Justice M.N. Jadhav Bombay HC CASE QUASHED PMLA complaint quashed for wantof sanction
[ Bombay High Court ]

Bombay HC quashes ED money laundering case against customs officer after ED admits no sanction

Justice Milind Jadhav held that a Joint Commissioner of Customs accused of amassing disproportionate assets needed prior sanction under Section 197 of the CrPC, and that the missing sanction went to the root of the PMLA complaint.

The Enforcement Directorate filed a money laundering complaint against a Joint Commissioner of Customs, and a Special Court took cognizance of it on 31 August 2023. The Central Government had not sanctioned his prosecution. On 18 November the Bombay High Court quashed the complaint and the cognizance order.

Justice Milind N. Jadhav held that Section 197(1)(a) of the Code of Criminal Procedure required prior sanction for a public servant accused of amassing assets beyond his income. He called the missing sanction a defect that cannot be cured.

Rs 2.45 crore and a layered trail

The petitioner, Sachin Sawant, is an Indian Revenue Service officer of the 2008 batch. He was Joint Commissioner of Customs during the period the prosecution examined.

The CBI's anti-corruption branch in Mumbai received information that between 12 January 2011 and 31 August 2020 he amassed assets, in his own name and his family's, and incurred expenditure of Rs 2,45,78,579. The prosecution says this was disproportionate to his lawful income.

The Enforcement Directorate alleged that he layered the money through bank accounts of companies controlled by a close friend. It was then moved into family accounts as monthly salary, the complaint says.

He and his father also took property loans, gold loans, agricultural loans and unsecured loans, the prosecution alleges. Almost all repayments were made by depositing cash and transferring it to the loan accounts, which the ED treats as the generation of proceeds of crime.

Two cases, one still open

The CBI registered a first information report against Mr Sawant under Sections 13(2) read with 13(1)(b) and 13(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, and Section 109 of the Indian Penal Code. The court recorded that he was never arrested in that case.

No final report had been filed in that predicate case, the judgment notes, and the CBI was still investigating. The ED had meanwhile registered its own case on 13 December 2022 under Sections 3 and 4 of the Prevention of Money Laundering Act, 2002.

The ED arrested him on 27 June 2023. The High Court granted him bail on 9 October 2024, and he was released the next day.

The Central Government suspended him by an order of 17 August 2023, effective from 27 June 2023. The suspension has been extended from time to time and runs until 27 December 2026.

The challenge to cognizance

The Special Court under the PMLA at Greater Bombay took cognizance of the ED complaint on 31 August 2023, in PMLA Special Case No. 1282 of 2023. Mr Sawant moved the High Court under Article 227 of the Constitution.

His case was short. He was a public servant who could be removed from office only with the Central Government's sanction. The ED therefore had to obtain prior sanction under Section 197(1) of the CrPC before filing its complaint.

Mr Mithilesh Mishra, his advocate, called the order taking cognizance illegal and said the defect went to the root of the proceedings. He relied on the Supreme Court's decisions in Directorate of Enforcement v Bibhu Prasad Acharya ((2025) 1 SCC 404) and P K Pradhan v State of Sikkim ((2001) 6 SCC 704).

He also argued that the case had made no meaningful progress because of the absence of sanction and other legal infirmities.

ED: sanction covers only official acts

Mr Prashant Mishra, Special Counsel for the ED, did not dispute that the petitioner was a Central Government servant. His position was that sanction under Section 197(1)(a) is needed only where the alleged act was done in the course of day-to-day official duty.

He said the ED's case concerned the acquisition, possession, concealment, layering, use and projection of proceeds of crime. None of that, he argued, was a governmental decision, statutory order or administrative act done in discharge of an official function.

Holding public office, he said, merely gave the petitioner the occasion or opportunity. He cited P K Pradhan for that and said Bibhu Prasad Acharya was different because the allegations there concerned allotment of land and water, which were official functions.

He also relied on two High Court decisions, Pooja Singhal v Directorate of Enforcement (2025 SCC OnLine Jhar 3961) and Vanimisetty Gopala Reddy v Union of India (2026 SCC OnLine TS 2694). Ms Anuja Gotad, the Additional Public Prosecutor for the State, adopted his submissions and called the alleged acts personal ones.

The ED's own papers settle sanction

Justice Jadhav first examined whether sanction existed. The ED's affidavit said sanction had been granted by Sanction Order No. 03/2026 on 18 March 2026, and that the CBI filed a chargesheet on 30 March 2026.

The court found that neither that sanction order nor the chargesheet was annexed. What was annexed was a 22 June 2026 order of the Central Board of Indirect Taxes and Customs on extending the suspension.

That order recorded that sanction sought by a letter of 6 February 2022 was still under examination. From this the court concluded that the ED had accepted that no sanction had been received for prosecuting the petitioner.

It then recorded that the ED had admitted that cognizance was taken without valid sanction from the competent authority. The ED's defence was only that none was needed.

Wealth outside official duty, unexplained

On that defence, the judge said the ED had not explained a basic point. The court observed that how the petitioner amassed the wealth outside the purview of his official duties was:

“neither explained nor even stated” (para 12)

He also noted that the Special Court had passed its order without checking whether sanction had been obtained. Section 197(1), which corresponds to Section 218 of the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023, applies to a public servant of the Central or State Government accused of an offence committed while acting or purporting to act in discharge of official duty.

Two conditions and the Supreme Court

The court read Section 197(1) as resting on two conditions. The accused must be a public servant not removable from office save by or with the government's sanction, and the offence must have been committed while acting or purporting to act in discharge of duty.

It treated the first as admitted. On the second, it said the charge was one of amassing wealth, disproportionate to his legal sources of income, while discharging his duty, and the same charge was levelled against his near relatives.

Justice Jadhav relied on Bibhu Prasad Acharya for the proposition that non-compliance with Section 197 is by itself enough to invalidate cognizance by a Special Court. He noted that the ED had finished its investigation and filed its complaint under Section 44(1)(b) of the PMLA although the CBI's investigation into the predicate offence had not concluded.

He reproduced paragraphs 5 and 15 of P K Pradhan. Those paragraphs describe the sanction requirement as a bar on the court's jurisdiction and ask whether there is a reasonable connection between the act and official duty.

The judge found it necessary for the Special Court to ensure that prior sanction was obtained before taking cognizance. In his view the case therefore clearly required prior sanction, which he described as:

“sine qua non for institution of and taking cognizance of the complaint” (para 16)

He then held that the want of sanction was not curable. The defect, he said, goes to the root of the proceedings, which he called the foundational jurisdictional issue, and makes all later steps in the prosecution legally unsustainable.

The judgment does not discuss the two High Court decisions the ED cited.

Order

The writ petition is allowed in terms of prayer clauses (a) and (b). The order of 31 August 2023 taking cognizance of the complaint and issuing process against the petitioner in PMLA Special Case No. 1282 of 2023, arising from ECIR/MBZO-I/69/2022, is quashed and set aside.

The complaint itself, filed by the ED for offences under Sections 3 and 4 of the PMLA, is also quashed. The judgment is silent on whether the ED may proceed afresh, and it makes no order on costs.