditor claim of about Rs 3,466 crore. The professional admitted only Rs 218.62 crore, under the head Other Creditor, and kept it off the committee. New Era has two applications pending before the NCLT to set aside Raheja’s claim and remove the professional.

What Raheja and its director argued

Mr Aabad Ponda, Senior Advocate for the petitioners, said New Era suppressed the NCLT and civil proceedings it was itself pursuing. He called the FIR a reaction to the Other Creditor ranking and said it did not explain a delay of 18 years.

On cheating, he argued that the FIR alleged no promise, representation or inducement by the petitioners to New Era. New Era, he said, claimed to have done its own legal due diligence before buying IFCI’s debt.

He added that Section 318(4) could not apply to a transaction that pre-dated the new code. Even under Section 420 of the old Penal Code, he said, no ingredient was attributable to his clients.

The agreement for assignment, Mr Ponda said, is not an assignment. It depended on Unimers settling debenture holders, getting a 2002 injunction vacated and withdrawing the 2002 suit, and the final deed was never executed or registered.

He relied on a list of decisions, among them Delhi Race Club (1940) Ltd v State of UP (2024 10 SCC 690), on deception as the foundation of cheating. The judgment does not discuss them.

What New Era and the State said

Mr Manoj Mohite, Senior Advocate for New Era, relied on an order of 29 March 2004 in a suit by ICICI Bank. It restrained Unimers from disposing of or creating third-party rights over its mortgaged assets, and he said the 2008 agreement defied it.

He said the Rs 29.62 crore went to Unimers’ unsecured loans and to refund promoters’ share capital, not to secured creditors. He alleged that the professional had colluded with the accused in ranking New Era as Other Creditor, and called that the core of the conspiracy.

On delay, Mr Mohite said New Era learnt in February 2026 that the guards at the Thane plot had been engaged by the petitioners, whose properties adjoin it. He said the two triggers were recent: the ranking of November 2025 and the missing movables found in February 2026.

He also argued that knowing of the agreement since 2008 was irrelevant. Mr Prakash Selot, he said, had pleaded it in the earlier company petition as a minority shareholder, and New Era’s knowledge was a matter of inference.

The State, through an affidavit of Police Inspector Juberahmed Mujawar of the EOW dated 7 October 2026, opposed the petition. Ms Shilpa G. Talhar, Additional Public Prosecutor, appeared for it.

The charge missing from the FIR

Justice Jadhav first looked at what the FIR said. The main grievance, he noted, was the disposal of Unimers’ movable assets and the Other Creditor ranking, and neither was in the FIR. Mr Mohite accepted this and said the charge was in the 2 April complaint.

The judge found a gap between the FIR and New Era’s reply affidavit. The statement of the complainant had, he said, “not a whisper” of the grievance over classification of its claim, though the affidavit alleged collusion with the professional.

The judge declined to accept charges of dishonesty, diversion, fabrication of records and conspiracy with no factual basis against the petitioners. Save for a bald assertion of conspiracy, he said, every submission of Mr Mohite was aimed at Unimers and its conduct, not at the petitioners.

He added that New Era’s own reply affidavit said its real grievance was against Unimers and its promoters. If so, he asked, why implicate the petitioners?

On the movables, the State’s own affidavit blamed Unimers alone. It attributed no role to the petitioners, the judge said, and was silent on the material placed before the EOW during the preliminary inquiry.

Eighteen years of knowledge

The judge held that New Era knew of the agreement long before 2026. In its 2009 Deed of Assignment it had confirmed that it took IFCI’s rights as is where is and as is what is, after its own due diligence.

Prakash Selot, who became a director of New Era on 15 September 2011, had pleaded the agreement in a 2008 company petition. He also verified New Era’s written statement of 12 February 2016, which acknowledged it.

An order of 7 December 2018 of a Delhi court also recorded the agreement as pleaded by New Era. On that timeline, the judge said, there was a delay of 18 years on the face of the record.

He also found that New Era’s case had improved at each stage: the EOW complaint of 2 April 2026, the four-month inquiry, the FIR of 11 August 2026 and the reply affidavit.

He concluded that the real reason for the case was not the agreement but the later ranking of New Era as Other Creditor. The complaint was, he said, a “counterblast” to it (para 22).

No deception, no inducement, no title

Justice Jadhav read the agreement as one with reciprocal obligations. Its clause 4 made completion subject to Unimers clearing the debenture holders, vacating the injunction and withdrawing the 2002 suit.

The price went through an HDFC Bank escrow account in stages. Only the first two instalments were paid. The third, tied to dismantling and removing the factory, was not.

The conditions in clause 6(a) were never met, the judge found. No Deed of Assignment was executed, MIDC never consented, and Raheja District III holds no title to the land. What it holds is a claim as a creditor for Rs 29.62 crore.

He said what Unimers did with the escrow money was within its own control. That was the subject of the allegations against the first four accused, so the indictment of the petitioners was, as he put it, not understood at all.

On cheating, he found no false representation. When the agreement was registered, New Era was not in the picture. The court held:

“a party entering subsequently cannot claim to have been induced” (para 25)

The judge added that no promise, representation or correspondence between the petitioners and New Era was alleged, and no individual role was attributed to either of them. New Era had itself conceded the absence of direct representation and inducement.

A dispute between creditors

The judge held that the agreement was conditional and never fructified. The case, he said, was at bottom an inter-creditor, civil and commercial dispute, which could not qualify as a criminal offence.

He called the preliminary inquiry an eyewash. Where an inquiry under Section 35(3) of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita was needed, he noted, the prosecution had issued a witness summons under Section 179.

He held the FIR a vexatious and malicious attempt to pressure the petitioners, the directors of Raheja District III and the resolution professionals. Registering it without the main offence in the FIR amounted to an abuse of process.

The judge also left New Era’s grievance against Unimers and the first four accused untouched. That, he said, was not before the court.

Order

The writ petition is allowed in terms of prayer clause (A). CR 78 of 2026 dated 11 August 2026, registered by the EOW, Housing Unit, arising out of FIR 1180 of 2026 of Oshiwara police station, is quashed against the petitioners along with all consequent proceedings.

The petition was filed under Article 226 of the Constitution read with Section 528 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita. Interim Application 3544 of 2026, filed by New Era Advisor Pvt Ltd, is disposed of.